Science and life after death SCIENCE CHOMIN
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-05-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
to scientific investigation.
Just such evidence is to be found in accounts of "out of body" experiences (OOBEs) by a few people who have been close to death but have recovered. A recent TV programme and an article in New Scientist, by brain researcher Dr Susan Blackmore, reviewed these experiences.
A survey of 102 near death experiences found that they seem to involve: feelings of peace; freedom from pain; a feeling of separation of mind from body; entering darkness or a dark tunnel; seeing light; entering the light.
The feelings were experienced in this order, with the first ones being most common, suggesting an unfolding "ready-made" experience as death approaches.
In the separation stage, people reported looking down at their bodies from above. Some described the medical procedures being carried out to resuscitate them as if seen from above. Others described things supposed to be invisible from where they were lying (but not from where their astral selves were hovering!)
Dr Blackmore quoted from 355, who had written to her of an OOBE she had had after she went into shock, following an emergency operation: "Although thought to be unconscious, I remembered the entire, detailed conversation between the surgeon and anaesthetist. I was lying above my own body, totally free of pain, and looking down at my own self with compassion for the agony I could see on the face; 1 was floating peacefully. Then I was going elsewhere, floating towards a dark but not frightening, curtain-like area... then I felt total peace.
Suddenly it all changed — I was slammed back into my body again, very much aware of the agony again."
Many near-death survivors spoke of meeting a "person of light". The identity of this person varied according to the religious background of the survivor. Christians tended to meet Jesus, Gabriel or St. Peter! Survivors felt they were passing into a world of joy, love and peace. Though strongly attracted by this other world, some survivors claimed to make a conscious decision to return to their bodies and resume their earthly according to Dr. Blackmore. Their very similarity argues for a common cause — the response of the brain to lack of oxygen and glucose, build-up of carbon dioxide and often waste products, as well as a sudden loss of inputs from the sense organs.
The vision of the tunnel with the light can also occur in epilepsy, migraine, meditation, falling asleep, pressure on the eyes or with hallucinogenic drugs. Dr. Blackmore explains this by a sudden failure of inhibition of nerve cells in the visual cortex (the "sight-brain'). The visual cortex becomes highly excitable and stripes of activity pass through it.
Because of the way the retina is connected to the visual cortex, a stripe of activity is perceived by the brain as rings or spirals of light or tunnels. Movement of the stripe gives the appearance of growth or shrinking to the shapes.
But why do these shapes seem so real? Dr. Blackmore argues that we view reality through the construction of models in our brains. The brain does the best it can with the available information, mixing in information from the memory. Blackmore suggests that such memory models could build up a vivid bird's eye view of the dying self. Residual hearing could fill in some of the details of the mental picture, 'real' because no other plausible model is available.
Dr. Blackmore's explanations help re-l establish the materialist idea of mental activity as the result of the operation of the brain, not something that occupies it temporarily, having an independant existance.
This is not to say the mind is "nothing but" the operation of the brain's cells, any more than Shakespeare's works are just a collection of letters of the alphabet. A dialectical materialist understanding of the human brain and mind has some way to go but insights such as Dr. Blackmore's are immensely helpful.
Perhaps another line of research might be into why people seem to need to believe so many impossible things -virgin birth, spirits that never say anything interesting, remote stars influencing our destiny, a God that makes us what we are and then wonders at our behaviour! tackle the big issues of journalism. at all. They are just used as spice and seasoning for the romantic comedy. But in this film, you do get a sense of what the work is, and how it's done. It's nice to see a film about people at work that isn't a cop show.
Women and the struggles ÇUR ORIES! for socialism A:Women s -Sociast-Organisa -amphle+.-60p vailable from SO, PO Box 823, endon SE15 4NA. 60p plus
Scan page 11
in CPSA -CPSA CPSA CPSA By Trudy Saunders alliance between the moderates and Broad left supporters must go year's Section Conference. We back to their branches and cam- must build a fighting rank and file paign for the Broad Left motions who will not allow the right wing to which have been passed at this sell our jobs.
Industrial The Broad Left has already suffered a number of defeats at this year's CPSA Conference in Bournemouth.
The DHSS Section Executive Committee elections went badly. The 'moderate 84' group won 22 seats and the Broad Left (BL) 8, 5 of whom are Socialist Caucus supporters.
A 'moderate 84' leadership comes at the worst possible time. 1988/9 will be a crucial year in terms of Tory attacks on our jobs, pay, conditions and service. *Moderate 84° leaders will undoubtedly back down in the face of these attacks.
In fact they are doing so already. At DHSS Section Conference they supported a motion calling for a redundancy agreement, thus tacitly accepting that there will be redundancies in the DHSS. One of their motley crew made the comment: "We can't achieve the utopia of no By Trudy job losses". Thankfully for us the motion was defeated.
A 'moderate 84' leadership [undoubedly opens the floodgates for the Tories to bring in all sorts of measures which threaten members, such as YTS, Limited Period Appointments, the Ibbs report and the Muller report.
At National Conference a number of particularly worrying motions from 'moderate 84' have been carried. One, which transfers decisions on pay from Special Pay Conference to the NEC, is a blow against democracy in our union. Another, which accepts the inevitability of local pay additions gives into a particularly pernicious Tory move which threatens our jobs and attempts to divide workers and weaken our union.
The defeat of the Broad Left in the DHSS is partly explained by an the misnamed Broad Left '84. But Militant supporters on the DHSS Secion Executive Committee last year must also take some share of the blame.
By not fighting the Fowler Review and by not balloting for all-out strike action over Limited Period Appointments, they paved the way for the current attacks on us and demoralised activists.
Increasingly the Broad Left has become an electoral machine. Comapaigning for Broad Left policies among the rank and file has been left out over the last few years.
We must do what the Socialist Caucus (the left within the Broad Left, including Socialist Organiser supporters) has always argued for: we must build a campaigning, fighting rank and file Broad Left which when in power gives a strong lead to members in the fightback against the Tories.