Fight Kinnock on home ground!
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Kinnock on home g
FOR AFAIRER, BETTER BRITAINI call for a new Richard Kuper and Michael Ball are understandably dissatisfied and dissillusioned with the response of the left to 9 years of Tory rule. They reject Kinnock's New Model Labour Party and the sectarianism of much of the revolutionary left.
But then they throw in the towel and opt for a new party based on the Socialist Conference network.
It is true that the labour movement is demoralised and weakened after defeats and betrayals. The Labour left which was vigorous and optimistic in the early '80s is now more tired and cowed.
Meanwhile a lot of manufacturing industry has collapsed and the service sector has grown. Many more women are now in waged work. We clearly cannot operate any longer on a conception of the labour movement. as composed of car workers and dockers.
The world has changed, but the Labour Party is still the party of the working class. The ability of the Labour leadership to demoralise and sell out rests on the support it has in the working class. The campaigns that Kuper and Ball point to as creating an 'independent left' all come up against the question of the The NHS workers very much wanted Labour Party support for their strikes. The anti-Alton campaign demanded that the Labour Party should honour party policy The traditional left' in or out of the Labour Party, sees the eclipse of the old labour movement as temporary — and maintains it is the only effective framework in which the new social movements can pursue their aims. Like many others, we would argue the converse: that separate identities and differentiation within the working class will become more, not less, important. Partly these are the product of the process whereby capital ceaselessly disorganises subordinated classes; but partly they are a response on a new basis to capital's disorganising processes.
So rather than accepting the traditional hierarchies of the labour movement our aim should be to forge a new alliance between the new social forces and a transformed trade-union movement.
Process
Where are we in that process?
There has been a growing number of independent socialists since the late 1960s, mainly ex-members of the revolutionary groups, inhabiting what their former comrades generally call 'the wilderness'.
-Socialist Organiser *O Box 823. London SE15 AA 91-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monay or by phone. monday evening ditor: John O lasmony Typesetting Upstream Ltd (TU)
01-358 134d ublished by Socialist Organiser. Pl ox 823. London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Signedrarticles do not necessarily reflect the view of Socialist Organiser Photo: John Harris and impose a three-line whip. If another left party existed it would have to work with and pressurise the Labour Party on these issues. Even the SWP has ended up selling papers outside Labour Party meetings. Since it is possible for the Ileft to work in the Labour Party we must work there - or artificially limit our struggle.
Kuper and Ball would side-step this fight. But abandoning the Richard Kuper ar Mike Ball argue 1 a new left party.
What they share in common is a rejection of the old party-building approach with its focus on the moment of seizing state power: from it all other events and struggles derive their meaning and were ultimately significant only insofar as they served as recruiting grounds for the party. Too many people, working-class militants and shop stewards among them, have experienced this as minipulative, and party discipline as arbitrary. Its success in maintaining influence in any significant working class campaign is limited (though its role in defensive struggle and solidarity work should not be understimated).
There is another more-or-less independent left, much of it oriented around the Labour Party. It is in many respects a new left with a relatively high proportion of younger members, including many women and Blacks, especially those whose outlook has been formed by the experiences of community and social movement struggles, often derisively called "single issue' campaigns.
two experiences: Fist washerat of labour local government at the GLC and elsewhere. Second was the 1984-5 miners' strike. In the process the Tories' true colours were, of course, displayed. More surprising to some was the mealy-mouthed, grudging attitude of Kinnock & Co. They more or less disowned the two most important national leaders (Ken Livingstone and Arthur Scargill) and the aspirations of all those they represented, helping to send those struggles down to defeat.
A whole layer has been politicised in a non-Labourist way by these events. Current struggles around abortion, Clause 28, the poll tax, Labour Party to the right wing won't do anything for the working Kuper and Ball look to the Greater London Council for their inspiration. Their rose-tinted view of the left in local government is its early class-struggle commitment to the debacle of 1985.
But it was after all a Labour GLC!
Kuper and Ball draw their inthe education reforms, and the NHS are certain to reinforce that process. The possibility of reforging an independent left is stronger than at any time since the early 1970s.
What is necessary to realise this possibility? 1) Active extra-parliamentary resistance must be encouraged. The role of sympathetic MPs (whether they acknowledge it publicly or not) is to use parliament as a forum to aid struggles outside it. It is not to subordinate those struggles to the supposed electoral needs of Labour. 2) There must be an ongoing re-evaluation of the ideas of the left; we can't afford to respond to Labour's policy review by reasserLayer ting old truths. Some central issues have got to be thought through afresh, to take account of changes in the international scene, the impasse of social democracy etc. For instance, what are the possibilities of national economic planning today, given Britain's perculiar place in. the world economy? What possibilities are there of democratic control of publicly provided services given the pressure to remain "competitive' and the failure of previous models?
3) In the later 1980s there are very few independent left organisations. The Socialist Conference, which has yet to prove itself, is one of them. If it is to play an important part in rebuilding the left it must demonstrate its ability to develop new ideas and mobilise people around them. As an essential step, it must be democratised and rooted locally and regionally. 4) The central importance of 'democratisation' must be recognised. It provides the key to 'empowering' all the diverse groups thrown into opposition by the realities of Thatcher's Britain. These now include social forces which have traditionally shown some hostility to Labour but who have been aroused similar to Hilary Wainwright's in her recent book "Labour a tale of two parties". . Wainwright sees the local government left, linked up with the famous 'new social forces' as a new Labour Party growing in the womb of the old. spiration not from the struggles inside the labour movement which created a radical GLC - but from the souped-up US-style pressure group/client group politics which the GLC turned to as it moved from ng if not mobilised by their concern for the defence and extension of civil rights and/or welfare provision. 5) There is a need to recognise the urgency of building an independent socialist party to give expression to the spirit of opposition, of resentment - and also of openness to new ideas — which is widespread on the left. At the same time there is the need to experiment with new forms of party organisation which transcend both the dead hand of bureaucratic control so typical of Labour and the centralist throttling of Leninist-inspired forms. 6) Finally there is a need to recognise that this party is not immediately on the agenda. It will not be built until the suspicions which exist among its constituent elements have been overcome. There are three aspects to this process.
First the recognition that the question of whether the Labour Party can be transformed into such a party does not have to be resolved in advance. We don't believe the Labour Party can be so transformWE WELCOME BENN AND HEFFER CHALLENGING THE LABOUR LEADERSHIP.
IT GIVES SOCIALISTS A CHANCE TO RAISE THE ARGUMENTS...
Socialist Socialist Organiser 359.
Our movement hasn't
represented oppressed groups, hasn't taken up their needs. We must fight to make it do so. That is. straightforward although very hard work.
But what Kuper and Ball are talking about is something very different. What underlies their article is a feeling that the working class is dead or hopelessly disunited and so we have to build a new movement out of disparate "new social forces"
The working class is far from dead. It is changing both in composition and in the sort of work people do. We have to understand that. But the working class and the labour movement is still the force for change within society.
We have to fight to make that movement representative, democratic, to politically re-arm our movement, and to throw out all the old reactionary semi-stalinist ideological baggage that clogs it up. The last thing we should do is abandon ship.
Kuper and Ball's project is a recipe for going nowhere. Instead, we need to reclaim our movement. We need to fight Neil Kinnock on his home ground.
We need to organise the biggest possible campaign in support of Tony Benn and Eric Heffer. To take the socialists, the supporters of Benn and Heffer, out of the Labour Party, will help no-one except those who want to convert Labour to pale-pink neo-Thatcherism. Richard Kuper's and Mike Ball's article is reprinted below party ed but we recognise we cannot prove this beyond reasonable doubt. Al the same time, there is nothing to prevent non-Labour Party members on many aspects of the socialist project.
Second, the demonstration in practice that differences in people's experiences and needs can be recognised and accepted while working together for common causes. In other words, developing new ways of bringing together distinct social forces is a precondition for the emergence of a political movement claiming hegemony over large sections of the left.
Finally, the shared elaboration of a political programme not as a sum of all sectional demands but as a unification of the shared interest in a new and forceful opposition both to Thatcherism and to any revival of the old-style corporate social democracy which has been tried and found wanting. In this process, no section can afford to regard itself as the 'natural leadership', around which everyone else must orbit.
ABOUT WHY You SHOULDN'T BE IN THE LABOUR PARTY!
Socialist
----- pull-quotes -----
(Article abridged from 'Interlink').