What we What went wrong in Russia?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 20 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 20
Be want socialism. We want the complete overthrow of capitalism. Yet everywhere that revolutions calling themselves socialist have been made - the USSR, China, Vietnam, Cuba - today there are systems very far from the workers' liberty we want. What went wrong? How can we do better?
The Russian Revolution of 1917 was a genuine socialist revolution. It put the economy and society of Russia under the control of democratic workers' councils (called 'soviets').
But the Bolsheviks who made the revolution did not believe that socialism could be built in one country alone, least of all in backward Russia. They saw their revolution as the first step in an international workers' revolution.
After World War 1 there were workers' revolutions in many countries of. Europe. But they were defeated -because in those countries there were no clear-headed, cohesive revolutionary parties like the Bolsheviks. The Russian workers' revolution was isolated. And worse: it was beset by civil war, attacked by Russian counter-revolutionaries and invaded by the armies of 14 capitalist states.
By the end of the civil war in 1921 the Bolshevik Party was in control of a state devastated by war and isolated by the defeat and ebb of working class revolution in Europe. The opposition parties had mostly gone over to the counterrevolution, and were all banned. Like industry, the working class had been decimated by war. Famine and disease stalked Russia.
Many workers returned to their peasant roots in the countryside. There at least they could eat.
The system of War Communism' rested on forced expropriation of grain from the peasants. With the end of the civil war it began to break down. Trotsky and Lenin realised that in order to
stimulate the economy
to make concessions to private trade and farming.
The effect of this was to strengthen the merchants and rich peasants (kulaks) at the expense of the working class and poorer peasantry. With the dispersal of the working class, the soviets had been seriously weakened as organs of democracy, and it was to a large extent the 'Old Guard' of the Bolsheviks who ran the state apparatus.
These Bolshviks partly depended on the bureaucracy they had inherited from Tsarism.
Gradually Bolsheviks became bureaucrats and the bureaucrats, balancing between the middle class and the workers, became more powerful.
Before his death, Lenin began a struggle against the bureaucracy. Trotsky took up this struggle from 1923. But as the revolution ebbed, the bureaucrats won out.
The bureaucracy was increasingly differentiating itself from the working class. Military officials, technicians, party functionaries and managers were gradually becoming an independent social layer rising above the working class, and defending their own material privileges. Stalin's doctrine of 'Socialism in One Country meant that the Communist International was being transformed into an instrument of Russia's domestic policy.
Once the opposition was firmly routed and Trotsky was sent into exile, Stalin took a sharp turn seemingly to the left, adopting much of the Opposition's platform but in a brutish form. He announced the elimination of the kulaks as a class and embarked on forced collectivisation of the farms. He also announced the first Five Year Plan with a crash programme of industrialisation.
The Stalinist bureaucracy fell out with the NEP bourgeoisie, with whom they had allied against the working class. As Trotsky would later put it, the bureaucracy fought the NEP bourgeoisie to decide which of them, bureaucracy or bourgeoisie, would have control of the wealth of society. The bureaucracy won, emerging as the soie master of Russian society. support. They took place in countries where the capitalist class was weak, disorganised, and corrupt, and where the working class was also weak and illorganised. When the Chinese revolutionaries entered the cities in 1949, they told the workers to stay at work and obey their managers - and then they proceeded to build a system of tight state control over the working class. These post-war revolutions took as their model not the workers' democracy of 1917, but the bureaucratic police state built by Stalin.
The struggles of Solidarnose in Poland showed vividly that working-class socialism cannot be identified with the Stalinist systems, but is mortally hostile to them.
The Solidarnose programme demanded:
*Workers' self-management in the factories: managers to be subject to recall by elected worker's councils.
*Opening the books of bureaucrats' economic planning.
*'A reform that will abolish privileges of the bureaucracy' *Wages and social benefits to be protected against inflation by escalator clauses.
*Trade union inspection of health and safety at work.
*The right to work for all.
*Expansion of creches and nurseries. Extended maternity leave, with job security.
*Longer holidays and a five week (instead of six days).
*Free elections, civil liberties, and abolition of secrecy in public life' * Access to the media; 'the allocation of paper, printing facilities, and broadcasting time must be subject to social *Free trade unions and the right to strike.
The confusions and hesitations among the Solidarnosc leadership are secondary. In the fight for such demands, the socialist side was Solidarnosc's not the Battered by fascism and Stalinism, and then lulled by the big post-war expansion of capitalism, the working class has not yet been able to recreate mass revolutionary parties. But struggles like those in Poland in 1980-81 or in France in 1968, show that the working class still has the potential to create a new society. Indeed, world-wide the working class is far stronger and more numerous today than ever before.
Scan page 21
Page