Is socialism possible?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 19 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 19
Socialism, workers' liberty, a society as different from the Eastern bloc as it is from Western capitalism -it may be a good idea. But is it realistic? Can we ever win that sort of socialism, or is it best to settle for the sort of half-measure that the Policy Review pri poses? Mark Osborn discusses the issues.
want to tell you about a woman who was 35 years old at the begining of 1968. Her name is Marie and she lives in a village outside Nantes, France. Marie gets up at 4.30 every day and goes to work by bus. In 1968 the bus was rickety and took an hour to take her to town - Where she got off, walked through the back doors of the office block and helped to clean the fourth floor.
Marie disliked the Communists and thought that De Gaulle was bearable. She said that the North African immigrants she worked with smelled bad and were stupid.
Marie took the shopping back home, cleaned the house, and cooked for her husband.
There's a problem summed up. Socialists say that the way out of waste ignorance, war and poverty is for the working class — the vast majority in the major capitalist countries - to take power from the capitalist class and run society in their interests.
To do this the working class must become an organised collective force, aware of its own power and its own interests. The trouble is that it is not. Most of the time, most workers like Marie, accept their lot. Everyday life, tells them that capitalism is the natural way to organise the world. They take out their discontent not on the bosses but on other workers.
After all, capitalism had allowed some improvements. Marie's mother used to wash all the family's clothes by hand and use an outside toilet, and Marie was better off. Besides, Marie was too exhausted at the end of each day to think too closely about the world - let alone do anything to change it.
It is comparatively easy for the capitalists to be a ruling class. They have education, leisure, a clear sense of their own interests and a powerful network of institutions and connections binding them together as a class. But how can exhausted, downtrodden workers, bombarded with prejudices and lacking opportunities to learn come to clearly see their place in the world as part of a revolutionary class? Or will better-off workers always see their interest in getting what they can out of the system, and will worse-oft workers always be helpless objects for charity and welfare?
These questions were answered in practice in France in May 1968. People who had written the workers off were eating their words by June.
The spark of student action lit a huge fire of discontent as French workers struck in the biggest strike ever. Office workers, joined factory workers and black joined white, as workers proved to themselves that they could unite to change society. Millions of people like Marie, who previously had not even joined trade unions, came on to the stage as players in world politics.
In the heat of the action and influenced by a small group of revolutionaries, the workers in Nantes formed their own Central Strike Committee or Workers' Council. Marie was a delegate from her workplace — for a week or so she helped to run the town. She helped to organise the distribution of food, the schooling of children and the control of traffic. For a week Marie was a revolutionary.
Alongside all the conservative ideas in Marie's head there had always been rs do have the do ability to chan ge sor ciet In times a f up heaval thi creativity com the fore' some different ideas. She believed that workers should have democratic control in their workplaces, and should get a better deal. She thought that unemployment shouldn't be allowed. She thought that every working class family had a right to a decent life, and that this was more important than making profits for the rich.
Suddenly she found that she could do something about it! Indeed she, and the workers of Nantes, had to do something about it. They saw that they had the power to stop society by their general strike; and they had the power to restore society by organising themselves in workers' councils.
We can see the same transformation of workers' outlook even in some small strikes. We could see it on a bigger scale in the miners' strike of 1984-5. In France in 1968 it happened on a bigger scale again.
A strike is not just a consciousnessraising session, it is a struggle. If you lose, then the defeatism which crippled you before the strike may cripple you again.
The same is true of general strikes.
A matter of weeks later Marie voted for De Gaulle in the election that was movement back on to solid bourgeois ground.
Marie voted for De Gaulle because she was demoralised after the ebb of the strike movement. De Gaulle promised to make reforms and restore order. So she voted for him.
In 1968 Nantes was unusual. Revolutionaries had more of a base than elsewhere, where the bureaucratic and conservative Communist Party kept control and fobbed workers off with half-measures.
But the story shows three things.
One: that workers do have the ability to change society. In times of upheaval, the creativity which is usually buried under a dead weight of inertia comes to the fore. Workers' ability to organise, to control, to plan - an ability which capitalism develops but at the same time restricts — flowers. France 1968 was not unique. The same working class creativity has been shown in Poland in 1980-81, in Portugal in 1974-5, in Hungary in 1956, and in many other times and places.
Two: that democracy for the working class is not just a matter of parliamentary elections. Workers can organise their own 'parliaments' ', like the Central Strike Committee in Nantes, with a more direct and flexible form of democracy than Westminster.
It is important to get socialists elected to Westminster. But if we did get a socialist majority in the House of Commons, that would only be the start of the story. That socialist majority would face obstruction and defiance from the House of Lords, the monarchy, the courts, and the top ranks of the civil service, the police and the army. The final weapon of the old ruling class - which it would certainly try to use rather than quietly go down to defeat - would be armed resistance, like Pinochet's coup against Allende in Chile in 1973.
We could defeat the obstruction, and reduce the armed resistance manageable size. In France in 1968, some police and troops refused to be used against the strikers.
But victory or defeat would not depend on votes in parliament. They would depend on how well workers were organised, and how boldly they acted, in the workplaces and the streets.
Three: that when the parties based on the working class cut down their aims in order not to clash so much with everyday conservative prejudices, then they fail to serve the workers.
Not only the French general strike of May 1968 showed this, but also the British miners' strike of 1984-5. The Labour leaders sat on the fence and refused to support the miners clearly and actively. That failure may have been decisive in weakening workers' confidence and solidarity, and letting the miners go down to defeat.
The struggles to stop the poll tax, to save the Health Service, and to scrap nuclear weapons raise the same problem today. We can win these struggles - but we need a labour movement that gives a lead, rather than always backpedalling to seem respectable.
Yes, we can win socialism - but we need to organise for it!
Scan page 20
Arguments: the Eastern Bloc it was necessary Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page nf Internationally the combined effect of the rise of Stalinism and the terrible convulsions of capitalism squeezed and decimated the Marxists. The millions of workers who had organised themselves into revolutionary Marxist parties were dispersed or channelled into utterly bureaucratic Stalinist parties which just served the Kremlin's foreign policy. Only the most stubborn and clear-headed Marxists around Trotsky, remained true to the ideals and ideas of 1917. They were isolated.
Against this background, revolutions took place in China, Yugoslavia, Vietnam and other countries under the leadership of Stalinist parties after World War 2. These were revolutions made by parties with middle class leaders and, usually, a mainly peasant base of