Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The lessons of Wallasey

Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s, 28 June 1988 · scan pp. 5–11 · Lol Duffy · about 3,929 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Kinnock waves goodbye to Party policy tions and a guarantee of a place for everyone unemployed for more than 12 months - were inadequate. But they were moves in the right direction. They have all disappeared in the Policy Many other commitments peared:

*Abolition of the House of Lords.

*Repeal of the Immigration and Nationality Acts.

*The right to free nursery education for all three to five year olds.

*Phasing-out of nuclear power.

*50% increase in housing investment programme, a freeze on rents, and an end to enforced cut-price sale of council houses.

The general commitment to "a fundamental and irreversible shift in the balance of power and wealth in favour of working people and their families" has also gone. Some other policies which have been scrapped - import controls, price controls, withdrawal from the BEC - were never supported by the Marxist left; but, like better policies, they are being ditched in an undemocratic way.

Withdrawal from the EEC is the only issue on which the Policy Review is explicit about scrapping previous policy -no doubt because the Labour leaders believe, correctly, that the broad Labour left's commitment to withdrawal is one of its weakest points.

The surviving policy commitments make a shorter list. They are:

*A Charter of Employment Kights, including a minimum wage. (There is no commitment to any details of this charter, however).

*Repeal of Tory anti-union laws, except the clauses making ballots compulsory for strikes and for the election of union executives.

*Removal of "the worst features" of the Tories' changes in housing benefit.

*A Freedom of Information Act; an elected police authority for London.

*A Repeal of Section 28, and a law to ban discrimination against lesbians and gays.

It does not add up to a socialist policy, or any comprehensive policy at all, for the 1990s. The debate about the Policy Review is a debate about whether Labour is to be a living political party, with distinctive Labour policies, or merely an electoral machine in the style of a US political party and a vehicle for selling phrases and packages chosen by market-research experts.

Fi the Labour Party nationally had achieved what we achieved in Wallasey at the 1987 election, we would now have a Labour government.

We reduced a Tory majority of 6,708 to a mere 279. We increased Labour's vote by 39 per cent. The 70th marginal on Labour's target list will, next time round, be number five.

We started our campaign in None might du, i one of the worst.

winters in memory, we leafleted the entire constituency to introduce our policies. "Lol is standing for Parliament as a working-class socialist who will not accept the privileged wages and life-style that buys people off.

"He will only take the national average wage and use the rest for the benefit of the labour movement. The campaign of Wallasey Labour Party will be open and honest. We will be calling about do a to answer puricestions For months we carried out a political survey of the constituency. By a door to door survey, asking for people's views on policies - Labour and Tory - we explained our policies, refuted the lies, and recruited to the Party. We began to involve new people in the campaign.

When a struggle broke out we didn't run away from it, scared. We stood with the workers and gave active support. A strike on the Leasowe estate, of women shop workers, put the idea of a socialist campaign for a Labour victory to the test. The strike was against harassment of staff by hired bouncers and for union recognition.

The Labour Party played a role of leadership in the dispute, alongside the TGWU, supporting the picket lines, helping to organise meetings of support, and raising funds. The strike was successful, the union was recognised, and the hired thugs left. And we brought some of the strikers into the Labour Party. They were among the best fighters in the election campaign.

The press denounced 'Marxist Lol'. Frank Field, the Labour MP in the neighbouring constituency of Birkenhead, said voters should not support me. Yet this was the result:

1987 1983 Chalker (C) 22,791 22,854 Duffy (Lab) 22,512 16,146 Richardson (SDP) 8,363 10,717 Working-class socialist policies can win mass support. We need a Labour Party which will do everywhere what we did in Wallasey!

Scan page 6

Campaignir for By Vladimir Derer (Hon Secretary, Campaign Labour Party Democracy, writing personal capacity)

The Statement of Democratic Aims and Values' will be the most important NEC document to be debated at Conference this year. It will serve as the basis for the final more detailed, policy proposals which will be presented to Conference in 1989.

It begins with the statement that "the true purposes of socialism and therefore of the Labour Party is the creation of a genuinely free society", and goes on to argue that this can only be achieved through a more equal distribution of power and wealth. To accomplish this "a major change in the institutional framework of the country" to "change the balance of power in Britain", would be necessary.

If these objectives are to be taken seriously then the measures outlined in the statement are hopelessly inadequate both to reverse the present trend towards even greater social inequality or to tackle the problem of Britain's chronic economic decline.

Unless these tasks, or rebuilding the economy and ensuring greater equality, are undertaken any prospect of bringing about "a genuinely free society" is a pipedream. The proposals in "Aims and Values" will clearly fail to achieve this.

The aspect of the document that gives the greatest cause for concern is the limited role assigned to the public sector. On the one hand emphasis is placed on the role of government in ensuring the Le Pent A H for the 199 efficient working of the economy. On the other hand specifically only "Health care, education, and social security" is to be "allocated irrespective of the purchasing power of those who receive such services..." and housing and transport (made) available to those who cannot afford, or do not choose to make private provision. " In addition "the public utilities — the water, gas and electricity telecommunication networks post and main outside the domain ruled exclusively by market forces.

But: "In the case of the allocation of most other goods and services" however, it is argued that "the operation of demand and supply and the price mechanism is a generally satisfactory means of determining provision and consumption. "

Think what this implies. It means that if UK capitalist enterprises choose to produce such supposed "non essentials" as cars, computers, washing machines and refrigerators abroad, thus destroying employment in Britain and causing the UK balance of payments (to deteriorate, this is "generally satisfactory" as an example of "the operation of demand and supply". It also means that in periods of-sharp increases in prices it would not be "satisfactory" to subsidise foodstuffs since this would involve interference with "the price mechanism"

Apart from this highly restricted direct state intervention in the economy, the NEC's 'Aims and Values' confine themselves to merely oiling the worn-out machinery of British capitalism. The role of the government is reduced simply to providing conditions for a well-educated and trained workforce, large and consistent investment in research, out now!

The latest issue of Worke Liberty is now available. Features include analysis the Gulf War, Fascism in France plus debate on Ireland. 95p plus 30p postage fro SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 4 design and development" (10) and to the setting up of "institutions and means... to ensure that capital is available in amounts, at prices and for purposes which facilitate initiative, development, production and sales... " (24).

Under Thatcher Britain has suffered a major decline in manufacturing industry but this decline was not due to lack of finance. On the contrary profits have boomed in recent ears; thus the idea that we can rebuild our manufacturing industry by an injection of cheap capital is laughable. The reality is that the private sector is unwilling to invest in British industry; no amount of capital being "made available" by the state will change this.

The Tories are peddling the fiction that the country's economic performance has radically improved. In fact Britain's trade deficit rises inexorably and central to this deficit is the appalling collapse of British manufacturing. This cannot go on for ever.

So long as the impact of the steadily deteriorating balance of trade in manufactures is cushioned by the flow of North Sea oil, the grave malaise of the British economy can misrepresented as an economic recovery. However, as soon as the oil runs out the economic reality will become obvious.

Once this becomes clear a general election is likely to produce a Labour government. But if Labour is elected on a programme constructed in the dream world of Thatcherite "prosperity" it will not be able to introduce the radical measures essential to deal with the economy.

There is no way Britain's economic problems can even begin to be tackled without embarking on a massive statedirected investment plan in the sectors of the economy that are crucial to reindustrialisation. To be effective such a plan would have to include a substantial measure of state control through the nationalisation of major financial institutions, and of at least one top company in each major manufacturing sector, together with compulsory planning agreements.

There can be no misunderstanding about what the NEC majority meant when they approved the extremely limited scope for state intervention outlined in Aims and Values'. Any hint that this should be widened was voted down. Ken Livingstone's amendment that the Party should be "committed to social ownership of the decisive sectors of the economy" was lost by 22 votes to 4. It is clear that the party leadership and the NEC are determined to get elected on a programme quite unequal to the task Labour will have to face.

The authors of Aims and Values condemn the present society for only giving the "full right to choose" to a privileged minority, whilst denying it to the great majority. They spell out the reason for this: "there is... an undeniable relationship between the resources that an individual can command and the choices which it is possible for that individual to make". The Labour Party therefore remains committed to the redistribution of wealth and power" (7).

Yet the measures

Scan page 7

Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page S fulfil this commitment. Since capital overwhelmingly is to remain in private hands, and since it is its private ownership that causes and perpetuates inequality, there is no basis for believing that 'Aims and Values' , if acted upon, would reduce these inequalities. Unless the ownership and control of the major means of production is taken out of the hands of the few, there is no way Labour can "ensure that.. change brings benefits that are available to everyone" as 'Aims and Values' pledges.

There is no such commitment in the statement. Indeed when Tony Benn moved an amendment that the Party's aim as stated in Clause IV of the Party Constitution, namely "to secure for the workers by hand and brain the full fruits of their industry and the most equitable distribution thereof that may be possible on the basis of the common ownership of the means of production, distribution and exchange, and the best obtainable system of popular administration and control" be included in the text - the Conti NEC defeated it by 22 votes to 4.

'Aims and Values acknowledges that *women and black people are grossly underrepresented in the institutions that form opinion" . It argues that "the full emancipation of both women and the ethnic minorities demands special measures to elevate their standing and status". Yet this comes from an NEC which has consistently opposed the rights of Labour women to elect their own representatives on the NEC, and the rights of black members to organise autonomously. The NEC can hardly claim an intention towards positive action in society as a whole when it refuses to allow the benefit of these measures to black people and women within its own party.

There is nothing in the document that reaffirms Labour's long-standing commitment to remove all nuclear weapons from Britain. That the leadership's intention is to ditch unilateralism was borne out by the Party Leader's TV interview on 'This Week Next Week' (5 Campaigning for nationalisation June).

NB: Numbers in brackets refer paragraphs of Aims and Values.

Joint North London meeting on Labour leadership contest, supporter by Hendon North, Hendon South, Hornsey & Wood Green, and other CLPs.

Your chance to question che leadersnip estion the leadersh ntenders Sunday 10 July, 2.30, at Caxton House, 129 St Johns Way, NI9.

Speakers: Tony Benn MP, John Prescott MP (or a spokesperson fron his campaign), and a spokesperson from the Kinnock/Hattersley campaign.

Tickets El waged, 30p unwaged, from your CLP secretary or from Sean Clegg, 6 Prospect Rd, London NW2 ZAL.

Scan page 8

Wing By Bob Fine f a socialist democracy is to be our goal, then the policy review should be democratic too. The bureaucratism of Labour Listens' and the determination of policy by closed committees and powerful individuals should give way to open and informed debate.

Labour should draw on the wealth of expertise of groups within and without the Party who have fought democratic struggles over racism, sexism, prisoners' rights, police harassment, trade union rights, electoral reform, local government powers, gay rights, official secrets and so on. The Labour Party should take evidence from groups like the National Union of Mineworkers, the prisoners' rights group PROP, women's sections, black self-defence groups, etc., and integrate their demands into a general socialist programme.

The more the Party looks outwards in order to engage the multiplicity of democratic struggles already being waged against the many arms of the state, A Bill of Rights The miners' strike showed that the police enforce the interests not of the majority but of the ruling class. Their rigid hierarchy, their training, their separation from the rest of society, and the personal ties of thei upper ranks make sure they do that Society could have an alternative, more democratic way of regulating itself - patrols organised and controlled by the labour movement and local communities. Police duty should be made a part-time job of every citizen, like jury service.

In the meantime we must fight for more control over the existing police force. • Chief Constables and their Assistants to be elected at regular fixed periods. • Directly-elected Police Committees to have full operational control over the police in their area. • Access to any police station and to police files at any time for members of the Committees. • Elected tribunals, completely independent of the police, should hear complaints against them. • Democratic rights within the police, including the right to form trade unions and the right not to used as scab-herders.

Far from MI5 being under democratic control, members last Labour government were probably themselves under surveillance by it. MI5 and other branches of the secret service should be scrapped.

Labour should also advocate: • Replace the armed forces the greater will be its capacity to offer its own lead to these struggles. For example, what credibility will all the talk about trade union democracy have if the Party is seen to fold its arms when the existing rights of trade unions are threatened and workers are left to defend them unaided?

A policy review of that sort is much needed in a Party which, until now, has accepted uncritically most of the parameters and structures of the existing state. The radicalism shown by the Thatcher government in restructuring the state, making fundamental changes in the administration of the civil service, the nationalised industries, the NHS, and local government, forces the question of democratisation on to the agenda of the Party.

Should we win the next election, the Labour party will inherit a very different and far more hostile state apparatus than it has encountered in the past.

Unless we prepare now to transform and tackle this apparatus, with the kind of determination shown by the Tories, but with different forces at our disposal, it will stand against us as a mighty obstacle to the implementation of any a people's militia. • Scrap all nuclear weapons. Britain out of NATO, NATO out of Britain. • Democratic rights for troops. • Workers' control of the armament industry, and conversion of the bulk of it to socially useful production under workers' control.

Four-fifths of all judges come from public school and Oxbridge backgrounds. Their background, training, and way of life makes the hostile to the working class.

Not only judges, but also magistrates and JPS are unelected. They are chosen only after they have shown themselves to be staunch supporters of the status quo. • All judges, JPs and magistrates should be elected. • End vetting of juries. • All legal representation to be pai‹ for by the state. Wealth should not determine whether you get a fair trial.

At present local councilors can be brought to court and surcharged and disqualified for carrying out the manifesto on which they were elected, if - in the opinion of an unelected official auditor - that is financially irresponsible. Central Government can break many of its own laws with impunity. • Autonomy for local councils. • The right of each citizen to effective redress against central government through the courts.

Within the civil service real power lies with the top ranks, who are flesh and blood of the ruling class. Many go on from the civil service to top jobs in finance and industry. Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 6 Org age 6 kind of socialist programme. Democracy is on our agenda not just because it is a good thing, but because it has become necessary for any other reform.

The immediate problem with the Labour Party's attitudes towards the state is not that they are reformist, but rather than they are not even reformist. Where are the perspectives and programme for democratising the judiciary, the magistracy, the police, the army, the civil service, the prisons, the Health Service, the nationalised industries, and, not least, Parliament itself? Where is the lead which the Labour Party should be giving on all these questions?

Again and again the Party has allowed the democratic ideas and impulses raised among workers by their experience of state injustice to slip through its fingers and turn into demoralisation or a feeling of impotence in the face of an untouchable force. The policy review should be an opportunity for the party to learn from its past mistakes, like the disastrously bureaucratic attempt at industrial democracy in the Bullock proposals of the mid-1970s, and from the new demands which Thatcherism has put upon it.

The Official Secrets Act should be abolished; a Freedom of Information Act introduced; and top civil service jobs made elective and paid workers wages.

It took a long and sometimes bloody struggle by the labour and women's movements to get our present rights to vote. But at the same time as the capitalist class has conceded wider voting rights, it has protected itself by moving real power away from Parliament. • Abolish the House of Lords and th monarchy. Remember: a Labour government was sacked in a 'coup" by the Queen's representative, the Governor-General, as recently as 1975 in Australia. • Give MPs full access and documents. • Annual elections on a fixed date. • A legal right to meetings in work time to hear the different political candidates and debate the issues. Equal TV and radio time for all parties except fascists.

The Policy Review document rejects the idea of a Bill of Aignts. In fact this could be a tremendous mobilising idea in the fight for democracy.

Bringing women's, black, and lesbian/gay groups together with the trade unions and labour movement and groups like the National Council of Civil Liberties to discuss the elements of a Bill of Rights could be the basis of a strong campaign. The campaign for the Bill of Rights could be conducted on the same basis that the Chartists and suffragists campaigned for their demands -industrial action and civil disobedience.

Scan page 9

Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 7 Campaigning for rights Police attack black youth for protesting against racist attacks

Scan page 10

peal the Tory anti-union laws! Campaigning for rights WARD Wapping picket Re By Philip Hutchinson (Dover Port Commiti National Union of Se: in personal capacity)

The union has tried every possible method to placate the courts and purge their contempt. But none of its has worked, and none of it will work while the law is so much against us and is being used by both the Government and the shipowners to break the union.

Obviously they're trying to prevent the officers of a union actually calling a strike. But even if the union officials don't want the strike, and the men still strike, they take it out on the union funds.

Irrespective of any of the national officers, Sam McCluskie or anybody else, saying strike or don't strike - no matter what he says — we will still be on strike in Dover. And because of that they will punish the whole union, not just the small area of Dover.

We now have the most repressive STE trade union laws in Western Europe. Margaret Thatcher and Jeffrey Stirling have been working on those laws for eight or nine years now. They have finally formulated them after taking on the NUJ, the miners, the NGA and SOGAT, and they've been very well planned.

The TUC has to become more of an educating and organised body, which it hasn't done so far. That's the only way to overcome the law.

I believe the Labour Party commit itself to repealing the Tories' A Workers' Charter • The right to strike. The right of strikers and their families to receiv state benefits. • The right to picket. The right of pickets to defend themselves. • The right to organise. The right individuals to join unions, of union officials to get access to workplaces, and of union representatives to have time off and facilities. • The right to negotiate. Employers should be legally compelled to Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 8 trade union legislation, but in all reality! don't believe they will. At the end of the day there are parts of the legislation that the Labour Party will want to keep.

We need to make the Labour Party socially conscious, which it's not at the moment. I support the present challenge to the Labour leadership. We not only need to rearm the Labour Party, but to re-heart it - put the fight back into it.

It's a matter of getting people actively involved, making people aware, and them becoming activists again.

recognise unions with majority support and to negotiate with them. Unions should have a right to company information. Individual workers should have protection against unfair dismissal, with tribunals being able to force employers to reinstate them. • The right to safety. The right to information on all risks and hazards, and the right to stop unsafe jobs. • The right to trade union independence. Unions' decision-making and political activity should not be controlled by the courts.

Scan page 11

Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 9 paigning ir jobs A Workers' Plan

----- pull-quotes -----

candidate in Wallasey 1987)

WORKERS LIBERTY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →