The human face of cuts
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-05-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Belinda
Weaver
*Broadcast Broadcast News' is probably the best movie in town just now. It didn't win any Oscars, but "Broadcast News' can make it on its own. It's really funny.
A few reviewers have said it's like a TV show. But TV is rarely this funny, this witty. If the TV soundtracks of so-called comedies didn't also have laughter tracks, we might mistake them for drama.
Where 'Broadcast News' is a little. like TV is in its shrinking away from any real conclusions, as it doing so would spoil it. This is a little disappointing, as serious themes have been raised. But here they are secondary to what is basically a romantic comedy. The big theme is of course the ethics of TV news. What should the networks cover, how should they do it, and how far should they go to get a story? Reporter Aaron Altman puts some of the team through their paces. 'Would they tell a contact they loved him just to get his story? Would they film a guy in the electric chair as the current is switched on?' He gets a unanimous yes to both questions. No soul searching here.
The only person really searching her soul is Jane Craig, Aaron's best friend, and a producer of news. She's concerned about the networks' increasing use of Barbieand- Ken doll newreaders and the reporting of soft, 'human-interest' stories rather than the real news.
Aaron, who's a solid hardworking reporter, gets no real credit for what he does. The networks favour people with the glitzy charisma, who can pump up the ratings.
Such a man is Tom Grunick, played as spectacularly selfabsorbed by William Hurt. Hurt knows his limitations, but they don't really bother him. When he gets a job on Jane's network and watches her in action with Aaron an the rest of the team, he phones his father exultantly.
I really think I can do this job! Of course he can - by using the brains and skills of the others to make him look good.
A crucial test comes up when Libyan planes attack a US air base in the Mediterranean. Tom is to read the story, but he hasn't the backgound to interview anyone credibly. Instead of getting himself Belief in life after death, in the independent survival of the "soul" or "spirit", is widespread. Many believers freely admit theri beliefs to be unsupported by evidence, that they depend on faith. Others are keen to find evidence that stands up William Hurt briefed by Aaron, an expert on Libya. Tom frets over whether to wear a navy or red tie with his crisp, freshly laundered shirt. Once he's done up, he feels ready. Like a baby, he waits to be spoon-fed the lines he'll need to say.
Handsome
Jane can't resist Tom, despite his dimness and shallowness. His stupidity only makes him more alluring. Who hasn't looked at someone impossibly handsome and been convinced they can't really be nd je.1+ Les Hearn's as thick as all that, Tom has authentic glamour, so Jane gets all tangled up, helping him look good. Her head-over-heels manner softens her. Even the network boss thinks she is becoming more flexible.
Which is lucky for her when the networks start to cut back. Staff must go, so the expendable ones get the axe. Tom isn't surprised, he says. "This has happened at every station I've gone to. This may well be the most significant line in the picture.
The forward and onward march of the Toms is just the flipside of duties, OOBEs are intensely real to those who experience them. They are convinced their spirits left their bodies and often felt less materialistic and more grateful for the gift of life.
Alternately claimed as evidence of the spirit world or dismissed as "just hallucintions, OOBEs may have sound physiological and psychological bases the cuts. After all, if the networks can get away with reporting trivia with dumb clucks to read it, why have reporters slogging away in faraway places at huge expense?
Tom is the future. Stunts, scandals and crime can fill up the gaps where politics and real news have drained away.
Jane professes not to like that future, but in falling for Tom, and sticking with the network, she's given herself up to that future. Jane huffs and puffs a lot about integrity and the rest, but she's going along with the system all the same.
In one ironic scene, when she In the aying system, sensory inputs are lacking and brain cells are free from the inhibition that usually controls them. The brain seizes on the vivid imagery from the visual cortex as the most real, and therefore best available, model. It tries to make sense of this "reality' by bringing out its memories.
Now it seems that many memories are stored in a bird's ey view form. Dr. Aaron are shooting footage of the Contras fighting the Sandinistas, she forbids the cameramen to stage any news artificially. What she forgets is how much of a puppet show the Contras really are - a creation of Washington. This dimension doesn't enter her thinking. Her view of 'the news' is not much purer or clearer than Tom's. He's just more honest about it.
What Jane and Tom's differences amount to really is a matter of personal taste. It's not really about jounalistic ethics or anything so grandiose but about small personal matters. he accepts schmaltz, she doesn't.
Broadcast News" doesn't really