Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What it is How Hitler won

Socialist Organiser no. 359, 9 June 1988 · scan p. 4 · about 1,114 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The start of In Sortant. 1930 the Nazis won 6.4 million votes - 18%. The official Communist Partyminimised this. Trotsky called for a workers' united front against the Nazis.

The official press of the Comintern is now depicting the results of the German elections as a prodigious victory of Communism, which places the slogan of a Soviet Germany on the order of the day. The bureaucratic optimists do not want to reflect upon the meaning of the relationship of forces which is disclosed by the election statistics. They examine the figure of Communist votes gained independently of the revolutionary tasks created by the situation and the obstacles it sets up.

The Communist Party received around 4.600.000 votes as against 3,300,000 in 1928. From the viewpoint of "normal" parliamentary notes is considerable even if we ,ake into consideration the rise in the total number of voters. But the gain of the party pales completely beside the leap of fascism from 800,000 to 5,400,000 votes. Of no less significance for evaluating the elections is the fact that the Social Democracy, in spite of substantial losses, retained its basic cadres and still received a considerably greater number of workers' votes than the Communist Party.

The gigantic growth of National Socialism is an expression of two factors: a deep social crisis, throwing the petty-bourgeois masses off balance i pary that would today b tionary party that would today be regarded by the popular masses as the acknowledged revolutionary leader. If the Communist Party is the party of revolutionary hope, then fascism, as a mass movement, is the party of counterrevolutionary despair. When revolutionary hope embraces the whole proletarian mass, it inevitably pulls behind it on the road of revolution considerable and growing sections of the petty bourgeoisie. Precisely in this sphere, the election revealed the opposite picture: counter: 10. 93 penc WORKERS LIBERTY Le Pen: A Hitler for th 95p plus 30p postage from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

359. 'Volunteer' women workers start the day revolutionary despair embraced the petty-bourgeois mass with such force that it drew behind it many sections of the proletariat.

How is this explained? In the past we have observed (Italy, Germany) a sharp strengthening of fascism, victorious, or at least threatening, as the result of a spent or missed revolutionary situation, at the conclusion of a revolutionary crisis in which the proletarian vanguard revealed its inability to put itself at the head of the nation and change the fate of all its classes, the petty bourgeoisie included.. This is precisely what gave tascism its peculiar strength in Italy. But at present, the problem in Germany does not arise at the conclusion of a revolutionary crisis, but just at its approach. From this, the leading Communist Party officials, optimists ex officio, draw the conclusion that fascism, having come "too late", is doomed to enevitable and speedy defeat. (Die Rote Fahne). These people do not want to learn anything. Fascism comes "too late" in relation to old revolutionary crises. But it appears sufficiently early — at dawn — in relation to the new revolutionary crisis. The fact that it gained the possibility of taking up such a powerful starting position on the eve of a revolutionary period and not at its conclusion, is not the weak side of fascism but the weak side of Communism.

Fascism in Germany has become a real danger, as an acute expression of the helpless position of the bourgeois regime, the conservative role of the Social Democracy in this regime, and the accumulated powerlessness of the Communist Party to abolish it.

If the Communist Party, in spite of the exceptionally favorable circumstances, has proved powerless seriously to shake the structure of the Social Democracy with the aid of the formula of "social fascism" then real fascism now threatens this structure, no longer with wordy formulas of explosives. Not matter how true it is that the Social Democracy prepared the blossoming of fascism by its whole policy, it is no less true that fascism comes forward as a deadly threat primarily to that same Social Democracy, all of whose magnificance is inextricably bound up with parliamentary-democratic-pacifist forms and methods of government.

The policy of a united front of the workers against fascism flows from this whole situation.

The social crisis will inevitably produce deep cleavages within the Social Democracy. The radicalisation of the masses will affect the Social Democratic workers long before they cease to be Social Democrats. We will inevitably have to make agreements against fascism with the various Social Democratic organisations and factions, putting definite conditions to theileaders in full view of the masses.

In July 1931 the CP made a "united front" - with the Nazis, by supporting their rolande campaign against the Social Democratic state goremmens of Prussia.

To come out into the streets wit the slogan *Down with th Bruening-Braun government!" at time when, according to the relationship of forces, it can only be replaced by a government of HitlerHugenberg, is the sheerest adventurism. The same slogan, however, assumes an altogether different meaning if it becomes an introduction to the direct struggle of the proletariat itself for power. In the first instance, the Communists would appear in the eyes of the masses as the aids of reaction; but in the second instance the question of how the fascists voted before they were crushed by the proletariat would have lost all political significance.

Consequently, we consider the coincidence of voting with the fascists not from the point of view of some abstract principle, but from the point of view of the actual struggle of the classes for power and the relationship of forces at a given stage of this struggle.

Such a "sudden" at first sight zigzag (of July 21) did not at all fall like a thunderbolt from the clear sky, but was prepared by the whole course of the past period. That the German Communist Party is governed by a sincere and burning aspiration to conquer the fascists, to break the masses away from their influence, to overthrow fascism and to crush it - of this, it is understood, there can be no doubt. But the trouble is that, as time goes on, the Stalinist bureaucracy strives more and more and more to act against fascism with its own weapon, borrowing the colours of its political palette, and trying to outshout it at the auction of patriotism. These are not the methods of principled class politics but the methods of petty-bourgeois competition.

It is difficult for one to imagine a more shameful capitulation in prinTurn page 9 to

----- pull-quotes -----

the slump the Nazis' triumph

How ultra- radical demagogy helped the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 359

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →