[In 1975 the Vietnamese people won a great…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
In 1975 the Vietnamese people won a great victory over the armed might of the US.
They had been struggling against French and then US imperialism for almost 30 years. Their heroism had inspired millions of activists across the world.
Yet today thousands of refugees are fleeing police-state repression and grinding poverty in Vietnam. The country is drained and discredited by its military occupation of Cambodia.
It could have been different. Vietnam is one of the few countries in the world where Trotskyism has had a mass influence. The life of Ta Thu Thau is the story of how that influence was won, and how it was destroyed by Stalinist repression.
Ta Thu Thau was the fourth child of a large and very poor family. His father was a carpenter. In 1925, he began work as a teacher in Saigon. At the age of 20, in 1926, Ta Thu Thau joined the nationalist group Young Annam, which was soon dissolved by the French colonial government.
In 1927 he went to Paris as a student. He joined the Annamite Independence Party (PAI), and soon became a leading figure in it.
In January 1929, following a clash between French right-wingers and PAI supporters, Ta Thu Thau attacked the French Communist Party (PCF) for its failure to _intervene on behalf of the Annamites (South Vietnamese) arrested at this meeting, and wrote about the "bill to be paid by the Colonial Commission of the PCF" for its "counterrevolutionary fractional work" within the PAI. A leaflet written by Ta Thu Thau concluded: *From our unspeakable slavery, we cry out to all the oppressed of the colonies: unite against European imperialism, white or red, if you want a part of the world for yourselves"
But by 1929 Ta Thu Thau had abandoned his earlier nationalist views and entered the Trotskyist Left Opposition. He was 23 years old. He set out his political perspective in a French Trotskyist paper (April 1930):
*The artificially-created indigenous bourgeoisie is not capable of making any revolution... A revolution based on the organisation of the proletarian and peasant masses is the only one capable of liberating the colonies... the question of independence must be bound up with that of the pro¡letarian socialist revolution"
Ta Thu Thau was expelled from France in May 1930. When the clandestine Trotskyist Lett Opposition was formed in Saigon in late 1931, he was one of its founders.
But the group soon split into three factions. Ta Thu Thau organised a group which published a duplicated news-sheet, Vô San ('The Proletarian').
Repression against all the Trotskyist factions was severe, and not long in coming. 41 people were arrested, including Ta Thu Thau.
But in the Saigon manicipal elections of April-May 1933, Ta Thu Thau was able to carry out legal agitation in collaboration with the Stalinist Nguyên van Tao, the nationalists Nguyen an Ninh, Tran van Thach, Le van Thu, Trinh hung Ngâu, and others. This group constituted a 'workers' list' for the elections.
A French-language newspaper, "La Lutte', was published to support the campaign (Annamitelanguage papers were subject to prior censorship), and two candidates from the 'workers' list' won places on the municipal council.
In 1934, this 'united front' of Trotskyists, Stalinists and nationalists formed a group called La Lutte', and relaunched the paper.
Their elections to office were annulled, so the group's members presented themselves anew for the municipal election of May 1935. Ta Thu Thau was among those elected.
Sought by the authorities for *subversive activities by way of the press', , he was given a two-year suspended prison sentence in June 1935. He was arrested again in December 1935..
The coming to power of the Popular Front government in France in June 1936 triggered off a vast , popular movement in Indochina, with strikes in the rubber plantations. in the Arsenal, and on the railways, and peasant demonstrations. This movement took shape as the 'Indochinese Congress' at a meeting in August 1936, principally of militants from the "La Lutte' group and leaders of the constitutional-nationalist party. A committee was formed to prepare a charter of democratic demands.
This 'Congress' movement was banned in September, and Ta Thu Thau was jailed. In the summer of 1937 the French Communist Party - which, because of its Popular Front policy, had shelved the demand for independence for France's colonies - ordered the Vietnamese Stalinists to break with the Trotskyists.
A general strike of railway workers landed Ta Thu Thau back in prison in July 1937. After a hunger strike of 12 days, he was brought back in front of the court on a stretcher.
'La Lutte' became an Annamitelanguage paper, "Tranh dâu' • and now supported the Fourth International. In February 1939 Ta Thu Thau was released from prison, and immediately started campaigning for the Colonial Council elections [Abridged prepared by skyist Group 360. in April. He was elected his comrades.
War broke out. "Tranh dâu' and the group that published it were banned. Ta Thu Thau was deported to the Poulo Condor island concentration camp in October 1940.
After his return from the camp at the end of 1944, Ta Thu Thau worked to build a Socialist Workers' Party. The Japanese coup put an end to French colonial power on 9 March 1945, and replaced it with the government of Bao dai. By the middle of 1945, Ta Thu Thau had made his way to Tonkin (further north), and was helping to publish the clandestine paper of the Socialist Workers' Party of North Vietnam, 'Combat", Ta Thu Thau participated in clandestine workers' and peasants" meetings in the mining areas. After the fall of Japan and the coming to power of the Stalinist leader Ho Chi Minh in August 1945, Ta Thu Thau hoped to get back to South Vietnam, but he was arrested by the Vietminh and assassinated in September 1945.
In 1946 Ho Chi Minh told Daniel Guerin: "He was a great patriot, and we mourn him... but all those who do not follow the line we have laid down will be broken".
from an account the Vietnamese Trotin France].
Scan page 10
!. Les Hearn's Reviews •