Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unity, Not Division!

Socialist Organiser no. 359, 9 June 1988 · scan p. 8 · about 1,375 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The need for workers' unity and socialist politics in th need for workers' unity and socialist politics Speaker: BOB FINE, recently returned from a visit to Cricketers pub, 15 Black Lion (Two minutes from conferance centre)

gays. We want Labour Party and trade For a united and free Ireland, union momte who support our with some federal system to protect basic ideas to become supporters of the rights of the Protestant minori- the paper - to take a bundle of tyl papers to sell each week and pay a For left unity in action; clarity in small contribution to help meet the For a labour movement accessi- democratically contrelled by our ble to the most oppressed, accoun- sapportere through Annual General table to its rank and file, and mili- Mating: and an elected National SUBSCRIBE!

Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post.

Rates(UK) E8.50 for six months, £16 for a year, Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E To:

Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

ORMARD WITH THE OKERS STRUC ent of aNALGO deles to So «Working for Freedom", the report from the NALGO delegation to South Africa, should be welcomed.

It is good to see a trade union in Britain building links with a sister organisation in South Africa. The report is informative and interesting. However, it is politically flawed.

There is no serious analysis of the South African workers' movement and the strategic debate inside that movement.

Let's look at some of the issues. Union Unity The largest trade union federation in South Africa is COSATU, with a paid-up membership of at least three-quarters of a million. There is also the National Council of Trade Unions (NACTU) which claims a signed-up membership of 400,000 and probably has a paid-up membership of 120,000. In addition there are several independent progressive unions outside both COSATU and NACTU.

The problems that divide the two federations and the road to unity require serious debate. Unfortunately Working for Freedom' provides a biased and one-sided view of the WATCH OUT *COSATU, we were told, judges its friends by their actions. One of the cornerstones of COSATU policy is its commitment to uniting the working people of South Africa into one trade union federation. Why then, we were asked, do some organisations declare support for COSATU and its aims, while at the same time they also support and artificially prolong the existence of the smaller trade union bodies which organise in opposition to COSATU? As the determination of COSATU members grows, so does their intolerance of those who sit on the fence'. To take no side is seen as taking a very definite side indeed. The NEHAWU President gave this warning in his address to the launching rally: 'Watch out! We are going to shake that fence and Many COSATU unions have taken a much less sectarian line than that contained in "Working for Freedom"

The giant metalworkers' union, NUMSA, has presented a joint series of wage demands with three NACTU unions in the metal sector. In the chemical sector, CWIU, the COSATU union, is very keen to work jointly with the NACTU chemical workers' union SACWU. During the OK Bazaars strike last year both NACTU and COSATU unions were active in solidarity and support for the strikers' union, CCAWUSA, a COSATU affiliate. -The whole trade union movement in South Africa needs to unite in the face of state repression, the employers offensive and the new anti-labour bill. The attitude expressed in "Working for Freedom" will not help develop that unity.

NALGO should adopt the TUC policy of providing support for COSATU and NACTU unions. NACTU has a public sector affiliate, the National Union of Public Sector Workers, and NALGO should be building support for them as well as the COSATU unions.

We may believe, as Socialist Organiser does, that the best policy is for all the independent unions to unite in COSATU, but we can't refuse solidarity to those fighting oppression because we believe they are in the wrong federation. NACTU is not a tame, collaborationist federation and therefore it deserves solidarity.

Moses Mayekiso. "Working for Freedom" also deals with the question of adopting trade union detainees.

The NALGO leadership have shamed the union by openly opposing the international campaign to free COSATU member and NUMSA general secretary Moses One particularly disgusting episode was the NALGO internasuggested that the Friends of Moses Mayekiso" campaign represented an illegitimate attempt to create a "cult of the personality" around Moses.

Moses Mayekiso is significant because of what he represents. Moses is a socialist, his union NUMSA is committed to the struggle for socialism. Moses and the other comrades from Alexandra are on trial for treason because they linked the struggle of the workers to the struggle in the townships and attempted to build democratic, accountable structures in the community on the model of the workers' democracy of the trade unions.

SYMBOL

Moses is a symbol of the militant, socialist tradition inside the South African workers' movement. Workers are committed to what he stands for. That's why NUMSA stewards have made up songs calling for his release and local COSATU committees have laid plans for protest strike action should he be found guilty.

When Moses' trial started there was a real possibility that he would face the hangman's noose. The charge was treason and it carried the maximum penalty of death.

So we had a situation in which the general secretary of the second largest union in South Africa faced the death penalty for involving trade unionists in the political struggle, and the NALGO leadership opposed any specific campaigns for his release.

In this context the action of the NALGO leadership in attempting to sabotage solidarity work for Moses can only be seen as disruptive and divisive.

The question must be asked, why? Why would a union with NALGO's record of solidarity with the struggle in South Africa oppose a campaign which has received support from Moses' union NUMSA, sell socialist tureaucracies. and other metal unions across the globe, including the AEU in Britain?

The reason is simple. The NALGO international department seem to see their role as champions of one particular viewpoint in the liberation movement in South Africa. They support the political positions of the dominant grouping inside the United Democratic Front, COSATU and the ANC. Anyone whose view of the struggle falls outside this camp is seen as illegitimate and not deserving of support.

One black worker, who was a MAWU organiser alongside Moses in the Transvaal in 1985-6 pointed out the hypocrisy of this approach:

"One is dismayed by reports that certain elements within Britain have attempted to disrupt and smash the campaign to free Moses Mayekiso on the grounds that he is being made a cult figure, etc. Yet these lathe past wish a done just that The attitude of the NALGO leadership must be rejected. All those forces fighting apartheid deserve support. At the same time the solidarity movement must be debate and discussion.

tant against spital.

pluralist. If one group wishes to highlight Mandela and another Mayekiso then that should not be seen as divisive, it should rather be seen as a positive diversity that strengthens the movement. At the moment there are strong reasons why trade unions should support a specific campaign to free Moses.

People who cannot see the difference between diversity and divisiveness will not build a very democratic or free South Africa after apartheid.

Socialism and the Freedom Charter.

Any movement of millions of workers is not homogeneous. Not everyone will agree. The South African workers' movement is just such a movement.

Within its ranks there is a broad and wide-ranging debate about the nature of the struggle. "What are we against?" and "What are we fighting for?" are the two main questions.

Many different answers have been put forward to both these questions, and there are many difContinued centre pages fringe meeting South African trade unions.

BOB FINE, recently returned from trade unionists in South Africa. Monday 13 June, 7.30 paper's deficit. Our policy is Editorial Board. : 6/12 months sub. I enclose E .To: iser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

----- pull-quotes -----

tional department circular which WE

socialism for unity

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 359

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →