Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

SCIENCE SLUMN Sci People

Socialist Organiser no. 361, 23 June 1988 · scan p. 11 · about 522 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

The summer edition of SFP* is now out, covering a wide range of scientific topics from a socialist viewpoint.

There is an eye-witness account government. Thousands died last year when mustard gas, cynide and nerve gas were dropped on this Iranian-held town. The gases were manufactured in a "pesticides"

plant built and supplied by European companies.

A feature on BST (bovine somato tropin) fills out the picture so far available to listeners to the Archers.

BST is a cow growth hormone said to increase milk yields by up to 25% without increased feed costs.

It is genetically engineered: the gene for BST has been inserted inte bacteria which happily make loads of the stuff. Injected into cows, it seems to have some detrimental effects on them and their calves. It is unclear whether BST gets into the milk or if it can affect hormones.

The Ministry refuses to release the evidence. But it does seem to increase the saturated fat content of milk. Therefore, it is doubly useless. It well increase milk surpluses and increase the butter mountains.

Another feature looks at schizophrenia. This to some extent invented disease, is ofter diagnosed on uncertain grounds. A body of symptoms is said to be typical of schizophrenia (thought disorder, delusions, hallucinations, hearing voices, loss of will, disturbed movement, incongruous emotional expressions) but someone suffering.

say, two of these will be diagnosed as schizophrenic, just as someone else suffering from another two different symptoms. And yet there is no similarity in their behaviour. Indeed, there is no justification for linking all these symptoms together in something called schizophrenia.

The diagnosis is frequently made on subjective grounds and then the person's behaviour will be interpreted to suit the diagnosis. In one experiment, a group of volunteers presented themselves to mental hospitals, complaining of hearing voices. Many were admitted on these grounds alone.

Once inside, they said they no longer heard the voices but the staff disbelieved them. One "patient" who was making notes on the experience was said by staff to show "compulsive writing behaviour"!

The hospitals were then informed of the study and its results and patients, expect more "pseudoAdmissions for schizophrenia then fell and some one-fifth of new patients were confidently said to be faking their symptoms. In fact, no more pseudo-patients had been sent.

The article also shows how attempts to show a biochemical or genetic basis for schizophrenia have generally failed. Here, the argument falters, with credence being given to social theories of schizophrenia. These see the disease as an intelligible and perhaps logical response to disturbed relationships between members of families. Unfortunately, these theories are just as circular as the conventional ones.

And the fact remains, that some people do suffer from delusions and hear voices etc. Many find these feeling unbearable and for these it may be that the powerful drugs given in mental hospitals offer some welcome respite, despite the many drawbacks of such drugs. *Science for People is available for 25 Horsell Rd. London N5 XL. Send f1 for single copy.

----- pull-quotes -----

of chemical warfare on the Iragi Kurds of Halabja by "their own

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 361

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →