Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

USSR: Is it really a revolution?

Socialist Organiser no. 361, 23 June 1988 · scan pp. 1–2 · Eric Heffer · about 1,014 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 1 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 1

CYUIULIUI

limited. They stop far short of self-liberation - and in the letting workers organise USSR, as everywhere, the themselves freely in indepen- liberation of the workers must dant trade unions or new be the task of the workers political parties. All moves for themselves will be moves *Harder work is asked of the workers, but so far they have received little more pay and they are not allowed to drink vodka". That is how Roy Medvedev - a dissident sympathetic to Gorbachev — sums up what the current reforms in the USSR mean for the workers.

Last October workers in a bus factory near the Urals struck against the effect of the reforms on them. They were having to work two or three hours extra a day, and weekends, and still losing £15 a week.

Their factory had previously "fufilled its plan" by turning out buses with 40 or 50 parts missing. Then stricter quality control was introduced. Previously the factory had shipped out 33 or 34 buses each day. Now it had trouble getting 25 through the quality control. The workers lost bonus money.

Deliberate In many other Soviet factories, ill-managed and with outdated equipment, workers must be facing the same problems. It is a deliberate part of Gorbachev's plans to increase inequality of wages - paying more productive or skilled workers more, at the expense of the others - to increase work rates, and to weaken job security. Some 15 million jobs are to be 'shaken out' over the next decade.

Everywhere in the Eastern bloc - Czechoslovakia, Poland, Hungary - workers have supported all attempts at democratic reform; and no doubt Soviet workers welcome Gorbachev's measures of liberalisation, however limited they may be. To have access even to a limted range of views in the media is better than being bombarded by a mind-numbing uniform 'party line'; to be able to vote even between two officially-vetted candidates for works manager is better than having no vote at all.

But the measures workers Tself-organisation bachev and the bureaucracy.

The rights of nationalities are central to democracy in the USSR, a multinational empire where the oppressed nationalities, Ukrainians, Armenians, Latvians, Estonians, and others, between them are the majority of the population.

The issue is already explosive. The Kremlin admits that it has lost control in Nagorny Karabakh, an Armenian enclave in Azerbaijan which wants to be united with Armenia. Armenians have staged a general strike on the Karabakh issue, with support from the local Armenian bureaucracy. There are mass protests in Latvia against Russification.

Corruption

Yet Gorbachev's faction in the bureaucracy is very much a Great Russian faction. Gorbachev has sacked local chiefs in several minority-nationalist areas - accusing them, probably rightly, of corruption -and replaced them by men more in tune with Moscow.

"Try to get your flat repaired. You will have to find a moonlighter to do it for you, and he will have to steal the materials from a building site." What Gorbachev says about repairs to flats is equally true of repairs to shoes, cars, televisions, vacuum cleaners, or fridges. In the USSR you even have to bribe doctors to get treatment.

Certainly Gorbachev's plans for more small cooperative enterprises are better than this. combination of ham-handed bureaucratic planning and wildcat capitalism. But workers will expect few miracles from them - certainly not enough to offset the bad effects of "perestroika' on their wages and conditions in the factories.

For the workers, Gorbachev's reforms are far from being a revolution. What's important about them is that they may shake up and destabilise the system enough for a real revoluagainst the resistance of Gor- tion to be made by the workers. If we hadn't had the contest for Leader and Deputy Leader, the political issues would not be coming to the fore as they are at the present time.

The leadership is being forced to discuss policies, even though they would prefer not to. The debate on unilateral nuclear disarmament has come about precisely because there is a leadership contest.

When Neil Kinnock gave his 'personal position' on television amounted to an attempt to change policy on the hoof.

There has been a very strong reaction to that. Denzil Davies resigned. He was never a unilateralist but nevertheless he did go along with Party policy on the basis of spending the money saved by scrapping nuclear weapons on other armaments. He was ted up with policy being made on television without consultation.

The whole position is in total disarray despite the fact that in the Independent the leader of the Party is now saying that he maintains the policy of the Party. He is quoted from a private luncheon, where he was speaking on the record so that it was printed by the Independent.

It was not a proper statement from the Leader's office. It is an attempt to rebuild bridges and fences. There has been a clear groundswell coming up from the membership of the Party and the trade unions. Neil Kinnock obviously wants to try and maintain the support for the leadership, and to convince unions like the TGWU that there has been no real change in policy.

But if Kinnock's original statement didn't represent a change in policy, people like Peter Shore wouldn't have welcomed it with such open arms. Nor would Bruce Kent from CND have reacted in the way he did. All the serious commentators regarded it as a real move in Party policy.

To me it indicates how correct it was to have the leadership contest. We are doing much better than anticipated, with support coming particularly from constituency parties. There is a very strong body of opinion in the Party which does want a radical socialist programme and policy, and wants the leadership of the Party to carry out such a policy and programme.

It has all been worthwhile, and between now and Party Conferenc

Scan page 2

GANG Gorbachev

----- pull-quotes -----

We were right stand

ed there is a hell of a lot to play for in terms of support,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 361

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →