Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Stalinism: the most implacable

Socialist Organiser no. 358, 2 June 1988 · scan p. 8 · about 1,439 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

SUBSCRIBE!

Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post. Rates(UK) £8.50 for six months, £16 for a year, The original idea of socialism in its empirical form and later in its most articulate and scientific form, that is to say, Marxism, arose in response to the social conditions of exploitation, injustice, and alienation of the human being. These conditions, which have prevailed in all societies accounted for by history and have taken their most sophiticated and extended forms in capitalist society, still persist unfortunately in postcapitalist and presocialist societies with their statified economies under bureaucratic dominion.

The first triumphant Marxist revolution took place on this planet approximately seventy years ago. This triumph, based on the upriand of the Russian workers peasants, was directed successfully by the Bolshevik Party, which was headed by men of great talent, boldness, and indomitable faith in the socialist cause: Lenin, Trotsky, Bukharin, Zinoviev, Kamenev.

The monopoly and the centralization of power in the hands of the Bolshevik leadership, which previously had been a key element in the victory of the revolution, later opened the door for Stalin to establish and consolidate his dictatorship. In addition, there was the isolation of the revolution, the depoliticisation and exhaustion of the masses, the weakening of the revolutionary leadership as a result of Lenin's death, together with the fact that Trotsky was surrounded by the counter-revolutionary bureaucracy.

Stalin created the most implacable dictatorship and tyranny known in modern history, betraying the foundations and principles of Marxism. Instead of using the truth as a battering ram and revolutionary weapon, he imposed lies and falsification of history as his modus operandi. Instead of abolishing the exploitation of man by man, he sent from ten to fifteen million Soviet citizens to work as slaves in Siberian "work camps." Instead of a respectful and comradely treatment of Lenin's Bolshevik companions, he set up a monstrous parody of justice with his Moscow trial frame-ups, as a result of which most of them were executed in the basement of Lublianka prison or exiled to Siberia.

Two years later, Leon Trotsky, the organiser of the Red Army and close collaborator of Lenin was also murdered in Mexico City by a GPU agent. For the "dictatorship of the proletariat Stalin substituted "the dictatorship over the proletariat" penetrating and invading every area of Soviet life with an absurd and asphyxiating bureaucratic control so that now, seventy years after the October revolution, the Soviet Union is still trailing behind the rest of the industrial world in many icientific and technical fields as well as in housing and the general stanlards of living of its citizens.

And as a grand finale, Stalin committed high treason against his ›wn country, the land of Lenin, when in his paranoia he decapitated he Red Army by executing its most experienced and brilliant generals and officers only a short time He griet or the sover hon ne the survival of the Soviet Union in seril. The list of Stalin's crimes is anti-socialist Dureaucracies. too long and varied to waste more time on.

It is shameful for humankind that in our time we have had to witness political regimes such as Stalin's. They have to be openly denounced and wiped out of any future page of history.

If Gorbachev and his leadership really want to succeed in achieving perestroika and glasnost and return to the road of authentic socialism, it is a sine qua non that light should be cast on all of the crimes of the Stalinist era. All the names of the innocent victims have to be made known and must be cleared. The historical truth must be reestablished. Among this long list of victims we have to emphasise once more the indomitable Russian revolutionary and Marxist theorist Leon Trotsky. He was a key protagonist in the triumph of the Russian Revolution and afterwards he became its fiercest defender in a deadly fight against the Stalinist counterrevolution. Leon Trotsky became the most calumniated and persecuted revolutionary on the planet. Until now, glasnost has not succeeded in freeing him of all these calumnies and neither has it allowed the publication of his writings and free gays.

For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.

For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.

For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.

discussion of them inside the Soviet Union. Leon Trotsky will show us how far glasnost will advance. The avalanche of lies, falsifications, and calumnies they have covered for more than half a century have to be exposed and eliminated forever! Free and open discussion has to be

established as it was at the beginning of the Bolshevik Party.

In history there is little place for experimentation. Most of the events have to be solved as they occur.

That's when one understands the extraordinary force and richness of the open, direct and violent polemics that took place within the ranks of the Bolsheviks during Lenin's time, when ideas emerged as incandescent iron ingots which were impetuously hammered out by the blacksmiths of the revolution -forging the tools for its victory.

This was the great secret of the Bolsheviks' strength and success. The mediocrity of Stalin's court of adulation came later.

The last pages of history have shown us that the abolition of private property in the means of production is not a magic formula that will automatically take humanity into an earthly paradise.

A second element of great importance of reaching socialism is the solution of the equation of power. As with property, it has to be shared by all the working sectors of society. If the power is only in the hands of one social group, chances are that this group will sooner or later keep the best and the most of what society offers and will not have very much concern about what is left over for the remaining groups. The third important factor is to establish an adequate level of abundance which will permit the fufilment of all human needs. Scarcity will always generate stratification of society with inequalities on a national and international scale. The fourth factor will be the orevailing of internationalism.

"Socialism" behind national borders will always be a potential source of conflicts and wars.

Man came out of the cave seminaked. He has reached the moon, has freed the energy of the atom, developed the super computer, and created a new science of genetic engineering. Is he then unable to create a more just and harmonic social organization on this earth? Or has human history reached its last page?

Until the present, the train of history has not reached its final. destination: authentic socialism. It had to make a previous stop in an inhospitable desert. Fortunately, little, by little, the train is resuming its forward motion.

From the US magazine "Bulletin in Defence of Marxism".

We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board. 6/12 months sub. I enclose £... …To: ser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

your copy! Sunday 5 June. Leeds SO educational: The politics of racism. 5pm at Leeds Univer sity Student Union.

Wednesday 8 June. Cardiff SO meeting: "Lesbian and Gay Liberation'. Speaker: Millward. 7.30, Gower Hotel.

Thursday 9 June. 'Women for Benn and Heffer* meeting, 7.30, Walworth Town Hall, London SE17. Speakers from the Campaign Group of MPs, Maudsley Hospital, and the P&O strike. Saturday-Sunday 11-12 June. Second 'Chesterfield' Socialist Conference, at Chesterfield Technical College. Queries c/o Socialist Society, 9 Poland St, Londo W1.

Thursday 16 June.

Newcastle SO meeting, 'After Alton'. 7.30 at Newcastle Poly.

Monday 20 June. 'Def free comment in the left press!' A meeting to celebrate Socialist Organiser's victory over libel cases brought by Vanessa Redgrave. 7.30, Conway Hall, Red Lion Square. Speakers include John O'Mahony (SO)

Workers' Liberty 88 summe school, at Sir William Collin School, London NW1.

Conference of Socialist Economists 1988, at Sheffield Poly. Queries: CSE, 2! Horsell Rd, London N5.

Advertisement

OUT NOW Revolutionary History No. 1 Includes articles on British Trotskyism in '30s; two views of the Socialist League; Kautsky on intellectuals and the working No. 2 out Mid-June: "The hidden history of the Spanish Civil War". Includes an eye-witness ac-

----- pull-quotes -----

Esteban Volkov

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 358

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →