Insight unsound
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
As the controversy surrounding the SAS Gibraltar shootings rumbles on, it becomes increasingly obvious that much of the British press has been acting as little more than propaganda outlets for the government and the Ministry of Defence.
Press reaction to Thames TV's Death on the Rock was entirely predictable: near hysterical denunpathisers" (known IRA sym- ciations of the programme and its etc etc) and a vicious smear campaign against witness Carmen Proetta. Leading the baying pack was the Sunday Times, which (unlike the Sun, Mail, Express and the rest) is generally considered a 'quality' paper with reputation for bold investigative journalism.
This reputation is largely founded on the past exploits of the 'Insight' team, who in their heyday ('60s and early "70s) notched up a series of dramatic exposes and almost single-handedly brought the Distillers Company to book over the Thalidomide scandal.
Since the Digger installed the craven Andrew Neil as editor, *Insight' has had its wings clipped. The rich and powerful are now but rarely the subjects of "Insights' investigations: more often it is people who have in one way or the other displeased Downing Street. Since the Gibraltar shootings the Insight' banner has, in effect, become a flag convenience for the government/MoD version of events and a useful cover for government inspired smear campaigns against those with the temerity to challege the official line.
It is a sign of the times that the ST's "top investigative team'" has itself been investigated and convincingly exposed by another (albeit Irish) newspaper the Sunday Tribune. The Insight' hatchet-job on Death on the Rock' had made extensive use of 'statements' obtained from two witnesses, Stephen Bulloch and Josie Celecia, both of whom were reported as emphatically contradicting Carmen Proetta's version of events. The Tribune tracked down Mr Bulloch and Mrs Celecia and found that both had been totally misrepresented by the Insight' report.
According to Private Eye some of the 'Insight' team have protested about distortions to their copy.
One, Rose Waterhouse, has written Are Socialist Organiser has come under critical fire for what we have said about Gorbachev, and about Gorbachev and Reagan.
So let's discuss the issues in question-and-answer form, so that nobody can misunderstand what we are saying.
Isn't it good if Gorbachev and Reagan make the world a safer place by military agreement, even if it is only a little safer?
Of course it is! But we should not exaggerate what has been achieved. Only a very small part of the nuclear arsenal which threatens humanity with annihilation has been destroyed.
One measure of what has been achieved is that the warheads from those US missiles which will be destroyed by agreement will simply be remounted on other rockets! The USSR will probably do the same.
Any lessening of tension and military competition is good, but let's keep our eyes on what's really going on.
But why denounce Gorbachev? He represents the best thing at the top in the Soviet Union for a long time. He has got lots of enemies who may defeat him in his drive for 'openness' (glasnost) and reconstruction' (perestroika).
What does he mean by 'openness' and 'reconstruction"? Openness is good. So far it has taken the form of a small eruption of truthfulness in what the Russian people get as officially permitted The leading USSR papers are called Izvestia ('News') and Pravda ('Truth'). It is an old joke that there was no news in Izvestia and no truth in Pravda. So far glasnost has meant a little news and a little truth.
But only a little. Pravda still reported the recent strikes in Poland as an affair of wreckers By John O'Mahony plotting to destroy the economy. And the degree of 'openness' is still entirely decided from on high. Workers in the USSR do not have the right to make their own investigation and publish their onw papers and magazines.
Yes, but Gorbachev has made a start. Why be so sour?
Because the old system served a ruling elite — the bureaucracy which runs the state and the economy - and they are still in They have found that they cannot rule effectively in the dark, so they want to bring in a bit of light. They are determined to control how much light. They are tinkering with the system, not transforming it. They are making changes to keep themselves in control, not to relinquish control.
But won't Gorbachev take things further? After all, glasnost is his Gorbachev is the leader of the bureaucrats. He is committed to their system. He is a moderniser in the interests of the bureaucracy. He is the chosen Tsar of the bureaucratic elite.
How can you be sure of that?
Because Gorbachev is the second, not the first, reforming Tsar. Nikita Khrushchev was the first. He took over soon after Stalin died in 1953. He carried through what were, for the time, far more radical changes than Gorbachev even proposes now.
He opened Stalin's slave-labour camps. He allowed critical voices to be heard for the first time in a quarter of a century. He told some of the truth about Stalin's reign of terror.
He eased the tensions. But he did not change the system basically. All power remained in the hands of the ruling 'party'. Opposition parties were still illegal - especially working-class socialist opposition parties. Trade unions, to organise workers to defend themselves against the bureaucratic management, remained illegal, and the workers were still forced into pseudo-unions modelled on the "labour fronts' with which the Nazis replaced the German labour movement in the 1930s.
Khrushchev was a great improvement on Stalin, to be sure. But after Khrushchev came a relapse. The USSR did not go all the way back to Stalin's system of terror, but it went quite a long way back.
And it was under the reforming Stalinist Tsar Khrushchev that the Russians reconquered Hungary, destroying the general strike with which the workers of Hungary contested control of the means of production with the bureaucrats in late 1956.
Maybe. But Gorbachev is the so far.
He certainly has not eased the condition of the workers of the USSR as much as Khrushchev did. In any case, we can't scale down the socialist programme for the USSR to suit Good King Mikhail Gorbachev. We need: • An end to the political monopoly of the bureaucracy (the so-called 'Communist Party') • Freedom to organise for opposition parties • An end to censorship and the bureaucrats' monopoly over the media • Free sell-determination IOr the nationalities of the USSR • Workers' control of industry • Free elections name ('soviets') • Free trade unions Prancel rule by working-class rule. If Gorbachev helps the workers of the USSR to realise this programme, then it will be because he has stirred things up so the workers move both against his conservative opponents and against Gorbachev himself. But, after all, Gorbachev is getting Russian troops out of Afghanistan.
Good! Now let him withdraw the Russian army from Eastern Europe. Let him leave Poland, Czechoslovakia, and Hungary, in peace.
He won't. He is withdrawing from Afghanistan because of the military setbacks over eight years and because he wants to channel resources away from the war and towards "perestroika' . That does not mean he will give up Eastern Europe.
Well, isn't perestroika a good thing?
It depends. What the statised economy in the USSR really needs mubar mantral and nolitical WOTKCES CULTUR Ponuval democracy. Gorbachev won't have that. So instead he is bringing in wasteful market mechanisms under state control. This hybrid offers no real solution.
The rulers of the USSR tried it over 20 years ago, and the experiment died at birth because of opposition to it from lower-level bureaucrats. The rulers of Hungary have been trying it for many years, and they are deep in an economic There will be opposition from the workers, too - for perestroika means a shake-up and the risk of unemployment for the workers. Yes. But Gorbachev does represent an improvement.
Maybe. But Gorbachev is a reforneed a revolution in the USSR, not mild, tinkering, insecure moves