Labour and Ireland
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
In the issue of Ireland, the Labour leadership is not abandoning hard-won socialist policies... because there have never been any!
The lack of any independent socialist policy on this issue is largely the responsibility of the left, not just the leadership.
For the whole 20 years of the troubles' the Labour and Conservative parties have had a bipartisan approach to Northern Ireland. They have agreed not to differ on the essentials, and to have a common policy on 'security, i.e. beating down the Northern Ireland Catholics.
Some differences were established between Labour and the Tories after 1980. Labour brought forward its commitment (in words) to a united Ireland. It became Labour policy to abolish the Prevention of Terrorism Act and plastic bullets.
Recently, however, those differences swamped by the all-party support for the Anglo-Irish Agreement - a treaty making Dublin a partner with London in the running of Northern Ireland, which was signed in November 1985.
Now all parties either support a united Ireland by consent, or at least are committed to accept it; but none have any plans to do anything to achieve consent. Labour's commitments on civil liberties issues are almost laughable in the aftermath of the Gibraltar killings. Front bench Labour MPs applauded the extra-judicial killings, and it was left to Eric Heffer to dissent.
A renewed bipartisanship is in force. Labour fully supports the centrepiece of Tory government policy, the Anglo-Irish Agreement, and this includes support for a much stronger 'anti-terrorist' drive.
Probably many Labour activists agree with the leadership on this. They are unhappy with the tougher security, but consider the Agreement to be broadly pro-nationalist and anti-unionist. One major reason for the lack of challenge to the leadership - and the fact that the Policy Review has not found it necessary even to mention Ireland - is the lack of any credible alternative from the would-be Marxist left.
Most of us tend to fall back on religious repetition of the slogan "Troops Out Now', as if it were the only and ultimate solution to the Irish question. Most Labour activists who about it know that this is inadequate. "Troops Out' alone wouldn't, in itself, lead to a democratic solution. Unless it were coupled with some programme to get a solution seen as democratic by both Catholics and Protestants, it would lead not to a united Ireland but to full-scale civil war and bloody repartition.
Some people are persuaded that such rational assessments must be discarded in order to purge themselves of British chauvinism or anti-Irish racism. ("Are you saying that they can't run their affairs without our help?") Others retain the gut instinct that British troops shouldn't be there, but recoil from the left's arguments because of their implications.
So most Labour activists are not happy with the prospect of another Labour Government beating down the Northern Ireland Catholics - another Roy Mason - but know of no alternative. It is time we took the Labour leadership up on their commitment to a united Ireland, for that is the positive democratic solution, and forced a discussion throughout the movement on how that is to be achieved.
We need a proposal which could unite the people of Ireland, and in the first place the workers of Ireland. The territory comes second. Socialist Organiser believes the best formula is a federal united Irelana,. with regional autonomy for the mainly Protestant areas, and maybe confederal links with Britain. But other formulas can and We can only take the debate further by proposing answers to the central problem in Ireland, the existence of two antagonistic Irish traditions or communities. The prospect of new Roy Masons can be avoided, but only if we have a positive alternative.
To begin with we need a wide-ranging discussion which focuses on the two main requirements of any solution: • The right of the Irish people as a whole to self-determination; • The need to conciliate both major traditions in Ireland.
We need to commit a Labour government to: • Working actively for the objective of a united Ireland within the lifetime of a Parliament. • Calling a conference of all parties, including Sinn Fein, to discuss the terms of a settlement. • The dismantling of the repressive apparatus used to beat down Republicans. End the Prevention of Terrorism Act, abolish Diplock courts, and end the use of plastic bullets and strip-searching. • British military an political withdrawal as part of political settlement.
the poll tax!