Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The USSR is not socialist!

Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s, 28 June 1988 · scan pp. 21–22 · about 1,279 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 21 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 21

By Since the late 1940s it has been clear to me that the Soviet Union wasn't the socialist millennium at all. The workers there have been as bureaucratically controlled — and more so, in some respects — as in capitalist Britain.

Therefore a fundamental change is necessary in the Soviet Union, and the fight for such a change is as important as in this country.

Even if there are no capitalist moguls in the Soviet Union, there are state bureaucrats who manipulate society and have developed into something like a new class. The USSR is not socialist. It's not the sort of socialism that I believe in.

What about the economy based upon a type of public ownership? That should certainly not be destroyed. It should be defended. I want Gorbachev to develop democracy and democratic ideas and free discussion in the Soviet Union. But I have a feeling that there will be some forces there who want to destroy the socialised character of the economy in the Soviet Union - and that I am not in favour of.

One way to define it is to spell out what programme you think the workers in the Soviet Union should fight for. 1 think that what they have to fight for is • genuinely free and independent trade unions; • the right to have free publications, which can express their own points of view clearly; • the right to have political organisations, quite separate from the Communist Party; • the right to have free elections. I think the one whose views I come closest to is Luxemburg - in that sense I suppose I am a Luxemburgist. I really have got a great affinity with what Luxemburg said about the Soviet Union immediately after the Russian Revolution - total defence of the revolution, but at the same time enough understan ding to be critical of events.

These are all the things the workers have to fight for. I don't agree with the idea now of individual states hiving off. I think there has to be a genuine freedom in all these states, but it would be a tragic thing if some parts of Russia hived off as independent states, and suddenly became Islamic Fundamentalist or something of that kind. I think that would be retrogressive.

The important thing is for the workers to fight for free and independent trade unions, the right to have their own type of Solidarity', and the right for free political organisation, the right for freedom of speech, the right for free elections, and the right to have independent organisation.

Will the workers in the states get that peacefully?

bureaucrats surrender?

It depends, of course, on how strong they are, whether the army could be used against them. I don't know - maybe it would, maybe they can't get it peacefully, I don't know, but I do think they have to try. To judge by what has happened in various other countries where the military have ended up as the dietators it may well be that they couldn't get radical change in the USSR peacefulOne of the strangest things on the left is the double standards, where you have people who are right to get very excited about Chile, South Africa and so on, but who either sympathise with the rulers in the Eastern Bloc or are very reluctant to say anything against them even when they do things like the rulers of Chile and South Africa do - suppressing Solidarnosc, for example. It is one of the biggest areas of weakness on I think it is best understood as an historical question. The fact is that the revolutionary left in this country began as a left in support of the Russian Revolution. Therefore many on the left believe that anything that is said against the Soviet leadership, or the Soviet state, or the Soviet system is said by people who openly or secretly support capitalism. For decades they just did not believe the truth about Stalinism because, they said, it was all 'capitalist When I moved support for 'Solidarnosc in the National Executive Committee of the Labour Party, I was told by one of the trade union leaders that I was adopting a very wrong attitude because after all Solidarity was a 'breakaway union'.

I said: 'if you are talking about a breakaway union from a democratic union there might be an argument, but these are not democratic unions in Poland, they are state unions. They are organs of the state, so you are not talking about the same thing'. But I did get that resolution through.

The trouble is that there has only ever been a handful of people on the left -and I'm talking about the genuine left -in this country who stood up and said that Solidarity should be supported.

When they argue that the Catholic Church influences Solidarity, I point out that all the same arguments apply to Ireland. The fact is that priests in the struggle - not all of them, not the hierarchy in the main, but lots of them — have, like the Catholic workers, been active in the struggle for freedom and independence for Ireland. James Connolly remained a Catholic until the day he died, because it was part of a mass movement of the workers. But the role of Catholicism in the Polish labour movement confuses people who should know better.

When there should be an angry outcry from the left in protest at oppression in the USSR and Eastern Europe you normally, at best, get silence. And that's wrong.

This is a very big issue. I think we have to get pamphlets out on it. I have issued a statement on it as part of my campaign for the Deputy Leadership, in which I accused Mrs Thatcher of being a lying hypocrite when she says she favours Solidarity, because she deprives workers here of free and independent trade unions.

I said that Thatcher speaks with two voices. She certainly does, but the British labour movement should not speak with two voices. We have to speak with one clear voice and according to one simple standard in support of the right of workers everywhere to organise trade unions free of any state control.

The terrible double standards with which some on the left view the USSR also showed in their attitude to the USSR's invasion of Afghanistan. You had a mass movement in protest at America's bloody war in Vietnam, and rightly so, but bored disinterest in the USSR's war against the peoples of I was one of the few left wing Members of Parliament who protested very strongly when the Soviet Union marched into Afghanistan. The best thing that Gorbachev has done up to now has been to start to withdraw from Afghanistan. It really was no different from Vietnam. We have to be honest about it — we can't go on having those double standards.

I know that is very much a minority view on the left, very much so. People feel that if you make a stand you are siding with right wing reactionaries. But you can make your socialist stand against oppression by 'left wing' regimes and at the same time distinguish yourself clearly from the right wing by putting questions and policies to them that they cannot possibly accept. You can show them as hypocrites because of it. It depends on how you do it.

We have to convince people that there is a separate view, a working class view - that you do not have to side with either the hypeanerate or with Thatshon

Scan page 22

Arguments: New Realism ani

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →