Socialism or SDP Mark II?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Labour must not transform itself into pale-pink SDP Mar a pale-pink SDP Mark The full NEC of the Labour Weekly. The capitalist Party has before it a number of stronger than ever.
The difference between "Indocuments which have emerged dustry and Society" and "A Prothrough the joint NEC/Shadow ductive and Competitive Society" is Cabinet policy making commit- firstly that there is no real analysis tees. At this stage these are draft of capitalism in it and secondly, reports. Some minor alterations even on public ownership it is much more flabby and revisionist. What and re-drafting could still take Manny said about "Industry and place, but it seems that the basic Society" can be said about this attitudes and proposals are document, but even more so. As more or less settled. you are aware, Manny was by no means at all times on the Left, but Take the draft report of the The recognised that you could not Policy Review Group called A Productive and Competitive change society without public ownership Economy". Unless the document is Bearing in mind what he said, let fundamentally changed, I hope us take a closer look at the present Party Conference will reject it. It is document. It says in paragraph 1.1. basically non-socialist; it could have "Labour's aim is to develop a talent been drawn up by a committee based economy for the 1990s and headed by Dr. David Owen. It is, in beyond". What exactly does that my view, a right-wing SDP docu- mean? Such a statement could have ment. Although it has some good come straight out of a Tory or SDP points, it is a document that even Manifesto. It is a series of words some Tories could accept. I am sure which add up to nothing. Ted Heath would find little wrong Then in paragraph 2.2 it says, with it. No wonder Dr. Owen can *The right balance must be struck now say he could, under certain cir- between what the market and those cumstances, re-join the Labour operating it can do for themselves, Partyand the economy in the short run, This policy document is far more and what Government can do to revisionist in a right-wing direction establish a framework in which than the one which caused so much medium and longer-term respontrouble in 1957, i.e. sibilities for investment, for imSociety and Public Ownership" proving competitiveness and for That document, after fierce debate, harnessing the new technology, can was carried at Labour's 1957 Con- be sustained"!! ference by 5,309,000 for, to I have to say, clearly and frankly, 1,276,000 against. that that adds up to an abandonIt is interesting to note those who ment of a socialist strategy and a were wholeheartedly in favour socialist objective for society. No without any reservations, and those wonder Peter Walker at the House who were against the document. of Commons Press Gallery lunch The document was supported by last Wednesday could say that there Bill Carron, right-wing leader of the is now little difference between the AEU, but equally clearly rejected Labour and Tory parties.
Take for example, paragraph 2.4, the Executive is to be congratulated which talks of "These failings can on this analysis of capitalism, this only be tackled with a macrocondemnation of capitalism. But economic policy of steady expanobviously the implication is this: if sion, competitive exchange rates capitalism is condemned, then the and low inflation". Such a stateonly alternative is a further pro- ment could surely have come from gramme of public ownership in the the mouth of Mrs. Thatcher herself. national interest, and not as one of In paragraph 2.9, it talks of a the vital features in this document *new partnership between insuggests, to bolster up the Stock Ex- dividual and society" and goes on change in the future. If we endorse to say, "It will be the task of a this document and if the next Labour Government to meet its Labour Government implements it, responsibilities, working with in the future we shall not have a business and with the community to political conference, we shall have a ensure that investment is made, meeting of shareholders with the technology is harnessed, economic directors on the platform; and the development is balanced and susDaily Herald will no longer be the tainable. We are confident that inParty newspaper, it will be the dividuals and firms will respond by Financial Times . Today there is taking advantage of the opporno Daily Herald or even a Labour tunities that open up, and that that 60p.
Tories!
Rebuild the Left!
4NA.
358, Eric Heffer response will in turn create a more successful creative society."
That could have come straight out of an SP policy document.
It underlines what I have already said in my book, "Labour's Future", that some people in the Labour Party want to abandon socialism and create an SDP Mark Il, thereby accepting that the capitalist system, with some minor changes, is here to stay. It is the opposite of our socialist conceptions.
It is interesting to note that not one word is said in the document about working with the trade unions. In paragraph 2.15, for example, it says it is essential that Government agencies and local authorities work in partnership with firms, the Confederation of British Industy, trade associations and chambers of commerce so that the process of policy-making and industrial development is one of concerted action."
Apparently: concerted action between capitalist firms, without the trade unions!
This is a dreadful document. Paragraph 2.16 talks about * ... the changes needed to improve our competition" and says that "They must be indentified in consultation with industry so that the areas which offer the best return... " can be determined".
The whole document is obsessed with competition. This is the hallmark of the capitalist system. I always understood that as socialists we believe in production for use, not for profit based on competition. That concept is now clearly being abandoned and competition placed at the centre of Labour's policy. If it were a matter of some degree of competion in a publicly owned socialist economy, that would need to be considered, but here it is competition without a fundamental change in society. And that, in essence, is to accept thatcher's agenda.
This comes particularly public ownership is mentioned in the document. It talks of a new approach. A new approach is one thing, but abandonment of public ownership which this really is, that is surely something else.
Instead of genuine public ownership, as advocated by such diverse people as Nye Bevan and Neil Kinnock, when writing in the Labour Monthly of December 1974Herbert Morrison, Manny Shinwell, Clement Atlee etc., we are offered the "public interest company" , which will have targets agreed, and "strengthened regulating authorities which will have the power to monitor and enforce those standards" . The standards? "Service to the consumer, investment, pricing policy and other measures of economic performance"
The document then goes on to say, 'In some cases, a change in ownership or control as well as regulation may prove necessary if the consumer and economic interest is to be fully safeguarded" . What a big deal! Forgive me if I am wrong, but I thought that public ownership under democratic control as advocated in Clause IV of the Party's constitution was essential to get rid of class society and the privileges that arise from it; and that it was the essential means with which to transform capitalist society into a democratic socialist one, so that power would be transferred to working people and their families.
Today, with the tremendous adEuropean countries create a European Socialist society.
The document talks of "Developing a new agenda for European co-operation" '. Unfortunately, like the rest of the document it is words without context. The real issue which is not seriously raised is who is to own and control the means of production, distribution and exchange?
What are we to do about the monopolies and the multinationals?
Surely it is important that we grasp the nettle and to understand the real issues - who has the power and how do we transfer it from the capitalist companies to the people?
I call upon members of the Labour Party to oppose this document and to defeat it at Conference. In doing so, I would like to refer to a speech made by Mr G. Fear of Crosby CLP at the 1957 Labour Party Conference, and I apologise for the lengthy quotation. He said *We had a great inheritance passed on to us by our forebears, and pis erredant 1945 by Mr. Atlee and brilliant, faithful colleagues. Now we have something entirely different. People are saying that you can dirty your hands by dealing with capitalism.
There are some of us... who… are still of the the opinion that capitalism is an evil thing. If you do not believe me, I wish you to go back and get George Lansbury's book, *These Things Shall Be" and Fred Henderson's book, 'The Case for Socialism" .. If you are going to employ socialist funds In perpetuating capitalism you have a nell of a responsibility to posterity. In any case you are going to lose the right to call yourselves a Socialist Party. You will not be a Socialist. Party, but a Reformist Party.
You are never going to attack the vitals of capitalism in the way we intended"
That was the authoritive voice of the Merseyside rank and file of the Party. The truth is, Labour did not. win the 1959-General Election two years later. Its Gaitskillite reformism, its compromise on basic socialist issues did not win. Gaitskill backtracked on too many Issues. especially on the basic question of a socialist transformation of society. His leadership was a disaster.
Do not let us suffer from that same fate again. Labour did not. lose in 1979 because of our Socialist. Programme. Under Harold Wilson. and James Callaghan we had, in fact, retreated from it, and in 1983, the right-wing SDP split had confused the people. Those who say our policies were wrong misread the situation.
It is not softly, softly that wins election. It is boldness. A bold policy won for Labour in 1964 and again in 1966. Labour lost support when it failed to carry through its "revolution" and turned on its trade union supporters.
It should be remembered what Gaitskill said in reply to the 1957 debate at Conference. He said, ".
the millions of electors we have to convince, including millions of Labour supporters, are not quite so well educated in socialism as that, and they will not be satisfied, if when they ask Why are you proposing to take over this industry?
you simply reply Because that socialism"
It is the same type of argument we hear today. It is the argument of retreat and compromise, of SO-called realism: in fact it acceptance of the capitalist status quo. The answer to that argument is that we have to relate the argument for socialist policies to the lives of the people.
For example, if we want safety at sea, we need public ownership of ships, ferries, docks and shipbuilders, with the needs of the people put first. Had we had genuine socialist public ownership we should not be in the situation we are in today with the Seafarers strike and the Zeebrugge disaster.
We must advocate People before Profits.
If we put service before all else, it must be through public ownership. Don't let us apologise for it. Let us go out and explain why it is required.
----- pull-quotes -----
left's Eric Heffer MP, the Heffer deputy leader candidate for argues that
Back Fight the and H
Available plus 30p pos from SO, PO
rain with a publicly owned socialist economy can, together with other