Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Defend Ron Brown!

Socialist Organiser no. 357, 26 May 1988 · scan p. 2 · Alan Johnson · about 1,935 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

women which he had seen in kon - against the wishes of the activists

So what? All this should be a - not to. have Ron Brown as a lesson to those on the left who think speaker. This is deplorable. it 'smart' to attack the private lives Ron Brown should be criticised of Tory politicians. The same smut- for his political shortcomings, such ty moralism can be used against the as his admiration for Colonel Gadleft, too. dafi and his support for Russian.

This Friday, 27 May, a 'Benn for troops in Afghanistan, not for what leader' rally is being held in Edin- he may have done in the House of burgh. The organisers have decided • Commons shower or his flat. "You CAN call a poof a poof!" proclaimed the Sun last Wednesday, after the Press Council rejected complaints about headlines like "Runcie backs ban on pulpit poofs"

The council's decision, readers were told, meant that "The Sun was right to use the words 'poof" and 'poofter'."

Actually, the Press Council did not say that the Sun (and the Star) was right to use those words. They ruled that the language was coarse and no doubt intended to be derogatory and insulting" , but that such words were "commonly used and so come within the discretion of the editor"

Now, personally I tend to think that some people within the gay and women's movement often make too much of linguistic niceties, as though changing people's vocabulary is going to change the social forces that cause oppression. But there are limits...

If it's OK to use the word "poof" because it is "commonly used" then why not... well, you know, a lot of other "derogatory and insulting" names for minority groups and foreigners.

A brief and random scan through recent editions of the Sun and Star revealed the following colourful turns of phrase, making full use of "commonly used" terms: "Push off sour krauts" (Star); "We can give the honourable Nips a run for their yen!" (Sun); and "Rocard the wet is Frog's new PM"* — the Sun's remarkable headline announcing the appointment of the French prime minister.

Harmless

Stuff like this may seem harmless enough. The Japanese, Germans and French are not generally persecuted or discriminated against in Britain these days. But who can doubt that such language helps legitimise all sorts of nasty prejudices that are still bubbling away beneath the surface in Britain The use of the words 'poof' and "poofter' is a more serious matter. Gay people are discriminated against, and they do get beaten up. For a national newspaper to use such words about homosexuals is like using the equivalent language about blacks, Jews, and the biggest oppressed group of all, women. like to think that if ever that started happening, all decent people would be up in arms — but presumably the Press Council wouldn't object, because such words are "commonly used"

Incidentally, the Sun is not completely without scruples when it comes to offensive language: editor Kelvin McKenzie recently took the Independent to the Press Council for printing the exact words (f*** and c*** will have to suffice for SO readers) that passed between Mike Gatting and the umpire during an eventful England/Pakistan cricket match. Not surprisingly they laughed him out of court. How about "Reptile chief told "slither off'" for that one?

57, By Stan Crooke Last month Leith Labour MP Ron Brown was suspended from the House of Commons for dropping the ceremonial mace and refusing to apologise.

As Ron Brown said, it would be better if the mace were sold off to raise money for the unemployed. *These pigs from Scotland should have no human rights. They should be treated like the evil animals they are." So said Terry Dicks, Tory MP for in one death, one serious injury, 165 arrests and rioting in Central London.

The "football hooligan' is again.

How should socialists respond to football violence and to the Tories use of it to whip up yet another 'moral panic' and increase the punitive powers of the state?

We need very clearly to restate some basic truths, That a warped society, in which profit comes before people, which brutalises through poverty, unemployment and racism, produces brutal violent people. That increased police powers to "deal' with football violence will only strengthen the very state which underpins that warped society.

Thatcher herself has hammered home the theme that the 'enemy within' is led by both football hooligans and strikers. Powers used tomorrow against the Chelsea "Headhunters' would be used the day afterwards against trade unionists. Anyone who doubts this should ask themselves why Thatcher is now calling her government "my regime".

That football is a business run for profit like any other. Why did Heisal disaster happen when the British government, the Belgian government, Liverpool FC and the European Football Association knew the stadium was unsafe and had not had a full safety check since the early 1930s? Because it was the Belgian FA's turn to get the millions of pounds receipts would bring.

Why do clubs ignore the racism that pervades football? Why are better facilities, transport and seated stadiums not considered as "solutions'? Because the game today is a multi-million dollar business and, as such, reflects the idea of profit first and profit last.

But as important as these arguments are, are they enough? Are we aware of the resonance that Terry Dicks' view (substituting hooligan' for the disgusting comments about Scottish fans) will have amongst working people? Are we sensible of the subtle explanation of football hooliganism deployed by Thatcher to reinforce a new moral vision.

Are there no possibilities for the left to challenge this vision and to move from a ritualised defence at a time like this to a powerful attack on Thatcherism, indicting it for the very promotion of football violence? I think these issues are worth discussing.

First the left must 1988.

But the Parliamentary Labour Party backed the suspension. Brown's flat, opposite his own.

Last week Ron Brown was trouble again. He was accused some MPs and the tabloid press "frolicking' with a woman in House of Commons shower.

Then the Sunday People ran a front-page story in which an appropriately-named Mr Tutt tuttutted about the "string of sexy By Alan Johnson romanticism about football violence being an 'authentic working class sub-culture of revolt', albeit misdirected. It is an ugly, squalid expression, in an extreme form, of an ugly, squalid society.

My father gave up watching Newcastle and St. James' Park when a molotov cocktail was thrown onto the West Ham supporters' enclosure. Ask any Asian family that live near a ground in London about 'the lads' out for a spot of *Paki-bashing' after the game. Speak to those doctors who are now experts at the 'Saturday stitch-ups' of Stanley knife slashes.

So who do we blame? Here Thatcher steps in with an explaination.

Unlike the Labour Party, Thatcher takes ideological combat very seriously. She has since 1979, developed an impressive repetoire in this battle of ideas. Whether the issue is unemployment, poverty, inner-city decay, single parents or football violence, she has played subtle variations on a powerful theme, and the theme is blame the victim.

You thought these were society's problems? Not so. For a start there is no such thing as 'society. There dividual choice and individual the with inPolice arrest scotland tan responsibilities.

This view was well summed up more applications than one. recently: "the mother in question did not have to have her baby. understandings and explanations Wrecked cars and old mattresses could find a real resonance. re-write are dumped by somebody and graf- the agenda for debate and start confitti does not scrawl itself" (David Edgar, Marxism Today, October 'common sense. 1987). Blaming the victim has been a most useful tool indeed in a socie- We have echoes of the Tories' calls ty with 3 million unemployed, 12 for short, sharp, cheap, totally inefmillion in poverty and periodic fective but also stern, so-respectable riots. "solutions'.

Now, when Kinnock speaks, as he did, of Thatcher creating load- earnest concern from earnest samonev' society he probably just Labour Party Labour-All party stumbled on a gimmick for one of Commons football committee his speeches. But in one sense spokesperson about whether it all cher's glorification of individual means that English football clubs greed, the creation of a society that would not be allowed back into Hod od money chance wit knows the price of everything and Europe next year.

character writ native understanding of the prolarge, could be brought into the blems. John Williams, researcher centre of the debate over football into football violence, has described football as "the flawed product of a It's not just that Southern fans society scored with real divisions of have taken to chanting at Northern race, sex and class". fans "we've got jobs, we've got Precisely. jobs, you haven't, you haven't"

It's that Thatcher has created a ding centre-stage as the lynch-pin of climate, a 'common sense, in our approach would point to two which the Chelsea "Headhunters' things. Firstly, to an understanding actually feel quite at home. that the continuance of a society It is xenophobic nationalism. It is which rests upon such divisions rubbishing of any notion of anti- guarantees the provisional, temporracism. It is careful orchestration of tary nature of any gains made in a backlash against 'aliens' (lesbians, combatting football violence. gay men, feminists, blacks). It is reassertion of reactionary, illiberal, causes and solutions. It allows us to intolerant, militaristic culture, and relate what we say and do about of course it is greed is good football violence to what we say philosophy that underpins it all. and do on everything else.

"Make a killing and don't worry The Tories deal in' doing the spade-work for this rally SCO's about the consequences" can have political philosophies which help them construct majority support.

This alterntive repetoire of But the Labour Party deals in pragmatic policy documents addressed to someone else's majority.

Secondly, it would point us testing the Tories on the terrain of towards a socialist practice in the There and how. It would mean we But what do we have? Echoes. * support the Professional Footballers' Association initiative to involve communities in clubs; * champion the work of Liverpool City Council in its schools' educaAnd verging on the sick, we have tional programme to combat football violence; * challenge the structures of ownership, control and accountability of clubs; * that we spread the kind of antiracist initiative that Leeds is taking over Leeds FC, that we take Instead we need a wholly alter- seriously for instance that blaak players are writing to Bernie Grant in the House of Commons about the level of racism in football (and when we do that why couldn't we tie in the racism suffered by Bernie Grant in the House of Commons and the government's indifference Bringing this kind of understan- to that too.

This basic alternative understanding, its constant application, could provide the ideological cement' to hold the campaigning together and generalise it. This is to do what the Tories have done so well since 1975.

As Stuart Hall put it "to speak -to define the crisis - what it is and It is an alternative explanation of how to get out of it".

The problem we have is that this is actually a different conception of politics to the stale, parliamentary minuette of the Labour front bencoherent ch.

----- pull-quotes -----

Hayes and Harlington after the violence of the annual England- Scotland match, which resulted

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 357

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →