Socialism or barbarism?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 16
When four and half million French voters mark the twentieth anniversary of the greatest strike in history by backing an openly fascist party, then it is time for the labour movement and the left throughout Europe to beat the alarm drums.
No fascist movement has had this sort of support since World War 2. Jean-Marie Le Pen's main plank in the presidential election on 24 April was hostility to France's two and a half million immigrant workers, most of whom come from North Africa; but his National Front comes forward as the embodiment of a comprehensively rightwing outlook on the world.
The stock exchange crash of 19 October last year has yet to register in the world's economy. We do not yet know what its repercussions will be, but a profound, or even catastrophic, slump is probable. The comparatively easy and civilised politics of consensus which governed the countries of Western Europe for most of the '50s and '60s have already been strained by economic tensions since the mid-70s. A big slump will wreck them. The French fascists' fourteen percent of the vote is a tremendous base for extreme reaction at the beginning of what may well be a dramatic shift in Western politics.
Now, of course, France in 1988 is not Germany in 1930; nor does Le Pen yet have the same strength that Hitler had in 1930. By the end of 1930 Hitler's SA had 100,000 organised storm-troopers; Le Pen base is still mostly electoral.
But what if the stock market crash disrupts the economy fundamentally? There are no grounds for complacency. Yes the differences between 1988 and 1930 are important; what there is in common is also important.
Disappointment and disillusionment with the Establishment and the official Left gave Le Pen his first electoral boost in 1983-4, when the Socialist-led Government turned sharply towards austerity and cuts. The 'cohabitation' of the Socialist president Mitterrand and the Gaullist prime minister Chirac between 1986 and 1988 swelled the fascist protest vote 'urther. Now, after Mitterthe course of histo or will we once agai phets unarme rand's presidential victory, a new Socialist-led Government is being formed, which will be less inclined even than Neil Kinnock to tackle capitalism seriously. There will be more disillusionment, more despair, more fuel for the Nor is it just a matter of France. The electoral success of the French far right will inevitably boost fascism throughout Europe. The success of the racist bigots in France will give oxygen to the forces rise of the racist barbarian Le Pen, show that the in-between choices may soon disappear.
Many times before workers have faced the choice of socialism or barbarism; their organisations have failed them, and they have paid the price in barbarism.
We may now be entering a new cycle of history in which the central question of modern time, socialism or barbarism, is again posed to the workers of France and other parts of Europe, immediately and urgently.
Once more, maybe, everything will depend on the strength of the internationalists, the revolutionaries, the fighters for workers' liberty — will we be strong enough to shape the course of history, or will we once again be prophets unarmed? We do not and cannot know how long or short the time-scales will be. But Le Pen's election triumph, in the shadow of a looming economic slump, should focus the minds of all serious socialists.
The labour movement is not now in any state - of collective mind or body - to secure the socialist alternative to barbarism. We need to regenerate and reorient the labour movement. We need to rearm and regroup the socialists. We do not have all the time in the world.
For racial equality - End deportations, scrap immigration controls. • Full equality for black people and immigrants. Special programmes of access to education and training to ensure real equality. • Labour movement support black community self-defence racist attacks. • A campaign to recruit black people to the labour movement using material in appropriate languages and to purge racists from all positions in the movement. Support for black workers' right to have their own caucuses and sections.
Scan page 17
Organiser. 28 June lat
----- pull-quotes -----
e more, maybe, everything wi l depend the strength of the inter- nationalists, the revolu- tionaries, the fighters for workers' liberty — will we be strong enough to shape