Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

No backtracking on the Bomb!

Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s, 28 June 1988 · scan pp. 14–16 · Walter Wolfgang · about 1,458 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

chair, Labour CND)

n the world arena, the struggle for European and world nuclear disarmament is now joined.

Gorbachev's proposals for the achievement world nuclear disarmament by the year 2000 provide the possibility of progress. But this prospect has caused European and American hawks to mount a series of counterattacks; their stated aim is to prevent European and world nuclear disarmament.

The INF treaty is the first agreement on nuclear disarmament since World War 2. Previously only had agreements on arms control, agreements which sought to control the direction of an escalating arms race.

But the reductions proposed by the INF agreements, though tremendously important, affect only about 5 per cent of nuclear weapons, and that only if they are not sabotaged by the substitution of new nuclear weapons. Substitution of new nuclear weapons has already been proposed inside NATO, notably by Mrs Thatcher. The decision on substitution by NATO has been postponed because of the opposition these proposals have engendered, but they remain on NATO's agenda. Yet Britain has already commissioned new nuclear weapons, and that proposal has not been properly opposed by Labour in the House of Commons.

There is hope of a Start treaty resulting in a 50% cut in nuclear arsenals; to see these proposals in proper perspective it must be realised that even a 95% cut in nuclear capacity would leave the US and the Soviet Union with enough nuclear weapons to destroy each other. The prospect of a Start treaty has already been delayed largely because of American insistence on its Star Wars project, which represents a major escalation of the nuclear arms race into outer space.

So the struggle for disarmament is on and will be with us for the rest of the century.

There is a need to mount a counterpressure against the nuclear hawks to allow disarmament a chance to succeed. That counterpressure can best be exerted by a European country refusing to have nuclear weapons on its soil and closing all nuclear bases. This could trigger off refusals by other European countries to allow nuclear weapons to be deployed and would strengthen the doves in the United States. In that situation the US is more likely to agree to speed the disarmament process while they have some negotiating counters lett.

After years of discussion the Labour Party has adopted the policy of unconditionally abandoning nuclear weapons and closing down nuclear bases on British soil and in British waters. That policy will not only make relatively safer in an unsafe world, it provides us in the new situation with a vital lever to encourage European and world nuclear disarmament. Provided there is the conviction internationally that Labour will carry out this policy, it can have an effect long before a Labour Government takes office.

To throw doubt in this situation on Labour's commitment its own conference policy is to hamper the world-wide disarmament process.

In the last election that policy should have been advocated by relating it to the prospect of world-wide disarmament in order to gain the maximum amount of credibility. This was not done. Instead was a commitment never sanctioned by conference - that all the money saved should be expended on conventional weapons, although there was a rough balance between the two power blocs. Since then there have been rumours that the policy review would be used to ditch Labour's only remaining radical commitment.

An amendment to put Labour's commitment to scrap nuclear weapons and close nuclear bases into the interim Policy Review document was lost in the NEC, though another amendment reaffirming Labour's commitment to the mutual dissolution of NATO and the Warsaw Pact was carried. Then came Kinnock's famous television interview where he said that in the new world situation there was no need "something for nothing" unilateralism.

Mayhem broke special interview with The Independent was set up for Neil Kinnock. That interview was "on the record". It was reported in The Independent on 21 June. He reaffirmed that he wanted a trade-off with the Russians on Polaris and Trident. But what would he do if there was no tradeoff? Would he keep Polaris and Trident?

Kinnock replied: •In terms of our defence interest it is better for us not to be nuclear dependent. If you think that our defence interests, and our ability to support our obligations in the alliance, are better met by using our resources for different objectives, then that is the way in which you will go". He confirmed that this was the defence policy on which he had fought the last election, but he said there is much greater confidence the exchange will take place"

In a roundabout fashion, at least, the diluted anti-nuclear-weapons commitment on which the last election was fought was now reaffirmed.

A Russian response to Labour's unilateral nuclear disarmament would help the snowball effect which I have described above. But it is not essential and must on no account be made a precondition for Labour's initiative.

In his original television interview, Kinnock clearly underestimated the pressure that would be brought by European and American nuclear hawks. He stated that the election of Mr Dukakis as President would clear away the impediments to the disarmament process. While Mr Dukakis's election is not certain, Mr Dukakis has already made it clear that he supports NATO's policy of the first use of nuclear weapons.

Nuclear disarmament would-wide has not yet been achieved. It has moved into the realm of practical politics, but an intense struggle is going on world-wide between the disarmers and the friends of nuclear weapons. Here Labour's undiluted unconditional, initiative absolutely essential.

The next Labour Party conference must clearly affirm its commitment to unconditionally abandon nuclear weapons and nuclear bases within the lifetime of the first Parliament of a Labour Government. There should also be an amendment to the Policy Review document which clearly states that commitment.

A statement that the money saved on nuclear weapons should be redirected to job creation and resources for welfare services is also essential. And at the same time the question of Britain's unilateral withdrawal from NATO should also be raised, even if it is not won this year.

But after that there campaign linking Labour's unilateral commitment to European and world disarmament. Within that campaign, Labour's commitment to remove all nuclear bases must be clearly stated. To have an impact on the world situation this campaign should take place in the country and in the House of Commons and should be clearly and unequivocally supported by the leader of the Party.

Constituency Parties should not wait for this, and should campaign on the Conference policies as from now. This will also make it more difficult to make further attacks on the policy by the use of the final Policy Review document which will be published in 1989.

The policy of the Party on this and other matters is the property of the Party as a whole. It is not the property of any single individual and can only be amended by Conference. At a time when the struggle between the disarmers and the friends of nuclear weapons takes place a world scale, Labour's contribution can be vital even before it achieves office.

In the past a Balance of Power has often broken down into war after a detente process had begun but had not been consummated. The stakes are not confined to Labour's electoral credibility, though that too is important.

The real stakes are the survival of the human race.

In the new and in some respects hopeful world situation, Labour's clear and consistent advocacy of British unconditional and unilateral disarmament is vital.

Scan page 16

socialism barbarism? Socialist Organiser. 28 of racial intolerance in Britain.

Marxists have said repeatedly that the choice for the workers of the world is either socialism or barbarism. There has been much barbarism in Europe this century. For tour decades it has been mainly in the Third World. In Vietnam and Cambodia, US imperialism rained naplam on the people. In Afghanistan. the USSK has done the same sort of thing for the last decade. Across the Third World, the advance of capitalism has driven millions of peasants off the land and left them to starve - while American farmers are paid not to produce food, and Western Europe accumulates huge stockpiles.

For four decades, the choice of socialism or barbarism has receded for the working class in the metropolitan countries. We have lived under the constant threat of total barbarism - the destruction of civilisation through nuclear war - but from day to day there have been in-between choices. The looming prospect of the dislocation of the world economy on a scale not seen since the end of World War 2, and the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →