Campaign Organiser
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
From September the Government plans to bring in another cheap-labour scheme, 'Employment Training'. For unemployed people over 18, it means working 40 hours a week for dole plus £10. It will replace the Community Programme - which at least pays trade union rates and the abortive Job Training Scheme. No new money will be spent to provide real training. The new 'Employment Training' scheme threatens to be for over-18s what YTS is for 16-18s - cheap labour, and increasingly forced cheap labour. The 'ET' scheme will theoretically be voluntary, but in practice unemployed people will face increasing threats of having their benefit cut off unless they go on a scheme. Clearly the Government is moving towards the US system of The TUC, shamefully, has supported ET. But the new scheme can be stopped! This broadsheet discusses how "Workfare' - working for your dole, Jim Denham looks at the background The Manpower Services Commission came into existence early in 1974, shortly after Edward Heath's Tory government had DETEND been brought down by the miners.
bodies involving representatives of the government, the employers (via the CBI) and the TUC. It gave the TUC leaders the pleasant sensation of having real power and influence in economic policy — which is one reason why they have been so keen to detend it ever since.
At first the MSC was a modest affair with a small budget and just 40 core staff. Its role was to plan and co-ordinate existing training KUN LINO and employment programmes, but not to take over control of them. All of this changed dramatically in the mid-70s, as unemployment rose to the embarrassing level of 1.7 million and youth unemployment reached 15%. The Labour Government (by then led by Jim Callaghan) had to be seen to do something, and the result was the first of the "Special Employment Measures" - the "Youth Opportunity Programme" (YOP) and the "Job Creation Programme"
Over the years such "Special Employment Measures" were to UST take up more and more of the MSC time, money and energy, while other services which actually provided real training - TOPs schemes and Skillcentres - were ruthlessly cut back.
The first suggestion that such schemes should be compulsory came from a Labour minister, Albert Booth, who wanted to deny dole payments to youth who refused a place on YOP.
Permanent
From 1980 onwards, the new Conservative Government accelerated the process of running down TOPs and the old apprentice system and made the "Special Employment Measures" (originally envisaged as temporary stop-gap measures) a major and permanent feature of the economy. By the time YTS replaced the discredited YOPs in 1983/4 and the Community Programme was in operation for the adult unemployed, the budget for "Special Employment Measures" was over £900 million - more than the total MSC budget of three years before.
The TUC gave YTS full support, despite increasing disquiet amongst rank and file trade unionists, who were worried by the high level of "job substitution' (i.e. properly employed workers being replaced by "trainees") and the appalling health and safety record of YOPS.
The TUC leaders replied that they had obtained great improvements including firm guarantees regarding training qualiFour pages Tories' new "Employment fight it.
<ZE IN HIKI STOp MW.
IPAINING CAVILMI ty, health and safety and equal opportunities. They had also convinced the MSC to increase the training allowance from £23.50 to the princely sum of f25!
TUC General Secretary Len Murray was so enthusiastic about the scheme that he personally appeared in YTS advertising!
It was a similar story with Community Programme, which replaced the Community Enterprise Programme in 1982. The old scheme has paid an average of nearly £100; under CP this was cut to £65., Initial opposition from the voluntary sector and individual unions was undermined by the enthusiastic. support given to CP by the TUC. Interestingly, the TUC justified its position by explaining that the government had threatened to introduce a scheme which would pay participants their benefit plus E15-£20.
Restructured
Clare Short describes what happened next: "At the same time (as the introduction of CP) public sector services were constantly cut back. The only money that was available for CP schemes. As public services were cut back, more and more projects caring for the elderly, improving community buildings and restoring the environment were funded by the MSC.
"But the jobs provided were temporary and very low paid. The adult labour market was being restructured in exactly the same way as the youth labour market. Unionisation was weakened and low-paid. Insecure jobs became acceptable alternatives to unemployment."
Now of course, even the old CP seems relatively good when compared miloyment Train proposals real lesson the TUC ought to learn from all this is that even though their participation in the MSC may have delayed some of the worst excesses of the government, the long term result has been to legitimise a continual erosion of the pay, conditions and expectations of unemployed people.
Workfare
The "Workfare" principle that clearly underlies ET would have been totally unacceptable to any sell-respecting trade unionist only a few years ago: now the TUC supports ET on the grounds that if they oppose it the Government will come up with something "worse" (what exactly could be "worse" than the "benefit-plus' ET is not entirely clear).
Even the TUC's much vaunted ablility to veto schemes on the MSC has now disappeared, as the employers have a built in majority over TUC representatives on the new "Employment Commission"
It's time the TUC got out of the MSC/Employment Commission and started to fight workfare. If there ever was a case for staying "on the inside" to fight for "reforms", that time is long gone...
360.
Scan page 6
It seems impossible to imagine any trade union leader accepting a doubling of working hours and a cut in pay for their members, but that is precisely what the TUC did to Community Programme workers on 20 May this year when they voted to support the Government's new work-for-dole scheme, "Employment Training'.
Community Programme workers currently earn about £56 for 20 hours work. Under ET they do 40 hours' work for benefit plus £10.
The Tories aim to push 600,000 people through the scheme every year. That is three times the size of CP. In many areas more people will Protest against JTS. Photo: G. Makin be working for their dole on ET than for any other employer.
The Government claim that ET will succeed as a voluntary scheme because it will attract people on the basis of 'quality training' . The truth is much different. The total money available for training 600,000 ET workers is less than is currently available for the 200,000 CP workers, yet they say CP is being abolished because of its lack of training!
Skill
Martin Fletcher, a l senior manager for NACRO, let the cat out of the bag by saying that NACRO will offer training in such skills as 'mixing' . A very useful "transferable skill, he claimed, because If you can mix cement you can mix a cake". Course two is evidently 'How to bullshit' A very important feature of ET is that two thirds of the workers will be placed in normal workplaces. The aim is to get people working for their dole money next to workers earning a proper wage — one of the best ways of driving down wages for everyone. Many bosses will sack existing employees and replace them with ET labour.
and Safety at Work Act and the Sex and Race Discrimination Acts will be denied to ET participants because the Government will label them 'trainees' rather than employees.
If ET succeeds, it will not be voluntary. How many people do you know who would volunteer to work for their dole?
As JTS proved, the unemployed will say "NO" to work-for-dole. The Government will be forced to introduce benefit cuts and suspensions for people who refuse a place on the scheme ie, make it compulsory.
CENT The last meeting of the TUC General Council voted narrowly to give "conditional support" to the government's new Employment Training Scheme (ET).
This vote came despite the fact that ET plainly fails to meet any of the TUC's much vaunted '5 principles, by which all such schemes are supposed to be judged. These are:
1. All schemes must be voluntary.
2. Schemes must pay the rate for the job.
3. Quality training must be provided.
4. Trainees must have full employee status and protection under the law.
5. Trade union approval must be obtained at local level.
ET will pay just dole money plus £10, doing away with the rate for the job presently paid on Community Programme Schemes, and Employment Minister Norman Fowler has repeatedly failed to give a straightforward assurance that ET will be voluntary.
ET's funding arrangements make talk about 'quality training' a joke, and trainees will not be covered by Employment Protection and anti-discrimination legislation. The unions have already lost their powers to veto schemes at local and at national level.
Edmonds
Despite this the General Council gave T 'conditional support' , to be reviewed again three months after the scheme's introduction in September. The vote was clinched by the GMB General Secretary, John Edmonds, who performed a last minute about-face despite having publicly denounced the scheme for months. Edmonds claimed that a recent letter from Norman Fowler to Norman Willis made significant concessions to the TUC's objections to the scheme. This is nonsense: Fowler's letter contains no new concessions whatsoever. ET remains what it always was: a cheap labour scheme paying benefit plus Temporary, part-time, casual - and E10 to the vast majority of participants.
The General Council's decision was quickly followed by an announcement from the Association of Metropolitan Authorities, giving Labour councils the green light to put in their bids to become ET Managing Agents with access to thousands of cheap-labour trainees. However, NALGO and the TGWU voted against ET at the General Council. These unions hold the key to local authorities' ability to operate ET.
NALGO
NALGO, which has so far led union opposition to the scheme at the TUC, must implement an effective policy at both national and local levels; * Boycott ET at local level. * Refuse to cooperate with drawing up plans for ET.
Refuse to accept ET work placements in council departments. * Demand redeployment of ans council staff whose jobs depend on the existing Community Programme. * Prevent Council facilities being used by private ET agents. * At national level link up with the TGWU to campaign to reverse the TUC's position at this year's Congress. * At local level form liaison committees of the rank and file of all local authority unions, to fight ET.
ET is a major step towards US-style 'Workfare'. It is an attack on the unemployed and on the employed; local autnority jobs will gradually be replaced by cheap labour trainees if ET goes ahead. NALGO must continue to lead the fight against such schemes. We need real training leading to real jobs.
----- pull-quotes -----
the dole? No way-
URSELF! It was one of many "tripartite"
HIND BOURS
Rights Workers rights like the Health
TUIC agrees. to Work. fare' By Jim Denham