10 years of shattered dreams
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-05-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Socialist Organiser no. 355, 12 May 1988. Page By Gerry answer to the virulent anti-semitism unleashed in Europe, which was to reach its climax with Hitlerism. For many Zionists, this search for a nation state was bound up with socialist aspirations (although we might question what they understood by socialism.
Until the 1930s and '40s the project of building a settler state in distant and underdeveloped Palestine, surrounded by hostile and suspicious Arabs, seemed crazy to most Jews. But after the attempted genocide of world Jewry by the Nazis and the callous indifference to the Jews' plight of the other big powers, the Zionist case appeared to have been vindicated. Now they would put trust only in their own, Jewish, people and deal with other peoples in a ruthless and 'realistic' spirit.
The Allied governments told Europe's surviving Jews to stay in their 'own' countries — in countries like Poland, where there were pogroms after the end of the war. Those same governments had closed their doors to Jewish refugees in the '30s and'40s as Nazi persecution escalated. The Jewish survivors reacted with bitter, desperate fury.
Unfortunately that fury vented itself not on the ruling classes who deserved it, but on the Palestinian Arabs. The Jews, the most terribly oppressed people in the world, created an oppressor nation.
Britain ruled Palestine at that time. Zionist immigration since the late 19th century, and especially since the 1930s, had built up the Jewish population to one-third of the total.
The Jews, however, were more powerful than the more numerous Palestinian Arabs. They had developed a more-or-less autonomous Jewish economy - a modern capitalist economy, while the Arab economy was still semi-feudal — and a Jewish proto-state within the framework of the British colonial administration.
Over the decades, the Palestinian Arabs had become fiercely hostile to the Jewish immigrants. A large proportion of the Arab peasants had been driven off their land and become paupers. In truth, the people mainly responsible for this were Arab landlords, rather than the Jews, who had bought only 6% of Palestine's land, paying the landlords well for it.
But the landlords directed the peasants' fury against the Jews; and indeed the Arabs saw themselves refused jobs in industry and capitalist agriculture because of the 'Jewish-labour-only' policy, and often treated with racist contempt. As they saw it, the Zionists were taking over Palestine, bit by bit, to create a Jewish state in which there would be no place for the Arabs.
In 1936-8 the Arabs rebelled, but were defeated by joint action of the British and the Jews. By 1945-8 they were exhausted and disorganised.
Zionist groups started guerilla war against the British authorities. In 1947 Britain threw its hand in and passed the issue to the United Nations. The UN recommended the partition of Palestine into two states, one Arab, one Jewish.
Most Zionists acepted this partition plan. The Palestinian Arabs did not, and neither did the neighbouring Arab states. Jordan, Iraq and Egypt were still semi-colonies of Britain, but Britain decided that it must let their governments act Arab-nationalist on this issue.
British troops started to withdraw from Palestine. Arab guerillas attacked Jews. Full-scale war developed. The British troops stood by. The Zionists got arms from Russian-controlled Czechoslovakia; Stalin reckoned that they could be a useful lever against the British Empire. Better motivated, organised, and armed than the Arabs, the Jews prevailed.
There were atrocities. In April 1948 Zionist right-wingers massacred 250 non-combatant Arabs in the village of Deir Yassin. The mainstream Zionists condemned the killing, though in fact they had provided military cover.
By the time the state of Israel was
declared in May, 300,000 Arabs were already in flight. Then the neighbouring Arab states declared war, claiming that they would "drive the Jews into the sea'. The Zionists' citizen army, welldisciplined and utterly convinced of its cause, routed the Arab armies, drawn from corrupt, landlorddominated societies. The most effective force on the Arab side was Jordan's British-officered Arab Legion.
Israel established itself on far greater territories than originally proposed. The UN's proposed Palastinian Arab state disappeared: Jordan took the West Bank, and Egypt took the Gaza Strip. Both these territories were later seized by Israel in 1967.
By the end of the 1948 war, some 700,00 Palestinian Arabs had fled what became Israel. The new Jewish state refused to allow the refugees to return. Talks about letting some of them back in the early '50s came to nothing.
The Arabs who remained in Israel were put under military administration. By one means and another, a large part of their land was stolen from them. In place of the Arabs who had fled or been dispossessed, Israel settled large numbers of Jewish immigrants, from Europe and from the Arab countries, where the 1948 war had triggered a wave of anti-semetism.
Israel, then as now, was not much like the generous dreams of the socialist Zionists. The impulse for its creation came not from any great advace for the Jews, but from the horrors of the Holocaust; it was never an alternative to those horrors, but a result of them. In a socialist world it might have been possible to create a Jewish state peacefully, generously, without injustice; in the dog-eat-dog world of capitalism, only the most extreme fury and desperation could provide the necessary drive.
And no nation that oppresses another can itself be free: the last 40 years have given the Israeli Jews much proof of this, as their society has become more militaristic and racist.
Nationalism, even the nationalism of the oppressed, is a blind alley. But it is no good doing as many on the left do, and rejecting Israeli-Jewish nationalism only to embrace the opposed Arab nationalism, or pretending that Israeli-Jewish nationalism belongs to a special category, more vicious than any other nationalism. Nor is it much good saying that Israel should not have been created: today we have two nations, Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs, the great majority of whom had not been born in 1948.
Many argue that the creation of Israel was a deliberate plan by "imperialism': Israel was intended to be a 'watchdog' for western interests. In fact the Zionists wanted a. state for their own reasons - which were utterly understandable, after the Holocaust and the world's reaction, without any reference to imperialism. They were successful as a result of their own efforts. They were at war with the dominant imperialism in the region, Britain. And the 'special relationship' Israel now has with the United States did not develop until 1967.
The creation of a Jewish state had never been the essential socialist answer to the 'Jewish problem'. But the socialists were defeated in the first half of this century. Hitler triumphed. Six million Jews were massacred. The survivors had to make their way in a racist, dog-eat-dog, imperialist world. They did so, creating a new problem, that of the dispersed and oppressed Palestinians.
Socialist policy must look for a way forward, not backwards.
Ámong Israelis today there is a lot of soul-searching. Many question what successive governments have done to defend Israel's "security'. Israel has had bigger demonstrations against its government's war - in proportion to population - than any other coun try ever. Out of these protests a new, socialist movement can emerge, one that recognises the rights of the Palestinians and builds Jewish-Arab workers' unity,