Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Solidarnosc and

Socialist Organiser no. 355, 12 May 1988 · scan p. 6 · Alan Johnson · about 922 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Alan Johnson argues that socialists need to understand what drives Polish workers to identify with the Catholic Church.

Many socialists in Britain are hesitant about supporting Solidarnosc because of the visible strong influence within it of the Catholic Church. But why is it that the Church has that influence?

Let's start with Father Jozef Tichner who preached at Solidarity's first national congress. His book "The Ethics of Solidarity" clearly supports workers taking strike action: *Senseless work is the most extreme form of the exploitation of man by man. It is a direct insult to the human dignity of the worker. When work becomes senseless, the strike is the only kind of behaviour which makes sense"

Tichner is not opposed to socialism. He merely distinguishes between 'Closed Socialism' (Stalinism) and 'Open Socialism' Closed Socialism', , "allows of only one possible form of exploitation -that which is the result of private ownership of the means of production. When, therefore, after the abolition of private property, the workers come to the conclusion that they are being exploited, closed socialism concludes that they have fallen victim to an illusion."

Or take Father Jerzy Popieluzko, the priest murdered by the Polish security forces in October 1984. After martial law of 1981, when many steelworkers in Warsaw were being arrested and jailed, beaten and attacked, Popieluzko declared *The duty of a priest is to be with the people when they need him most, when they are wronged, degraded and maltreated."

He sat with the steelworkers in court, he worked tirelessly to raise money, food, clothing for the jailed workers families. And, yes, he preached against the authorities as well. For that he was killed, his finger-nails ripped off, his body black and blue, his tongue ripped out.

Again in May 1977, in Krakow, a leading KOR (Workers' Defence Committee) sympathiser, Stanislaw Pyjas, a student, was killed. His funeral was attended by 2,000 students. Violence was feared. Who supported the students and appealed to the workers of Krakow to act to ensure they didn't get hurt? Cardinal Wojtyla.

When 14 people began a hungerstrike against the arrest of KOR members in 1977, where did they find sanctuary? In St. Martin's Church in Warsaw.

The church is one of the precious few places where Poles can escape the tyranny of the state. Before the rise of Solidarnosc, it was the only major institution in Poland autonomous from the state. The Catholicism of a Polish worker fighting for his or her class, or of a priest closely linked with such workers, is different from the Catholicism of the Vatican.

Here is a scene: 31st August 1985, the 5th anniversary of the founding of Solidarnosc. Workers, farmers, old, young are attending church for a 'birthday mass' . Posters, produced by the underground, are displayed. One shows a large fist crushing a prison. Another, a defiant 5-year old to represent Solidarnosc.

Hymns are sung, but hymns with words like "Oh my country, how long have you been suffering! How deep your wounds today!" An observer is "reduced to helpless tears by the passion in their voices" • As the 'birthday mass' ends a powerful voice comes through the loudspeakers "Let us swear to make Solidarnosc live"

Thousands of fists shoot into the air, and thousands of voices shout as one "We swear it" . And outside a group of Silesian miners — no doubt remembering their comrades killed in December 1981 - lay a wreath over the grave of Verzy Popieluzko. Where else, under martial law can workers gather like this, feel their unity like this, express their opposition like this?

Now to understand all this does not mean you have to support it. It doesn't mean we can forget the church has its own interests, its own goals, its own ideas — often bitterly opposed to what we stand for as socialists. It doesn't mean we stop proposing and fighting for secular, rational, human, workers' solidarity. But it does mean we can never support the bureaucrats on the grounds that their 'MarxistLeninist' mumbo-jumbo is somehow better than the workers? Catholicism.

Indeed, the most important thing to be said against the Polish Catholic Church is that its hierarchy has been one of the most important props of the Polish state!

It constantly preached 'moderation' and 'compromise' to Solidarnosc from August 1980 to December 1981.

Take for example the Bydogozcz crisis of March 1981. According to Timothy Garton-Ash in his book "The Polish Revolution' , the "workers would never again approach the extraordinary degree of mass mobilization, popular resolution and preparation which they achieved on 30 March" as they prepared to launch a general strike. At the eleventh hour Lech Walesa called it off. Walesa said: "The Pope wrote to us and the Primate pleading with us for reason and reflection".

And Jaruselski was happy to broadcast Archbishop Glemp's message the day after martial law, which said: "The authorities consider that the exceptional nature of martial law is dictated by a higher necessity. It is the choice of a lesser rather than a greater evil. Assuming the correctness of such reasoning the man in the street will subordinate himself to the new situa- Inside the Gdansk shipyard tion."

To refuse our support for Solidarnosc is to strengthen the church. Can't you hear the bishops? "Look at these western ABOUR socialists. They watch you beaten bloody with truncheons and thrown PARTY in jails for defending your rights. And what do they do? They dn nothing. Come to us..." SUPPORTA

----- pull-quotes -----

POLISH JORMERS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 355

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →