Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[The Tsarist Empire was justly described as 'the…]

Socialist Organiser no. 358, 2 June 1988 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 2,013 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The Tsarist Empire was justly described as 'the prison house of nations'. It oppressed a vast number of peoples and nationalities. The Bolshevik Revolution broke down the walls and gates of that prison house, liberating the peoples. But the Stalinist counter-revolution has turned the USSR into an even bigger prison house of nationalities than the olEsarist Empire. The Bolshevik approach to the national question was one of their distinctive contributions to Marxism. Without it the Russian Revolution would not have been possible. Without the 'same approach to questions like Ireland and the Middle East, socialists today would be disoriented. Here Leon Trotsky makes a concise outline of the Bolshevik teachings on the national question.

This is the first part of a series on marxist ideas in preparation for Workers' Liberty '88. In two countries of pre-war Europe the national question was of exceptional political significance: in Tsarist Russia and in Hapsburg AustriaHungary. In each of these the workers' party created its own school. In the sphere of theory, the Austrian Social-Democracy, in the persons of Otto Bauer and Karl Renner, considered nationality independent of territory, economy and class, transforming it into a species of abstraction limited by so-called "national character."

In the field of national policy, as for that matter in all other fields, it did not venture beyond a corrective status quo. Fearing the very thought of dismembering the monarchy, the Austrian Social-Democracy strove to adapt its national programme to the borders of the patchwork state.

The programme of so-called "national cultural autonomy" required that the citizens of one and the same nationality, irrespective of their dispersal over the territory of Austria-Hungary and irrespective of the administrative divisions of the state, should be united, on the basis of purely personal attributes, into one community for the solution of their "cultural" tasks (the theatre, the church, the school, and the like). That programme was artificial and utopian, in so far as it attempted to separate culture from territory and economy in a society torn apart by social contradictions; it was at the same time reactionary, in so far as it led to a forced disunion into various nationalities of the workers of one and the same state, undermining their class strength.

Lenin's position was the direct opposite. Regarding nationality as unseverably connected with territory, economy and class structure, he refused at the same time to regard the historical state, the borders of which cut across the living body of the nations, as a sacrosanct and inviolate category.

He demanded recognition of the right to secession and independent existence for each national portion of the state.

In so far as the various nationalities, voluntarily or through force of necessity, Workers' 88 Liberty summer school coexist within the borders of one state, their cultural interests must find the highest possible satisfaction within the framework of the broadest regional (and consequently, territorial) autonomy, including statutory guarantees of the rights of each minority. At the same time, Lenin deemed it the incontrov. tible duty of all the workers of a given state, irrespective of nationality, to unite in one and the same class organisations.

The national problem was particularly acute in Poland, aggravated by the historical fate of that country. The so-called PPS (Polish Socialist Party), headed by Josef Pilsudski, came out ardently for Polish independence; the "socialism" of the PPS was no more than a vague appendage of its militant nationalism. On the other hand, the Polish Social-Democracy, whose leader was Rosa Luxemburg, counterposed the slogan of Polish independence the demand for the autonomy of the Polish region as a constituent part of democratic Russia. Luxembourg proceeded from the consideration that in the epoch of imperialism the separation of Poland from Russia was economically infeasible and in the epoch of socialism - unnecessry.

She looked upon "the right of self-determination" as an empty abstraction. The polemic on that question lasted for years. Lenin insisted that imperialism did not reign similarly or equably in all countries, regions and spheres of life; that the heritage of the past represented an accumulation and interpenetration of various historical epochs; that although monopolistic capitalism towers above everything, it does not supersede everything; that, notwithstanding the domination of imperialism, the numerous national problems retained their full force and that, contingent upon the internal and world conjunctures, Poland might become independent even in the epoch of imperialism.

It was Lenin's view that the right of self-determination was merely an application of the principles of bourgeois democracy in the sphere of national relations. A real, full-bodied, all-sided democracy under capitalism was unrealisable; in that sense the national independence of small and weak peoples was likewise "unrealisable". However, even under imperialism, the working class did not refuse to fight for democratic rights, including among them the right of each nation to its independent existence.

vested the slogan of national self-determination with extraordinary significance. Although Western and Central Europe have somehow managed to solve their national problems in the course of the nineteenth century, in Eastern Europe, Asia, Africa and South America the epoch of national democratic movements had not really begun to unfold until the twentieth century. To deny the right of nations to self-determination is tantamount in effect to offering aid and comfort to the imperialists against their colonies and generally against all oppressed nationalities.

The problem of nationalities was considerably aggravated in Russia during the period of reaction. "The wave of militant nationalism," wrote Stalin, "called attention from above to numerous acts of repressions by those in power, who wreaked their vengeance upon the border states for their love of freedom, calling forth in response a wave of nationalism from below, which at times passed into crude chauvinism." This was the time of the ritual murder trial of the Kiev Jew Bayliss. Retrospectively, in the light of civilisation's latest achievements, especially in Germany and in the USSR, that trial today seems almost a humanitarian experiment. But in 1913 it shocked the whole world. The poison of nationalism began to affect many sections of the working class as well. Alarmed, Gorky wrote to Lenin about the need for counteracting. this chauvinistic rabidness. "As for nationalism, I quite agree with you," replied Lenin, "that we must cope with it more earnestly than ever. We have a splendid Georgian staying with us here who is writing a long article for Prosveshcheniye (Enlightenment), after garnerning all the Austrian and other material. We will bear down on it." The reference was to Stalin.

Gorky, long connected with the party, knew all its leading cadres well. But Stalin evidently was utterly unknown to him, since Lenin had to resort to such an impersonal, although flattering, expression as "a splendid Georgian". This is, by the way, the only occasion when Lenin characterized a prominent Russian revolutionist by the token of his nationality. He had in mind, of course, not a Georgian, but a Caucasian: the element of primitiveness undoubtedly attracted Lenin; small wonder that he treated Kamo with such tenderness.

During his two months' sojourn abroad Stalin wrote a brief but very trenchant piece of research entitled "Marxism and the National Problem". Since it was intended for a lawful magazine, the article resorted to discreet vocabulary. Its revolutionary tendencies were nonetheless distinctly apparent.

Materialist

The author set out by counterposing the historico-materialistic definition of nation to the abstracto-psychological, in the spirit of the Austrian school. "The nation, " he wrote, "is a historically-formed enduring community of language, territory, economic life and psychological composition, asserting itself in the community of culture." This combined definition, compounding the psychological attributes of a nation with the geographic and economic conditions of its development, is not only correct theoretically but also practically fruitful, for then the solution to the problem of each nation's fate must perforce be sought along the lines of changing the material conditions of its existence, beginning with territory. Bolshevism was never addicted to the fetishistic worship of a state's borders. Politically the point was to reconstruct the Tsarist empire, that prison of nations, territorially, politically, and administratively, in line with needs and wishes of the nations themselves.

The party of the proletariat does not enjoin the various nationalities either to remain within the bounds of a given state or to separate from it: that is their own affair. But it does obligate itself to help each of them to realise its actual national will. As for the possiblity of separating from a state, historical of forces Stalin. *1 deem it n the prut And, of Marxists But for tl cannot go tions to s The voluntaril democrat means of determine the Ukra Regional ter utilisa region; i national them to ties. " TI of region counterp that is, P nationali Howev significar proletaria the relati nationali Bolshevis divisible tionalitie! unions d tralism.

"The th ert its in! It places worker's lives the which = educated organisat ings, of th internatio One ol gramme *the pret national and for in amaze tionalisti our com that csecede -the ultin against o tificially cracies Bolshowjs disguised tically " sion or revolutio segregati tionalitie and injus possibilit that thu unificațig a close the dista complete tendency the full n Revoluti

Scan page 7

it is a matter of concrete circumstances and the relation "No one can say," wrote lat the Balkan War is the end of nd external circumstances that other nationality in Russia will cessary to postulate and to solve em of its own independence. ourse, it is no business of the o place barriers in such cases. at very reason Russian Marxists t along without the right of na-lf-determination." terests of the nations which y remain within the bounds of c Russia would be fenced off by "the autonomies of, such selfd units as Poland, Lithuania, ne, the Caucasus, and the like. autonomy is conducive to a bettion of the natural wealth of the does not divide citizens along lines and makes it possible for group themselves in class pare territorial self-administration s in all spheres of social life is ised to the extra-territorial -atonic - self-administration of ies in matters of "culture" only. er, most directly and acutely t, from the point of view of the t's struggle, was the problem of ins between workers of various lies inside the same state. n stood for a compact and innification of workers of all nain the party and in the trade 1 the basis of democratic cenpe of organisation does not exluence on practical work alone.

an indelible stamp on the whole spiritual life. The worker life of his organisation, within • develops spiritually and is ..The international type of on is a school of comradely feelle greatest agitation in favour of nalism." the aims of the Austrian pro- Leon Trotsky of "cultural autonomy" was ervation and development of the Workers' 88 diosyncrasies of peoples." Why that purpose? asked Bolshevism sent. Segregating the various na- Liberty portions of mankind was never ern. True, Bolshevism insisted Tickets for the nation should have the right to the right, but not the duty - as pression. But the thought of arpreserving national idiosyn- unwaged £5 (add was profoundly alien to n. The removal of any, even even the most refined and prac- on the day). Ticke nponderable" national oppresdignity, must be used for the lary unification rather than the n of the workers of various na• Wherever national privileges ies exist, nations must have the summer school to separate from eath other, they may facilitate the free i of the workers, in the name of approchement of nations, with If you want more information about Worke t perspective of the eventual Contact Mark Osborn, Socialist Organiser, =usion of all. Such was the basic af Bolshevism, which revealed SE15 4NA or phone 01 639 7967. asure of its force in the October

----- pull-quotes -----

Moreover, in certain portions of our planet it was imperialism itself that in-

summer weekend: Waged

ate, most effective guarantee €9, Students and

£1 for ticket boug 2-3 July 88

Sir William Colli for one day only:

Wage £6, Others Euston, London

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 358

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →