Science Columns
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Causal links?
Three topics in the scientific and general press last week -leukaemia and Dounreay, miscarriages and VDUs, Alzheimer's disease and aluminium — illustrate the pro\blem of proving a link between harm and its possible causes. - In each case, there is a statistical -link. At Dounreay, there is about six times as much childhood leukaemia as would be expected on average. A study of 1600 Californian VDU operators has shown an 80% greater chance of miscarriage. And, potentially most far-reaching, the risk of getting a type of dementia called Alzheimer's disease increases as the amount of aluminium (Al) in drinking water. More than 3.5 million people in Britain drink water with higher levels of Al than allowed by European Community regulations and research shows a link even at levels below EC limits.
This has alarmed the water authorities who routinely add Al to some water supplies. This is done to get rid of small particles of solid that might protect harmful bacteria from the chlorine that is added to kill them.
Other causes of Al in water in clude acid rain. Al is the third most abundant element on Earth but most of its compounds are insoluble unless the water has been acidified.
Al is also present in tea (!) and may get into food from cooking utensils. Unlike most metals, dissolves slowly in both acids and alkalis. Hence, fruit should not be cooked in Al saucepans (and caustic or washing soda should not be used n them either).
The water authorities have decided to look into alternatives to Al compounds in treating water. They are doing this because this is the first time the possible health hazards of Al have been spelt out, this as yet unpublished reasearch being the best evidence so far.
But is Al responsible for Alzheimer's disease? This tragic disease involves loss of memory; loss of practical abilities such as talking, dressing. using tools; loss of vocabulary and reading; indeed, loss of personality. Unfortunately, the victim may have some idea of his or her condition as extreme anxiety is also found.
Changes in the brain occur, with