Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Equal pay: a long was to go

Socialist Organiser no. 355, 12 May 1988 · scan p. 8 · about 504 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The recent decision by the Law Lords to uphold Julie Hayward's claim for Equal Pay is an important precedent, broadening the scope of sex discrimination legislation. Julie Hayward is employed as a cook at Cammel Lairds shipyard in Birkenhead. The work she did was compared to that of three male craftsmen, employed in different jobs in the same workplace, and was found to be of equal value" ie, requiring comparable skills and effort.

Up until now such a comparison could not have been made. The 1970 Equal Pay Act allowed women to apply for equal pay only when they did exactly the same job as a male worker in the same workplace or company.

The Government was forced to amend the Act in line with EEC statutes in 1984, to legislate for pay for women doing different but comparable jobs. Then it took Julie Hayward four years and innumerable hearings and court cases to win what are apparently her rights.

Now Julie's union, the GMB — who helped Julie bring her case to court - have said that they will not be supporting any more legal cases, but will be using the precedent "to help in collective bargaining". The GMB like other unions is very interested in recruiting women members in this period of membership decline. However, in the climate of new realism - where union leaders are willing to accept any kind of scabby deal from the bosses - "collective bargaining" by those leaders holds out limited hope for low-paid women workers. Only rank-and-file action will bring real gains.

Part of the reason that it has taken Julie Hayward so long to win her case has been the complete mess and confusion over what Equal Pay legislation actually means. Even now, the process involved in women bringing equal pay cases to tribunals or to court will remain longwinded and laborious, with or without the backing of their union. The Equal Opportunities Commission - one filing cabinet and an answering machine — is a joke. So why bother?

Even with the "equal value" clause, the present legal framework is quite limited. There is no provision in all-women or mainly-women workforces, eg textiles and shops. There can still be no comparisons made across companies and industries.

Should we be in favour of this? Some feminists have argued that this is the only way to combat low pay for women workers. Sometimes this is couched in terms of a redivision of the bosses' miserable cake - ie that men should be prepared to accept wage cuts!

But women do get the worst deal both on wages and on conditions. Women's work is often part-time. All of this means that women are more exploited.

We should be in favour of better Equal Pay and sex-discrimination legislation. Julie Hayward's victory should be used by the unions to fight for that. And the unions should be fighting to improve all aspects of women's work. The only way they will do this is through the mass involvement of women

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 355

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →