Break the consensus!
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
The administrations which have governed Britain in modern times may perhaps best be classified not by reference to the traditional electoral cycle, but by indentifying four different periods of consensus, which have followed one after another. The first, the pre-war consensus, underpinned the National government and lasted from 1931 to 1940; the second, the wartime consensus, ran from 1940 to 1945 when the coalition was in power; the third, the welfare capitalist consensus, lasted from 1945 until 1976; and the fourth, the monetarist consensus, which began when the Labour Cabinet accepted the IMF terms, has lasted from then until the present day. To Jump governments from different parties into the same catagories may seem strange, but, looking back on all the various policies that have been followed by successive administrations, it is the similarity between them, quite as much as the differences, which now seem to be so strikingly obvious.
When the OPE oil crisis occured in 1973, all the underlying weaknesses of our economic system were exposed.
It became clear that the economic base on which the 'welfare consensus' depended had finally collapsed, actually ending half-way through Labour's term of office when the IMF demanded, and received assurances that public expenditure would be cut, supposedly to restore business confidence. At the end of its twenty-one-year life span, it was clear that the welfare consensus had neither revitalised British industry nor retained public support with the electorate, which successively defeated Wilson, Heath and Callaghan, who had all tried to make it work, thus paving the way for the election of a very different kind of Conservative government.
Democracy and socialism have been successfully kept off the political agenda, under governments of all persuasions, since 1945. Yet despite all that, the pressure for more democracy and for the ideas of socialism are strongly felt, and widely shared. But, like the early trade unionists, the Chartists and the suffragettes, they will only secure their objectives by organised strength and by pressing them onto reluctant parliamentarians and a frightened Establishment, who will only concede when they realise that they can no longer hold the line. It has often happened before.
The polarisations and confrontations that these class policies produced were certainly reflected in the thinking of the wider labour movement. But they were not articulated in the presentation of the case in the House of Commons, where an informed consensus began to develop in which the Tory wets, the SDP-Liberal Alliance and the Labour right were content to limit the argument to the question of which of them was best qualified to administer an unchanged economic system. It is certainly true that many people in the Conservative Party and the Alliance, and some inside the Labour Paty, backed by the majority of the Establishment and political commentators, now belleve that it may be possible to reconstruct our political system on the old Victorian, or modern American, principle that Whigs and Tories, Democrats and Republicans will forever play the game of ins-and-outs, within the broad framework of the policies and institutions evolved during the monetarist consensus which any successor will inherit from the Thatcher administration. In that sense, despite all that has been said about the destruction of the consensus by Mrs Thatcher, there still is a wide measure of agreement among parliamentarians as to how the political future might be shaped.
But despite the renewed evidence of the traditional huddling together at the top, the economic prospects as oil revenues and the privatisation windfall profits run down are poor, and the price that has been paid by millions of people in unemployment has created a much stronger resistance to the government of the day than we have seen since the 1930s.
So far the strength of this feeling has been mainly articulated outside Parliament, and if it forces its way upwards then we are heading for a very diferent sort of politics. Politicians of all parties, who are now seeking to retain or gain office in a basically unchanged system, may find that the next real radical challenge comes from outside the formal system: there are forces which will seek to be heard and will make demands and back them up with organisational strength. That should neither surprise nor alarm socialists, for looking back over the years since the war it is arguable that our problems today really derive from the failure of consensus and the failure to give the country the chance to face up to the basic retorms that are necessary in its industrial, economic and political structures if social justice is ever to be achieved. Indeed our whole history shows that every period of change has been heralded by some pressure from underneath or outside the House of Commons, Whitehall or the City of London.
(Extracts from '50 Years of Consensus Rule' by Tony Benn, in his book Fighting Back' [Hutchinson £6.95]).
Scan page 3
Socialist Organiser. 28 June 1988. Page