USSR: what's at stake
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
• 750% mandate for a further five Cinna Mau 1027 emallerale nrivate neasant farming. No sucl The Sun has taken a firm line on the recent outbreak of soccer hooliganism. •After the mayhem in Germany there can now be no question of lifting the ban. There will be no tears if it is made permanent.... the Europeans do not want us. And we certainly have no right to inflict on them the dregs of our society."
Can this be the same newspaper that habitually refers to Germans as "Krauts" (especially when they're *sour"), the French as "frogs" Spaniards as the "sick senors", etc. etc?
Anyway, the Sun on Thursday carried an in-depth probe into the mind of the yob. They commissioned a "panel of experts" on the subject and came up with some most interesting findings.
JOBS: "Some yobs are unemployed but surprisingly many of the ringleaders are accountants, solicitors and company directors..
"Self-confessed super-yob Paul Scarratt... sees himself as superhero, a patriot and leader of men... they have fantasies about bebarian..
DRINK: "Drink is the driving force behind most outbreaks of mass hooliganism, say the experts." (Well I never!)
SEX: "Yobs, as a breed, find enormous problems dealing with girls... it is only when they grow up and stop feeling the need to prove themselves as macho heroes that they can settle into loving relationships." (Ahh!)
FAMILY: "Yobs often come from broken homes or families which starve their children of affections." (Ahh!)
VIEWS: "Politically British yobs tend to be right-wing. Ironically (why?) they are more likely to back the Tories than Britain's smaller Nazi splinter groups. They are blindly loyal to Mrs Thatcher even though the Prime Minister detests their violent behaviour.
You get the picture then? My only question is why didn't the Sun ask them about which newspaper your typical hooligan reads?
Predictably Peregrine Worsthorne devoted his Sunday Telegraph editorial to the yob question.
Usually Worsthorne's column makes intelligent right-wing reading. But I'm afraid that on the evidence of this week's offering, old Perry seems to be losing his grip. The chap seriously tries to argue that hooliganism is the direct result of "that evil decade, the 1960s, when doctrinaire socialist egalitarians put the whole process in reverse."
The "process" Worsthorne is about is, apparently, the permeation of "courtly conduct" from the top of society gradually downwards. "Thus did the civilising process begin: by making successful careers conditional on courtly - or gentlemanly, as it became known - conduct.
This centuries-long process was, according to Worsthorne, reversed in a few permissive years, two decades ago, and last week's events in Dusseldorf are a direct result.
"It will be a long haul before the recivilising process gets underway again in this country. But a first condition is to recognise that economic inequality is not enough... social authority must be added to economic power," concludes the great thinker!
I suspect tht this last bit is a tacit admission by Perry that there is one big flaw in his argument, viz. the small fact of nine years of Tory rule. I shall maintain a close watch on Perry's column for further worrying signs of mental decline and keep Press Gang readers fully informed of developments.
Even the Sun's "panel of made more sense. What is In the 1980s, the USSR's economic performance has been bad compared to that of the Western economies with their slumps and crises.
Industrial production in the USSR is estimated to be about 40% that of the USA, and agricultural productivity 20 to 25% that of the USA.
The economy is stifling under the dead weight of buggin's-turn, passthe-buck, time-serving bureaucratic mismanagement.
Gorbachev wants to shake up the managers and shake up the economy. He is moving in five main directions. * A drive for discipline, against corruption and alcoholism. * Giving the rules of profit and loss, supply and demand, more scope in the economy. * Exposing corrupt, stick-in-themud bureaucrats to the threat of public exposure and losing their * Stacking top jobs with his own supporters. * Withdrawing from Afghanistan, and negotiating arms cuts with the US, so as to lessen the terrible drain on the USSR of military spending. Results so far?
Gorbachev has suceeded in improving relations with the US. He has replaced 13 out of the 20 members of the Politburo, and 11 out of the 13 members of the Secretariat, but there is still evidence of a lot of conservative resistance within the bureaucracy.
The media have become much less rigid, and there is much more liberty for writers and film-makers. Much of the 'democratisation' programme, however remains on paper.
The proposasi to the ruling party's conference which opens on 28 June include: * Limiting the term of office for all officials to ten years, unless they get At 9.15pm the next two Sundays (with repeats on Wednesdays), Channel 4 TV will be showing an unusual sort of thriller - about a left Labour government being brought down by the unelected Establishment.
Labour MP Chris Mullin wrote the book, 'A Very British Coup' on which the L series is based. When it was published, he discussed it with SO.
Your novel ends with the defeat of the Left. Obviously in writing it you must have had some ideal of how it could have ended in victory. How?
I think Perkins should have done a lot more to mobilise the mass movement. Also, I don't think he should have resigned when he did. He should have stood up to the blackmail.
you had written the story from the point of view of a rank and filer rather than the prime minister, it would have raised different questions. As it is, the main question raised is, 'what should the prime minister have done differently?' The decisions that affect the lives of most people in this country are not taken by those people themselves. What you and I are aiming for is a situation where the decisions that affect the lives of people are taken by the people themselves. Before we can even begin to make progress in that a 75% mandate for further five years. * Secret ballots for all positions in the state and in the ruling party. The ruling party will, however, keep its monopoly over candidates. * Better legal procedures for people to bring complaints against officials. (At present the main method for doing this - a widely-used though ineffective one - is anonymous letters to higher authorities).
And economically? As from 1 January this year, 22,000 out of the country's 37,000 enterprises are supposed to be working on a profitand-loss basis. In fact, most of their profits still go to central ministries, and most of their production is still determined by what the planners in Moscow tell them.
Repeated attempts to shift to market economics in the past, in the USSR itself and elsewhere in the Eastern Bloc, have been ineffective because of the tremendous inertia in the system. The bureaucrats in each sector have great power to conserve the status quo. And since every enterprise is desperate to ensure supplies, the web of vested interest spreads wide. Since May 1987, small-scale cooperatives have been encouraged, especially in service sectors. This means little, however, except bringing part of the black or grey economy into legality.
In Hungary economic reforms like Gorbachev's have been pushed for the last 25 years. The economy is still bureaucratically-regulated -or at least the official economy is. A big black or grey economy has developed, people talk openly about the 'new bourgeoisie' , real wages have fallen about 17% since 1979, and some 25% of the population is below the breadline. show so far. on official figures, the LOO has little to USSR's national income grew only 2.5% last year, while 4.1% growth was planned. The more daring of Gorbachev's associates have called for buying and selling of shares, more bankruptcies, allocation of investment funds by banks on commercial terms, and the end of all central planning outside utilities like electricity supply.
Market reforms have had more effect in China, where agriculture has effectively been transformed from collectivist organisation into LEETPU private peasant farming. No sucl radical moves, however, are plann ed for Soviet agriculture.
What is the socialist alternative? * Disbandment of the police and armed forces, replacement by a workers' militia. * Breaking-up of the bureaucratic hierarchy of administration, and its replacement by a democratic regime of councils of elected and recallable workers' delegates, with freedom to form many workers' political parties. * Workers' control in industry. Free trade unions.
Abolition of bureaucratic privileges: reorganisation of the economy according to a democratically-decided plan. * Abolition of the bureaucracy"s monopoly over information: freedom for working-class newspapers, meetings, radio and TV stations, etc. * Self-determination for the nations. oppressed by the Kremlin.
----- pull-quotes -----
Yobs and nobs
Gorbachev's programme?