Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

China's political

Socialist Organiser no. 361, 23 June 1988 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 2,448 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

If you are coming down to London for the Workers Liberty Summer School then you must go and see Hibiscus Town. It's much better for you than an evening in a smoke-filled bar!

This him was made last year in Shanghai by the veteran director Xie Jin who also directed the Two Stage Sisters. Like Two Stage Sisters, Hibiscus Town is about two contrasting women. The women in Hibiscus Town are a party cadre and a 'rich peasant' . The film is about how they survived two decades of China under Mao. You don't have to be a film buff or an expert about the Cultural Revolution to enjoy this powerful melodrama, which touches on every political nerve of post-1949 China.

The story starts in 1962 in rural Hibiscus Town, where Hu Yuyin and her husband worked hard to make a success of their bean curd tall. At that time much of China vas in dire poverty after three years if bad harvests, and the Russians ad just withdrawn all technical aid.

A zealous work team headed by ne woman cadre Li Guoxing comes ito town to continue the movelent against the *five bad ements" - ie, people with ubious class backgrounds, inluding the village idiot "crazy" ing. The "movement" soon ¡cuses on the bean curd stall's profits.

Hu Yuyin is made to sweep the reets with the "crazy" Qing who , in fact, an artist purged in 1957 uring the period of the Hundred owers, when the film director mself had a rough time.

Oing and Yuyin fall in love and •through some horrific times, for ›ad elements" had no rights at all, Cadre Li herselt survives purge after purge, and remains firmly in political power in Deng's China after the Gang of Four have been toppled, which is when the film ends. She is the target of the film's venom. There must be thousands in the middle and upper echelons of the Chinese Communist Party today who will squirm a bit if they get to see this film for they are bureaucratic and hypocritical survivors just like Li.

The film's ending is ambiguous and cleverly so, because film directors have to be survivors too! For me, the film is saying: never mind whether it's Deng's capitalist road'l or Gorbachev's "perestroika" the Chinese and Russian parties are made up of cadres like Li, and are rotten through and through. Don't expect them to bring about socialism!

Go and see this film with a beautifully told story and strong characters. It's on at the ICA cinema, Pall Mall, until 4th Julv.

Scan page 7

Andrea Dworkin: feminist or Glenda Jackson in 'Business as Usual' - a film that portrays women differently. some bloke, kiddies and, lately, an interesting job and it all ends at the altar or on a lingering kiss. Heroines go off into Barbara Cartland-land of happy ever after.

Life isn't like that. And for lots of people, that life would have no appeal anyway. If you're gay, or if you don't want kids, or if you don't fancy monogamy, or it you want to work and have kids without feeling guilty, then these fairy tale films are just a pain.

Society won't let us have images of the kind of women we could honour and like. We go looking for heroines and role models and come out feeling disheartened. Even the new movies showing the corporate woman, or the woman doing a 'man's' job aren't satisfying or convincing.

Ideology

In the recent Baby Boom Diane Keaton's Manhattan corporate woman turns down success in favour of man and baby. In Overboard Goldie Hawn only discovers bliss when she gets off her ritzy yacht and becomes a downtrodden wife and mother. And we all know about Fatal Attraction. In that the corporate woman is 'exposed' — a woman without a man of her own is a potential psycho!

We have to remember that films reflect ideology not reality. The society we live in is bourgeois capitalism and that ideology permeates the whole of society. The ruling class is able to make their culture the ruling culture. Their values, their ideals dominate art, the media, education.

Most of what we get is just Maggie Thatcher values dressed up in sets and costumes, with the hidden message that life will always be this way. We may know it's a lie, but that doesn't stop us from being swamped by it all, and even going along with it to some extent.

When a film sets out to make you laugh it's hard not to, even though the joke may be sexist, racist or homophobic (as most comedy seems to be!). Movies affect us on an unconscious, as well as a conscious level, so it's hard to disentangle what we really feel about them from what we consciously THINK about them. I've cried at films that I've despised with my head, laughed at films then felt ashamed, and felt really angry at things the rest of the audience seemed to find hilarious.

There are films around that do challenge society's values and that do try to present reality rather than ideology. But they make up a miniscule part of moviemaking and iney aren't ine rums tnat most tum goers see. They are worth catching up on if you feel browned off with the blockbuster circuit, or even if you're not.

Of course, some of the system" films aren't too bad. Crimes of the Heart, a comedy around last year, had great scenes with its three women characters, who played sisters. The relationship between the three was believable and it celebrated the women and their closeness. Women's friendship doesn't get much of a look in in the movies, yet to most women it's one of the great things in their lives — having a friend, sharing thoughts and feelings.

Last year's Business as Usual was another hope giver. Glenda Jackson played a strong, believable woman who gets involved in a political fight about sexism ana uiscoveis a wildic lot about herself. Of course, she was punished a bit because hubby strayed with her not being at home doing a woman's job, but the film was on her side.

Sally Field had a similar complaint made to her when she played a textile worker who got a union started in her factory in the film Norma Rae. In a hilarious scene she rushed around, putting clothes in the washer, throwing food haphazardly into pots, and urging her husband to 'have his way' with her from behind while she caught up with the ironing. He just looked like a clod, and she appeared triumphant.

Stereotype

Movies can try to put women down, but sometimes they break through it. Women manage to transcend suffocating, stereotyped images the films try to sell us.

No matter what role they put her in we know Katharine Hepburn is pretty feisty. And hardly anyone could keep Bette Davis down. Joan Crawford and Greta Garbo seemed worth a dozen men each.

But until we get the films that show you can make choices that are different from the nuclear family without being a freak, or that you can love women rather than men sexually, that you can work and succeed without being a repressed hysteric pining for a husband and kids, that you can have close friendships with women, rather than compete constantly with them for men's attention, that there are other ways to run society — we'll just have to put up with the ones we've got but we shouldn't buy their message.

Since the publication of her book Pornography, Our Blood Dworkin has taken the American feminist scene by storm. Her book Intercourse is likely also to be a feminist bestseller, advertised as part of the feminist book fortnight.

In America, Dworkin's feminism has become massively popular, almost unchallenged. Mary Daly, devoted to creating a new female language to encourage a "cleansing/depolluting of the self by the self" has described Dworkin's new book as "feminist work at its best."

is hardly surprising as both writers come from the same feminist current, cultural feminism, and a very reactionary creed it is too.

Cultural feminism is the American feminist norm, its highly emotive, hyperbolic language permeates through a great deal of literature in America and Britain. Its central point is that 'patriarchy' or what Dworkin calls 'male supremacy, 'man made world' or even 'gynocide' has achieved the absolute domination of women. This gynocide is expressed and maintained through rape, clitorectomy, incest, prostitution, woman hatred in male fantasies. Pornography is the male ideological tool which theorises this murderous sexual hatred of women.

But gynocide is also, if not more so, maintained through the mutually consented-to fuck. Patriarchy is all powerful, there is no escape from it, its historical span is timeless, it is not a system that can be shattered or cracked.

Why, regardless of political and economic reform, regardless periods in history in which women have gained greater sexual freedom. such as the 60s, does the position of women not change? For Dworkin the answer is simple: women are stupid and silly, they don't recognise this state of affairs, they continue to want to fuck men (although for Dworkin this is impossible - women are fucked, i.e they are passive and inactive in sex). She maintains "occupied women will be collaborators more base in their collaboration than any other collaborators have ever been: experiencing pleasure in their own inferiority; calling intercourse freedom.

In fact women who most enjoy fucking are "a living corpse existing for sexual use". Sexual pleasure for heterosexual women living in a 'man made world' means that the woman is empty, dumb, an automaton "being owned and fucked". Dworkin states: "We exist as persons only to the extent that men in power recognise us" for that we must be willing to fuck and then our "will is raped" so we become less human anyway.

Dworkin is nauseating and offensive. Her method is to deliberately use passages of literature in which men discuss sex to illustrate misogyny. The symbolic becomes the literal, words become reality. The Freudian notion that intercourse is an attempt by men to return to the womb is hysterically denounced as proving that all men are incestuous.

Similarly, ( the notion that the Nazi death camps were sadism out of control gives Dworkin the excuse to call men "National Socialists'. story about a woman raped by the devil, constantly defiled until she goes into coma and eventually dies is used to illustrate Dworkin's belief that sexually active women have all physical strength sapped and become mere shadows in real life. A Tolstoyan story of a man who murders his wife in order to save her from his lust is taken to mean that only in death can women be free. Rape, incest, women prostituting their bodies, becomes the language with which Dworkin describes all sex and as a result degrades the trauma of real sexual Violation.

Like a goddess on the far horizon is a different woman. She is Joan of Arc and virgin. Dworkin describes her in terms reminiscent of Christ: "Joan died for the right of physical privacy from which other rights could derive, without which other rights are meaningless - and in this sense she died for and on behalf of all women." Joan "did not want the clothes of sex, she wanted clothing that was a barrier to invathought. As a virgin, she was able 100k, touch, to have a real physical freedom and, according to Dworkin, patriarchy murdered her for her crime.

The virtues which Dworkin stresses in Joan, her virginity, her refusal to ornament herself shows Dworkin's peculiar dislike of modern women. Modern virginity is merely a state of waiting while make up and fashion show a willingness of the modern female to invite invasion and possession. Dworkin's moral code is a strict one indeed, only too frighteningly similar to that of the Right.

Quite clearly sex in our society is distorted, much of male sexuality is ugly and both men and women place too much emphasis on the act of intercourse itself. feminist poem talks of the meaningless syndrome in which men "whang, whang and come". It is a sexuality that gropes in the dark, that is embarrassed and rushed. Women do not explore their own bodies and are told in women's magazines, ourselves and other human beings will inevitably mean that sex cannot be pure, that there will be gross fantasies, sexual failure, that erotic feelings are impoverished But human desire is immensely complex; the mind can imagine a supersexual world that bears little relationship to sex itself. Fantasies of rape and degradement are only real when they are acted upon. What is most difficult for most. feminists to come to terms with is that female desire is often only too similar to that produced by mainstream soft porn. Women's romance books sell millions, and in all the male is the dominant, erect stranger and the woman a quivering wreck. Does this mean then the woman's sexuality is passive? No, women can transform images passivity in an active way. Anybody out on the town on a Friday night will see groups of women together, feet shod in stillettos, clip clop on the pavement, short skirts, bare arms, painted pouting lips. The message is that they want sex, but they are assertive about it to the point of being aggressive.

Andrea Dworkin has a tale about such women. When Joan was sick of women following soldiers for sex she murdered them. Dworkin pleased about it. Cultural feminism is elitist, not only are men hated, but so are stupid women, the ones who like fucking. Only few women are fit for the feminist future, not even the women who have a positive sexual identity towards other women Dworkin is against lesbian erotica. No, it is women who will accept the need to re-establish an "old virginity" and put it upon a pedestal, the women who want to create a new female language and deny the culture and science and knowledge we have learned to use for the oppressed.

All of Dworkin's criteria for real womanhood are negative, hostile, nihilistic. Her sex war is apocalyptic: men are irredeemable, inherent National Socialists and collaborators to be dealt with. I have read very little that is more intense in its dislike of women. My fear is that Dworkin will be uncritically accepted as the dominant feminist voice to the extent that 'feminism' will become a term that we, as socialists, must disassociate ourselves from.

----- pull-quotes -----

woman-hater? By Ruth Cockcroft

"Ten ways to fake an orgasm". Fear, deep alienation from

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 361

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →