Lebanon: further down the sectarian spiral
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-05-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Th TUC the TUC S lUC spilt!
EETPU rank and file on the Wapping picket line. Photo Andrew Wiard The current fighting in Lebanon is not, as some press reports suggest, a "proxy war" between Syria and Iran.
The two Shi'a militias, Amal and Hezbollah, are linked to Syria and Iran respectively, but the war between them has Lebanese roots.
Syria, which controls parts of Lebanon and has done so since 1976, is being drawn further and further into the conflict. The Syrian presence, and Iranian interference, make things worse. External forces of various kinds helped create Lebanon's crisis. But to understand the latest round of the Lebanese war it is necessary to know a lot more than that Syria and Iran have a stake in it.
Street gunfights started on 5 May, when the Hezbollah (Party of God) made a big push to control the been sadly lacking in its dealings en sadly lacking in its dealings with Hammond to date. Most EET- th Hammond to date. Most EETPU members are not dyed-in-the- members are not dyed-in-thewool scabs. They could be won to al analen elementary trade-union principles, against the business unionism of Hammond - if the TUC dares to go over Hammond's head and appeal directly to rank and file electricians.
The left within the EETPU, mainly grouped around the journal Flashlight, must be given the support of the entire movement in their campaign against Hammond's plans. All this will require a drastic change of approach from the TUC, which has so far handled the EETPU leaders with kid gloves and is traditionally loth to be seen to interfere in the internal affairs of individual unions: but Hammond has thrown down the gauntlet, and he will only be beaten if the TUC stands up and fights.
The AEU could be crucial to the outcome of this battle. Bill Jordan, the engineers' president, has long advocated a merger with the EETPU, and is Hammond's closest ally at the TUC. He has said that the AEU will stay with the TUC; but if the AEU, Britain's second-largest union, follows the electricians out the TUC, then an alternative rightwing tradevinion centre will be a viable proposition.
Without the engineers, Hammond's only bedfellows will be small fry like the Engineers' and Managers' Association and openly scab outfits like the Union of Democratic Mineworkers and the Professional Association of Teachers. The AEU would give Hammond's project real credibility. Fight the witch. Joyce Gould, the Labour Party's Director of Organisation, has issued instructions for a third attempt to hold the AGM of Cardiff Central Constituency This is a clear response to pressure from the "Fight the Witch-hunt in Cardiff Central Campaign" (FWHCC) and the incompetence of local officials. Gould has called the new AGM, southern suburbs of Beirut, dominated by Amal. A Syriannegotiated ceasefire only paved the way for more fighting. Since the fighting started, 200 people have been killed and 600 wounded.
Since Lebanon's civil war broke out in 1975, Beirut has been reduced to rubble and the political patchwork has completely altered.
The Shi'a Muslims were the outsiders in the early stages of the war, JEETPUI Again, the rank and file needs to be mobilised. The AEU Broad Left must organise the kind of campaign that last year ensured the defeat of the National Engineering Agreement.
The National Executive must be flooded with resolutions demanding that the union stays within the TUC. If necessary, lobbies of the Executive should be called, as they were last year, by the Engineering Gazette.
If Hammond and his co-thinkers in the AEU do succeed in splitting from the TUC, then affiliated engineering and general unions like the TGWU, GMB and MSF must declare all-out war on 'business In many plants, the EETPU is a for instance, the EETPU has 1823 members spread across 22 plants. In refrigeration it has 588 members; in the docks, 691; in the independent steel sector, 506.
lunt in Cardiff Cr through the Welsh Labour Party organiser Anita Gale, for 23 June.
Plasnewydd ward remains suspended and will still not be allowed to take part in this latest AGM. Wards and affiliated organisations have been told that they must resubmit delegates and renominate for officers' positions, thus giving the right wing the chance to remove delegates who have insisted the rules must be followed and that Plasnewydd fought out between Arab nationalists and right-wing Christian Maronites for control of the state.
By the mid-80s, the Shi'a groups were on top, in so far as anybody is on top in this devastated country.
Now the main Shi'a factions are ripping each other to bits.
Lebanon used to be the Middle East's playground. Beirut was full of wealthy banks and popular beaches. Beside the sun and sea was In the longer term, the TUC will only defeat business unionism by itself breaking from 'New Realism' To many trade unionists, the Hammond/Jordan approach seems only a logical extension of the conservative, timid style unionism represented by the mainstream TUC 'new realists' Over the past ten years, outfits like PAT and the Royal College of Nursing have generally grown while TUC affiliates have lost members. Ths pattern has only been reversed when TUC unions have taken a more militant line and led a fight — as they did, however inadequately, during the recent NHS dispute.
The temptation will be for the TUC to try to keep the EETPU and (more especially) the AEU inside the fold by making concessions on issues like single union/no strike deals. Recent history suggests that this is not the way to defeat business unionism. What is required is a clear, fighting alternative from the TUC.
entral!
ward be reinstated.
The ward was suspended last February because of the presence of Chris Peace, an expelled supporter of the Militant, at the AGM. He had been invited to speak at the ward, which had not been officially informed of his expulsion.
Anita Gale has been repeatedly asked on whose authority the ward was suspended, and has given a variety of replies. Her latest claim is that "no-one really took the decision to suspend" but the ward was nevertheless suspended because everybody knew the Plasnewydd AGM was unconstitutional".
Clearly, the ward has not yet been constitutionally suspended. The reality is that the ward is being victimised for campaigning against unpopular decisions by the Labour-controlled County Council and for nominating left-wingers for officers' positions in the party.
The witchunters have not had it all their own way. The FWHCC campaign has gained support locally from wards, constituencies and trade union branches and nationally from CLPD and Tony Benn. The Campaign has issued a mailing outlining events and will also be lobbying the new AGM and Labour Party Wales regional conference in Tenby on 20 May.
Locally the campaign is taking the initiative in the Benn-Heffer candidacy, calling a meeting to set up a suppori committee in South Glamorgan.
For details, model resolutions, speakers, messages of support and donations contact: FWHCC c/o 22 Norwood Court. Roath, Cardiff. Tel: 0222 462582. a dirtier reality: a grossly unequal society and a political stucture that discriminated against the Muslim majority. The presence of Palestinian refugee camps and therefore guerilla organisations, added extra explosiveness. Israeli attacks on Palestinians — hitting the southern Shi'a population especially hard -helped polarise society, already rid den with sectarian divisions, to the point where the tension was too much.
Sections of the Palestinan movement got dragged into a conflict that degenerated fast into a sectarian bloodbath. Syria intervened to stop the Lebanese/Palestinian 'left' winning. Later Israel invaded. Then Israel invaded again, in a war of terrible ferocity in 1982 that left the country in worse ruin. A multinational 'peace-keeping' force went in gave up after two disastrous years.
Among the Shia Muslims, the worst-off of Lebanon's numerous communities, first Amal and then the Hezbollah grew out of the depair generated by this accelerating social and political collapse, and in response to the utter failure of the traditional political groups to do anything at all about it. A whole generation has grown up knowing nothing but violence on a huge scale. Some of the very young recruits were born after the first round of the war, in which 40,000 people had lost there lives by summer 1976.
Religious fundamentalism, with its commitment to martyrdom, at least offered some answer - in its way a coherent one. It offered a total view of the world, in contrast to the decaying ideologies of Arab nationalism or more traditionalist leaderships. It also offered a model of success - Iran. The Hezbollah, the CWCT and extremist group, looked to Khomeini for support.
All the Lebanese parties had relied upon militias and strong men to rule their respective roosts. The civil war originally had some semblance of sense to it the largely Muslim and Druze left' wanted a non-sectarian system that would end Maronite privilege. Before long it was gang warfare, as rival factions shot it out for control of suburbs.
Often the greatest bloodshed was. within, rather than across, sectarian-political division: Maronite militias wiped each other out; likewise Sunni Muslims; or Sunni and Druze partners in the erstwhile Lebanese National Movement turned on each other. Now it is the Shi'as' turn.
The peculiarity of the two Shi'a groups has been their remarkable strength. It was Amal that drove Israel out of southern Lebanon, where all the secular nationalists had failed. The Israelis found that they simply could not cope with exenemies who seemed to positively -want to die.
The Hezbollah represents those who find Amal too soft' particularly on Israel, which still has a 'security zone' in the south from which it recently launched attacks into Lebanon. Amal's ruthless seiges of Palestinian refugee camps were not supported by the Hezbollah, which aims to "liberate Palestine'. Amal hates the Palestinians, blames them for Lebanon's ordeal.
Amal has done badly in the recent fighting, so their Syrian protection has been forced to move into southern Beirut - something they had previously promised Iran they would not do. The implications for relations between Syria and Iran -Syria is Iran's chief Arab ally against Iraq could be far-reaching. But all of that remains to be seen.
There are no easy answers to Lebanon's ordeal. There have been stirrings of workers' unity across sectarian lines, but still very tentative ones. That is the hope for the future. For the present, the bloodletting is likely to continue
----- pull-quotes -----
minority union, and would be vulnerable to a campaign. In Ford,
itl Fir •Li