Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Wreckers reports on Pravda's

Socialist Organiser no. 356, 19 May 1988 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 2,006 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Socialist Organiser no. 356, 19 May 1988. Page 3 The withdrawal of Russian troops from Afghanistan must be perplexing for those on the left who supported their invasion or did not oppose their presence.

They argued that Afghanistan was a different case from Vietnam or other battles against imperialism.

The USSR claims to be socialist;

and even if we reject this claim we can point to the frankly reactionary programme of the Afghan rebels and the support for them from the United States. In comparison if no more, the Afghan government and ILS Russian backers are "progressive"

The People's Democratic Party (PDP) government which took power through a military coup in April 1978 did promise land reform, modern education and women's emancipation in Afghanistan, one of the most underdeveloped coun tries in the world. But they tried to impose these reforms through the control of the central state machine by a small modernising elite of officers trained in the USSR. The mass of the Afghan people rebelled against this 'enlightened despotism'. Under pressure of the rebellion, faction fights exploded in the PDP. Moscow became alarmed:

Hafizullah Amin, the ultra-Stalinist who had come out on top in the PDP faction fight, looked like leading the pro-USSR regime to a shattering defeat.

In December 1979, Moscow invaded, got rid of Amin, created a new government from more pliant PDP members and took effective conSocratist Organ-ser 70 Box-823, Landon SE15 4a 01-639 7965 est dae-for reports: first post Mont Clay or by shone Monday euesen -Eartor John 0 Testony Typesetting Upstream Lid (TU% 01-358 134* Publismed by Socialist Organiser. PU Bex 823, London SEIS Ap -Printed by-Press Lak International LUK) Ltd (TU) Register as a newspaper at the Post Office igned articles dr trot easier!

eflect the view of Socialst Orgasm trol. It must have helped to put down the rebellion quite quickly.

Eight years on, five million people are refugees and perhaps a million are dead. The USSR has employed all the traditional techniques of modern new colonial warfare, including putting naplam fire to villages, in an effort to subdue the Afghan resistance.

The modernist programme of the PDP has been largely scrapped. Land reform has been halted, and the government loudly proclaims its respect for Islam; but all the efforts to appease the rebels have been as vain as the efforts to crush them.

The essential reality of Afghanistan is that the Soviet Union has behaved as an imperialist power trying to bombard economically and socially underdeveloped people into submission. That the Afghan people are backward - economically, culturally and politically - no more justifies this war of conquest than the backwardness of colonial peoples justified British colonialism in the past. The Zulu kings for example, were certainly no more modern-minded than the Afghan rebels, while British colonialism could promise progressive capitalist development in southern Africa.

Socialist Action, twice referring to the Afghan rebels as 'scum' call energetically for "Victory to the Afghan government' (May 1988). They do not say whether they support or oppose the Soviet withdrawal, but they do warn that a rebel victory "will wipe out... all traces of communism, liberalism, working class organisation (and) any organisation of women". What 'traces' of working class organisation, or liberalism, not to mention communism, exist now in Afganistan, under Moscow's control? Since when have the Kremlin bureaucrats been defenders of these things?

Socialist Action do criticise the "bureaucratic methods' of the Soviet Union - although bureaucratic is hardly an adequate adiective — but continue their spirited defence of the Soviet Vincence upper. It is a mate te British left has been supporting this scum" , meaning, again, the rebels. In fact, many on the British left, over the last 8 years, have supported the 'scum' ruling in Militant was one of the few groups who never switched to calling for Russian withdrawal after the reality of occupation became impossible to ignore. Mike Waddington (Militant, 13 May) argues that Gorbachev is getting out because the 'counter-revolution' has been defeated - a thesis not supported by any other observers, or, indeed, by any evidence.

Quoting guru Ted Grant from 1979, Militant rails against *the confused 'analyses' of the media, which portray the Russian withdrawal as a defeat" and proudly proclaims: "As always, Marxism has shown a far clearer understanding of the processes in advance than the capitalist 'experts' have been able to develop even with hindsight!"

The relevant prediction from Grant was that Russian troops would withdraw "once the counterrevolution has been defeated" '. So it is somewhat surprising to read Waddington referring to Gorbachev's description of the war as *a bleeding wound' and speculating that "Gorbachev has probably whipped up anti-war stories as a warning to the bureaucracy of what could develop if the situation continues" — a perculiar calculation for somebody about to secure victory.

In fact Militant means that Russia hasn't been defeated, rather than that it has actually wonwhich renders Grant's 'prediction' irrelevant. Of course the Russians haven't literally been driven out by the rebels storming Kabul, but very few colonial wars end like that. The USSR 'ailed to defeat the rebels: that is the truth of it.

Militant also are full of venom for the rebels, and praise for the current regime. Confident of Najibullah's future victory, they predict yet more glowing achievements to come. The methods employed by the USSR, the number of Afghan deaths, all of word. Mere details, no doubt, on the scale of historical progress.

What is important is that "illiteracy has largely been abolished and the position of women improved... new mosques have been built and 1,226 mosques have been repaired". The number of mosques - or homes - demolished is not recorded.

Militant have defined the Russian war in Afghanistan essentially as one of civilisation against barbarism — against the 'dark masses' as they once described the Afghans. If the Afghan masses aren't prepared to accept the benefits of the twentieth century, so much the worse for them.

Now Militant find themselves in the invidious position of having to support Russian withdrawal after opposing the call for it all along. The logic-chopping about Russian victory is merely a device to get themselves out of a fix. Their basic attitude, reminiscent of the Fabians, who justifed imperialism as the extension of civilisation, remains unchanged.

Afghanistan is no side issue. The view of the world and of socialism's place in it expressed by Socialist Action, Militant and many others on this issue is a major disease on the left. If 'socialism' , liberation', or "democracy' can be imposed on the mass of the people by a brutal military elite, then Marx's idea that the liberation of the working class must be the task of the workers themselves' is mere prejudice.

Socialists of course do not welcome the prospect of a medieval Islamic regime in Kabul. We are for progressive minorities defending themselves, and the development of a socialist movement. But we are not in favour of governments imposed on the mass of the population.

Any socialist movement must recognise that the peoples of Afghanistan, like any other have the right to self-determination. Socialism is about freedom, including national freedom. And from that point of view, the Russian departure from Afghanistan is a step towards socialism, not away Stan Crooke coverage of Poland LAW AND order reign again in the People's Republic of Poland. The paid agents of Western imperialism have been shunned by the Polish masses.

The government's programme for democratisation and economic reform can continue unhindered.

This is how Pravda reported the success of the riot police in beating down the recent wave of strikes in The current unrest, said Pravda, differs from 1980-1. That was an understandable protest - though one which got out of hand against 'mistakes' by the government. The recent strikes, however, sought to "provoke a political crisis, undermine the economy, and ignore the needs of the masses"

Only in one sense, claimed Pravda, were the two waves of unrest comparable. Both were led by the same people "who nearly wrecked. the Polish economy by strikes in 1981". • Western countries, Pravda continued, "pay for their well-to-do life in Poland and direct their activities"

One Solidarnose representative received six weeks in prison on the grounds that "he had recently been increasingly active as one of the main suppliers of information to the Western media which are conducting an anti-Polish campaign"

Pravda thought that Western countries had no right to complain about events in Poland. "Don't they constantly curtail workers' rights, don't they cut workers' living standards, don't they limit the activities of trade unions?" asked Pravda, ignoring the fact that different behaviour might be expected in supposedly socialist countries.

THE GOVERNMENT has made another move towards TV censorship with its new Broadcasting Standards Council.

Legislation to set it up has not yet been passed, but William ReesMogg has already been appointed chair of the Council, and has started by warning broadcasters that they must agree to a voluntary' self-censorship code or have him checking programmes in advance.

He claimed his concern was with violent trash programmes like "The A-Team', but it was Thames TV's critical examination of the SAS's killing of three IRA members in Gibraltar that made the Tories set up the Council.

IViomen and the struggle E FAiWoman's Actatist Osgriny peraphlet: 50p Available from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 60p plus

Scan page 4

GHAI The death of Harry McShane at the away from McShane's revoluage of 96 has led to a number of tionary socialism and it would be obituaries hailing him as 'the last interesting to know what he really Unfortunately, like his mentor the century to date, beginning even critical of Stalinism and its interna- McLean, he has left no permanent before the 1st World War. During tional apparatus. In 1981, he join- legacy in terms of a viable revoluthe war and in the years after the ed the Polish Solidarity Campaign tionary socialist organisation war he was associated with John platform in Glasgow to express his embedded in the trade unions and McLean in a period of great labour support for free trade unionism in Labour Party. His contribution however, in terms of inspiring a future generation of socialists is not and an avowed Marxist, thereafter ed by various labour movement went on to join the Communist Par- luminaries as a good old man of the ty and remanined a leading activist left. Most of them were light years Glasnost and the Soviet male: Moscow is about to stage its first Miss Moscow contest. It has already provoked a flurry of excitement among Moscow's eligible bachelors.

One young man 1 has written to one of the Communist youth papers advertising himself as a potential marriage partner for the contest winner. He has says he has a nice of the Red Clydesiders".

Harry's political career spanned turbulence on Clydeside.

McShane, an engineer by trade mother, an interesting job, and a talking parrot.

His only stipulation?

She must be blonde and long-legged.

So this is what Gorbachev's policies mean for Russian women...

The gap between Britain's top-paid and lowest-paid is at its widest for 25 years.

Around one per cent of the male working population earn £29,000 a year or more, with 90 people getting upwards of £300,000 a year.

Following the Budget, half of Britain's working population earns £9,300 or below after tax. The figures, compiled by Incomes Data Services from Inland Revenue sources, do not include perks available to top earners like company cars and accommodation.

The survey indicates that there are still very few high-paid women, with one man in 100 earning over 30,000 a year, until the 1950s when, finally disgusted by the adulation of Stalinism, he left to return to his trade. thought of them.

McShane became increasingly the Soviet bloc.

Latterly he was uncritically laudnegligable.

Report. Ian McCalman Glasgow

----- pull-quotes -----

Thatcher steps up censorship

Pay gap widens Paisley leads protests against Anglo-Irish deal. Photo: Derek Spiers, Builders lives of risk Miss Moscow

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 356

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →