Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What is socialism?

Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s, 28 June 1988 · scan pp. 17–19 · Colin Foster · about 1,966 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 17 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 17

By The basic principle of socialism is 'from each according to ability; to each according to need'. Instead of the economic system basing itself on each individual competing with each other to make money, it will base itself on people cooperating to satisfy their needs.

Socialism is about planning - the conscious control by society over production and distribution. Capitalism is a chaotic system, subject to periodic crashes, recessions and slumps.

All ons elections to administrative and managerial positions for fixed, short peri ods. Rotation of responsibiliti cut against vested rests. Administrators managers will be paid no privileges te defend' Socialism will abolish the causes crashes and slumps.

To do this we will need public ownership of the commanding heights of the economy. But socialism will mean a quite different sort of public ownership to those we know today. It will not only be more extensive - which it must be to establish real control over the economy. It will also be organised differently.

Nationalised industry has rightly been criticised for being bureaucratic. But socialist planning will depend upon real democratic control by workers.

To make planning democratic, the process will have to be quite complicated. People in particular industries and localities will have to discuss and draw up proposals for planning targets. A balance will have to be found between local, national and international decisions.

Won't this make life an endless round of meetings? Won't it lead to decisions being dominated by the minority who can be bothered to sit through all those meetings? Even if that minority are to begin with only the most active and dedicated people, won't they in time become a bureaucracy with vested interests?

This is a real danger. But a done to avoid it.

At present what democracy we have is almost entirely to do with life outside work. Under socialism, democracy will be centrally about what is produced. A great part of democracy will be about the workplace and based in the workplace.

Meetings can be held in work time to maximise attendance. Each workplace group will be able to elect its own delegate, mandate him or her, get regular reports, and replace its delegate whenever it wishes. Socialist democracy will thus mean much more real control than any democratic procedure in society today.

Of course, some people be more active than others. Some speak in meetings and get chosen as delegates, and some will not. But there can be sufficient checks and balances to stop that unevenness solidifying into bureaucracy.

All elections to administrative and managerial positions will be for fixed, short periods. Rotation of responsibilities will cut against vested interests. Administrators and managers will be paid at workers' wages, so that they do not have privileges to defend.

Three things are necessary for this sort of democracy to work:

• that everyone has a decent standard of living, so that they are not preoccupied by the struggle to survive or the struggle to get a better job; • that the working week is short enough for every worker to have time and energy to take part in the democratic

Scan page 18

Arguments: what is socialism?

debates; • and that everyone high level of education.

Without these things, as Marx once put it, "all the old crap" will indeed revive. But those things are possible. Capitalism has generated the technology and the productive capacity that make them possible.

Socialism would not mean an end to debates and disputes. How should cities and housing estates be designed? What should replace the advertising hoardings? What forms of transport should we develop? Can we reclaim the deserts and develop them for human settlement?

Should we organise things so that eve the world at different times of paris.

life? Can we have an international language? What sort of energy should we use? Wind and wave power, or can nuclear energy be made safe?

All these issues - and many we can't even imagine now - will be debated with great vehemence, because the debates will not just be idle speculation. The decisions will matter - because humanity will have taken conscious control of our destiny for the first time ever. Making sure that democracy operates is one thing. But you can't live on democracy. You can't eat meetings. Once the whip of wage-labour is taken away, how do we make sure the necessary drudgery is done?

Socialism will not be able to take away the whip of wage-labour straight away. At first, wages will be made more equal, but there will still be wages. People will have to work for the same reason that they have to work today: that they won't have enough to live on if they don't.

The difference will be that everyone will have the right to a decent job, and that workers will have real control over their conditions of work and what they produce. But there will still be drudgery, and it will still have to be done.

Over time, socialism will whittle away wage-labour. More and more goods — food, transport, housing, education, entertainment, clothing — will be distributed free ('to each according to their need') so that people do not need to rely on wages to buy them.

Meanwhile, people will become more and more aware that their work is to serve the common good. In present-day society, a job is simply a way of getting a wage to live on. Most people prefer it if their job is also something socially useful, but that isn't what your wage depends on. So most people, reasonably, see work as a matter of doing as little as possible for as much as possible.

Under socialism work will be ditferent; and so, in time, people's attitudes to work will become different.

Most people will want to contribute to the common good, and the pressure of majority opinion will be enough to push along any minority that doesn't.

The development of science and technology will allow us to reduce drudgery to a basic minimum, shared out equally; and creative work, over and above that drudgery, will become something most people want to do, not Socialism change sc change pe socialism different sharply separated from leisure.

Does that seem utopian? Remember that the 19th century socialist Blanqui was confronted with the objection: "Under socialism, who will empty the chamber pots?" (which, he retorted, just meant 'who will empty my chamber pot?') One of the less spectacular achievements of technology, the flush toilet, has made the objection obsolete; and not even the most sceptical can think it is utopian to think that everyone will clean their own toilet in the future society!

Won't all the meetings and debates make for inefficiency? And isn't a modern economy too complex to plan? Won't we end up like the Soviet Union, with shops full of large metal buckets but empty of toothbrushes?

Not everything will be done by meetings! There will be managers and administrators, and they will take decisions. But they will be elected and accountable, and they will not be a fixed class of people separate from everyone else.

Certainly planning will not be complete at first. Large areas will have to be will not just ciety, it tople. Ui ider people v rill li ways' left to the market economy and the balance of supply and demand. Many smaller enterprises will remain in private ownership.

We will win fuller social control over what we produce as we become more cooperatively-minded, more educated, more skilled - more like socialist citizens. But even in the earliest stages we could avoid the monstrosities of the What stops toothbrushes being produced in the Soviet Union to meet a need which everyone knows about is a huge hierarchy of bureaucrats, each passing the buck, blocking change, and looking after their own sectional interest. In a workers' democracy, production would be quickly adjusted to meet the need, and any manager who was obstructive would be out of his job.

But there's a lot that's not worked out about this idea of socialism. It is true that no perfect model of the future socialist society exists. The main 'models' - those countries that claim to be socialist - are not socialist at all.

But society has progressed before without anyone having a blueprint!

Capitalism is undoubtedly an advance over feudalism; but no-one in feudal society had even a vague idea of how capitalism would work.

We do have general principles about how socialism would work, and soundly-based theories about why the modern working class is the class thatSocialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 16 for the first time in history can make socialism. And general principles are all that is possible in the nature of the case. If socialism is to be genuinely democratic, decisions about precise structures must come from below. If socialism is to liberate the working class, then it will liberate creativity that we cannot possibly predict in advance.

For socialism will not just change society. It will change people.

We can see a small beginning of that change in the transformations that big class struggles - like the miners' strike of 1984-5, or the French general strike of 1968 - make in people's minds. Socialism will be a much bigger and more permanent change in the way people live, and so it will make bigger transformations.

Official capitalist ideology makes some very odd assumptions about human nature. We are supposed to do nothing outside our family circle for any reason except money, and nothing inside it for any reason except love. And this is supposed to be basic human nature, as unchangeable as the fact that we each one head and one nose.

In reality human nature has changed a lot over the centuries: The way people live has changed. The stereotype household of mum, dad, two children, a cat and a mortgage has not existed forever. Indeed, it is breaking down before our eyes today, even within capitalism.

Under socialism people will live in different ways. Some, almost certainly, will still want the stereotype bourgeois household. Some will prefer bigger communal households.

Whatever people choose, the socialist society will 'socialise' housework. That is, it will make publicly-provided childcare, cleaning, and restaurant facilities available to everyone. It will have to do that in order to liberate women, and to make sure domestic slavery is combatted as well as wage-slavery. After a few years of that, even if there are men who still want a wife tied to the kitchen sink and nappy-changing, they won't be able to find one.

The status of children will be changed, too. They will have their own rights as independent beings. They will not just be the property of their parents.

The most basic job of socialism is getting rid of poverty. That is one thing it could do very quickly. Capitalism has created tremendous productive capacities. If we take those into social control, and if we eliminate the huge waste within capitalism - from unemployment, the arms race, pointless competition, advertising, the luxuries of the wealthy - then we can certainly make sure that everyone has enough.

We can do that for the first time in human history. And that in itself will be the basis for a revolution in human nature: we will remove the fear of being done down by our fellow-beings which affects even the most prosperous workers today, in these times of mass redundancies.

That is socialism, in short: the liberation of humanity from poverty, insecurity, wage-slavery and state tyranny; the achievement of conscious control over our destiny. It is worth fighting for.

Scan page 19

Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page Arguments: is socialism possible?

designed to and did get the workers'

----- pull-quotes -----

at workers' wages, so th: they have rivile

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →