Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Not a 'mere plaything' Working women and the suffrage movement

Socialist Organiser no. 361, 23 June 1988 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,905 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

some lessons today in the h of the women suffrage movement.

«Women do not want their political power to enable them to boast that they are on equal terms with men. They want to use it for the same purpose as men — to get better conditions... We do not want it as a mere plaything!" Selina Cooper - textile worker, organiser for the National Union of Women's Suffrage Societies. "Our members are absolutely single-minded; they concentrate all. their forces on. one-object political equality with men. No member of the WPSU divides her attention between suffrage and other social reforms". (Mrs) Emmeline Pankhurst. The history of the women's suffrage movement is most popularly associated with the Pankhurst family and the organisation they set up — the Women's Political and Social Union (WPSU). The campaign for "Votes for Women" has been seen to be about spectacular 'militant' actions — hunger strikes, women chaining themselves to the railings outside 10 Downing Street and in its latter stages acts of arson. But there was another dimension to the campaign that has only recently been researched and discovered. No less effective or important, this is the involvement of working class women, specifically women workers in the textile industries of Lancashire and Yorkshire.

Injustice

These women became involved in the suffrage campaign not only because they felt the injustice of the lack of a basic democratic right. For them, it was also connected to ighting for better conditions as working women, and for many it was part of a struggle for a better society.

Indeed the 'vote had this broader meaning and connection with social equality for many working class militants in the early period of British working class organisation.

However this was beyond the understanding and horizons of many of the middle class women within the suffrage movement. The debates and contlicts that took place within the movement as a result of these differences, and the responses of the labour movement - for it was by no means supportive - are still very relevant for socialist women today.

Socialist

Throughout the nineteenth century the highest concentration of women's employment was in the textile industries: the Nottinghamshire hosiery workers, the woollen workers of the West Riding and the cotton workers of Lancashire. They were a cheap (being paid substantially less than men) and flexible workforce for the factory and mill owners. Married women were especially | preferred, as Marx Factory gate suffrage meeting in pointed out: *They have families at home dependant on them for support; they are attentive, docile, more so than unmarried females, and are compelled to use their utmost exertion to procure the necessaries of life."

Despite opposition from some male trade unionists and protective legislation these women were never excluded from these industries for women's wages were as important to working class families dependant on this industry (where work was often slack and seasonal), as their cheap labour was to the bosses. By the end of the nineteenth century, these women were relatively well unionised. Women were also involved in the early socialist organisations, the Social Democratic Federation (SDF) and the Independent Labour Party (ILP). It was from the trade unions and the socialist organisations that the local leadership of the suffrage movement emerged The women's suffrage campaign really started off in Manchester. (It was here that the WPSU was established by the Pankhursts). Manchester had always . a history of radical liberalism and within this, women's suffrage organisation. The Secretary of the Manchester Suffrage Society at the end of the nineteenth century was a university graduate, Esther Roper. Unlike her predecessors she decided to direct her efforts toward working class women. In 1893 she launced a "Special Appeal" ', a petition calling for the enfranchisement of women, which was to be taken out to the working women of Lancashire.

Petitions

The petition was initially taken up by the Women's Cooperative Guild. This was not a nineteenth century equivalent of the Women's Institute! The local branch of the Guild would organise regular meetings for women, freeing them for an evening at least, from the daily round of drudgery. They discussed all kinds of issues from the rights and wrongs of "rational dress" (i.e. not wearing corsets!) to workers' education and votes for The petition was taken round to local mills and factories by guild activists and trade union women. Factory gate meetings were organised, MI about 1910 delegations were sent to Parliament. Later ballots were agitated for in the textile unions on the question of women's suffrage. Most votes went in favour.

All of these 'activist" women were workers, or wives, or mothers or all three. Unlike middle class women they had little or no free time. Yet by 1901 29,359 signatures had been collected. In the same year the Lancashire petition was adapted and taken round the wool workers in Yorkshire, and cotton and silk workers in Cheshire.

The campaign was taken up in the TUC by Helen Silcock who was President of the Wigan Weavers Association. She moved a motion calling for votes for women on the same basis as men. At that time the franchise was still based on a property qualification. Some working class men without sufficient income still lacked the vote.

Hysterical Helen Silcock's motion was defeated because, it was argued, somehow or other, it would enPosity a air precion Here, rightly or wrongly, the women's suffrage question was associated with the hysterical demands of bourgeois spinsters' with nothing better to do with their time than squeal about votes for women. Really prejudice won the day, for Helen Silcock, had been careful to pose the demand as a class demand, that working class women needed, and deserved the vote as workers.

This debate was to rage on for many years, not only in the TUC but also within the SDF and the ILP. One side supported votes for women on the same basis as men the other adult suffrage.

To many women the latter was a device adopted in order to ignore the principle of women's rights. This was probably some of the motivation. The debate was aggravated and polarised further however, by the very public campaigns of the Pankhursts and the WPSU.

Emmeline, Christabel and Sylvia Pankhurst had all been members of the ILP in Manchester. Emmeline in particular was a prominent member of the ILP. Her aim, initially, was to convert the ILP and Labour Representation Committee for this purpose. This later became the WPSU. The group was tiny and firmly in the control of the Pankhursts and their close friends.

In the first few years the Pankhursts maintained their links with the Lancashire campaign, they spoke at public meetings in the area. But it was clear from the beginning that the Pankhurst's were less concerned with agitation at the grass-roots than with trying to influence Labour leaders and 'public opinion' at a national level.

Militancy

In 1906 the Pankhursts, and thus the WPSU moved down to London, abandoning their links with the Lancashire women. The policy of 'militancy' began to develop. Under the influence of Christabel Pankhurst their group became far narrower. Only one working class woman from the East End, Annie Keeny, carefully cultivated by Christabel was ever allowed to enter their charmed circle. The WPSU was the first to adopt the slogan "Votes for Women' and they certainly meant votes for some women. And the women who were involved in their campaign were middle class women. For sure their actions were sometimes brave, but when banquets at the Savoy Hotel were held to celebrate the release of women from Holloway prison, it is not suprising trade unionists and working class suffragists recoiled from their behaviour. They did not want to be associated with it as Eva Gore Booth (a long-time friend of both Esther Roper and the Pankhursts put it):| "It is not the fact of demonstrations or even violence that is offensive to them, it is being mixed up and held accountable as a class for educated and upper class women who kick, shriek, bite and spit".

Narrow

For Christabel these tactics worked and because the one, narrow goal was all important, so be it: "It is evident that the House of Commons and even its Labour members, were more impressed by the demonstrations of the feminine bourgeoisie than of the female proletariat", Today of course, the vote no longer has the same importance and connection to the fight for a better society, within the labour movement. The women's suffrage movement in Lancashire and the north of England was based on that idea. It also emerged from a tradition, in one particular locality, where it was possible for women to organise and where women did organise despite the huge restrictions in their lives.

Elitist

The struggle for the vote is past history but there is, in many ways a similar debate taking place in the labour movement today. For a long time the Labour Party's Women's Organisation has been demanding political equality within the Party This fight has been led by the Women's Action Committee. But WAC are in danger of forgetting just as the WPSU forgot, that no amount of political equality or constitutional changes will guarantee genuine equality for ordinary working women. Unless we take on board and link that struggle to the wider needs and interests of working class women, we are lost. The fight becomes, sterile, narrow and ultimately elitist. Women's sections today are exactly like the WPSU seventy years ago, charmed circles of well-educated, able women, personally dissatisfied with their lives maybe, but not interested in involving ordinary women whose need to organise is as real and important as it was for the Lancashire textile workers.

Equality

We don't need political equality as a "mere plaything" to get so many women into prominent positions in the labour movement, when the vast majority of women remain 'powerless' and unorganised. We need political equality because it is part of a bigger battle to get the labour movement to fight for the interests of working class women and the working class as a whole.

Most of the research into the participation of working women in the suffrage movement is contained in: "One Hand Tied Behind Us" by Jill Liddington and Jill Norris, published by Virago, priced £4.95.

361.

Scan page 9

It opens on Friday evening with a meeting on the Polish workers' movement Solidarnosc, with speakers including Zbigniew Kowalewski, an exiled leader of Solidarnosc's left wing.

On the Saturday and Sunday, the main Party and class: how should socialists organis so as best to help the development of working-class politics?

The National Question: what answer can we give to the national and communal conflicts that dominate politics in Ireland, in Palestine, in Sri Lanka and so many other places? Workers in the Eastern Bloc: does Gorbachev offer a way forward? Can Solidarnosc provide a model for independent workers' movements in other countries of the Eastern Bloc?

There will also be a series of introductory workshops, explaining and discussing basic ideas of Marxism for people new to socialist There will be a creche, socials in the evenings, and accommodation provided people coming from outside London. The 'Workers' Liberty 88' summer school w be held from Friday 1 July to Sunday 3 July in London.

themes will be:

----- pull-quotes -----

in 1903 she formed the Women's suffrage

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 361

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →