Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Kinnock clears the decks

Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s, 28 June 1988 · scan pp. 4–5 · Martin Thomas · about 1,038 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Labour s Policy Revien or to p ut it more accurately, the Lab our leadership's Policy Review + is an exercise in clearing the decks.

The 48-page document published by the National Executive Committee shelves almost every halfway radical policy commitment, substituting a lot of vague words. Labour Party conference in October is supposed to be able to amend the Review aocument, and certainly Constituency Labour Parties and trade unions should send in as many amendments as possible; but clearly the idea is to ram the whole document through with the excuse that all matters of detail must be considered at the second stage of the Review.

The second stage will then be able to build on the vague, but unmistakably right-wing, words of the tirst stage. The aim is nothing less than to scrap the last 10 or 15 years of Labour Party conference policy-making, and to install instead policy made from the top down on the basis of minion polls and market research.

Labour Party conference has voted unequivocally for unilateral nuclear disarmament. The 1983 manifesto hedged slightly: ^ll this cannot be done at once, and the way we do it must be designed to assist in the task to which we are also committed - securing nuclear disarmament agreements with other countries and maintaining cooperation with our allies"

But there was also a clear commitment: "We will cancel the Trident programme, refuse to deploy Cruise misiles and begin discussions for the removal of nuclear bases from Britain, which is to be completed within the lifetime of the Labour government"

In the Policy Review there is almost nothing but hedging. "The fast-moving developments in world events following the US-Soviet Summits will have their SUBSCRIBE!

Get Socialist Organiser dell vered to your door by Rates(UK) £8.50 for six mo aths. £16 for Lyear, Name ..

Address Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E. - To Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Get your copy! effect on our review of how Labour's non-nuclear defence policy can best meet the challenge of the 1990s. These developments emphasise the relevance of this poucy... in the meantime we consider that nuclear weapons create hostility and distrust which stunt the lives of individuals and communities across the world and that reliance on such weapons of mass destruction cannot contribute to the effective detence of our country or to the collective security of nations"

In the early '80s Labour developed the following policy: "Common ownership: we believe it is wrong that private individuals should, through ownership of the means of production, reap the benefits of the collective efforts of others and exercise unaccountable power over the lives of others... We believe in the social control of production, not the anarchy of the market".

Specifically: "We are committed higher public spending... We «The debate abo the Policy Review is debate about whether Labour is to be a distinctive po itical party with distinctive Labour policies'.

establish a publicly-owned stake in each important sector of industry and take back those sections of public industries which have been- hived off by the Tories... We will require major firms in each sector... to enter into planning agreements... Common ownership is an integral part of a democratic economy, because as long as large concentrations of capital remain in private hands, then power too will be concentrated'?. (1981 document, "The Socialist Alternative').

The specific commitments never matched up to the general claims. If "majo firms" were to be regulated only by SOCIALIST OR CELISES cops did Ulster shoot to kill new homeless The Tories *planning agreements with no clear means of enforcement - and the banks were to remain untouched, then there would not be "social control of production" and "large concentrations of capital" would "remain in private hands" . Instead of replacing the profit economy by planning for need, Labour proposed only to tinker with the profit economy.

But there was some commitment to some attempt at social control. In the Policy Review, that has gone. "Few would disagree that the market is the most appropriate means of ensuring the efficient distribution of many goods — certainly in a modern, industrialised society"

"Common or social ownership is not limited to state ownership" ,insists the Policy Review. True enough: but Labour's 1981 document explained clearly enough that state ownership is nonetheless central. "This 'market' is one in which only a hundred companies control 40 percent of manufacturing output... " Municipal ownership or worker cooperatives may be fine for small enterprises, but the major centres of industry, commerce and finance will be run either as capitalist empires or under centralised social control.

In fact the Policy Review is not even advocating more municipal enterprise and workers' cooperatives. It is saying, in coded language, no nationalisations or renationalisations'; and it is saying that employee share-ownership and ownership by pension funds are forms of socialist common ownership!

It proposes social control only for "monopoly suppliers" - businesses where even the keenest Thatcherite or Reaganite concedes the need for some public regulation!

All commitment to higher public spending has gone. Planning agreements have disappeared. Instead we have a warmed-over version of Harold Wilson's slogans of 1964 - "a talentbased economy... transformed by a technological revolution" , but without even Wilson's National Plan. Instead of planning, the "central question" is "how best to help the companies, the enterprises and risktakers [I think they mean capitalists], the managers and workers.. who will meet the challenges of the next decade."

*The heart of a rational economic volicy must be a commitment to full employment and the measures necessary to secure it" , says the Policy Review. But - having defined the "central question" of socialist policy as how to help the capitalists! - it proposes no measures to get full employment.

A government investment bank is mentioned as a possibility; there is much talk about the need for better training, without any specific proposals; and that is all.

Labour's previous policies - a 35 hour week without loss of pay; increased public spending; and expanded training schemes with trade union nav and condiSocialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page 3 The Policy Review

Scan page 5

----- pull-quotes -----

Britain's death squad 22 exposed!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →