What sort of anti-racism? JUSTICE
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-05-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Can some anti-racist education fuel racism and racist attacks? Newham 7/Justice for the Pryces. Socialist Organiser no.354 5 May 1988 Page 10 the press last week. The report, written by a committee of two white anti-racists and two black people, was asked for after a 13-year old Asian boy was murdered by a white fellow pupil at Burnage High School in Manchester, 18 months ago.
The gutter press has leapt on the report as a justification for not having anti-racist education in schools at all because "it is divisive by showing divisions", "it goes against the tradition of British tolerance" or it is even "black racism."
As Unmesh Desai pointed out in a letter to "The Independent' this week, "In fact, the type of anti-racism criticised in the report — principally that which is based on racism awareness training (RAT) - has been strongly attacked from within the black community for years, in particular by A. Sivanandan and the Institute of Race Relations.
For black people, racism awareness training and similar doctrines trivialise the issue of racism and undermine the struggle against it."
This official anti-racism sees the issue as bad ideas in people's minds, rather than structures in society, and thus ends up trying to push liberal self-condemning guilt to white people and corrupt ethnic pressure-group politics to black people.
For working class people, black or white, it is irrelevant — or indeed NULt E•KI damonstration. Photo Andrew Wiard, Report. harmful. It leads white working class people to see anti-racism as a middle-class fad and sheer hypocrisy - for the concern about racial disadvantge goes together with lack of concern about class disadvantage. It offers black working class people nothing concrete and leaves them to face the backlash.
At Burnage School, according to the report:
•White students were lumped into the same camp as Darren Coulburn" , Ahmed's murderer, even though Darren had been recognised as highly disturbed and should have been removed from the school after he burnt down the Arts Block in 1985.
•White students were prevented from attending Ahmed's funeral which "helped to reinforce a feeling among white pupils that they were somehow to blame for his death."
•In March 1987 nine white 5th year boys were locked in the school kitchen for their own safety and smuggled out in a van. They never returned to school. The school neither saw the grievances of the Asian pupils, nor resolved the position of the white boys.
The report puts it very well when says: "The basic assumption behind many policies is that since black students are the victims of the of white suderes iced e stadour are all to be seen as racist' whether they are ferret-eyed fascists or committed anti-racists. Racism is thus placed in some kind of moral vacuum and is totally divorced from the more complex reality of human relations in the classroom, playground or community."
We do need education in schools to understand other cultures and also the need to fight against racism, both institutional and personal. We do need to ensure equality of opportunity for black pupils. But to try to do this at the expense of mobilising for a general white and black fight against racism by guilt-tripping white people and haltıng free discussion on race issues is bound at some point to backfire. much more than this, but that was before the massive expansion of irrigation in the 1950s, from 2 million hectares to 7 million hectares. One of the crops is cotton, requiring water ten times a year.
But it is the other things that happen to the irrigation water that turn the story into a disaster.
First, because the water is not recycled into the Aral Sea, it runs off into a huge new salt lake in the North Turkmenian desert.
Second, the thousands of kilometres of irrigation canals, dug hurriedly and unlined, allow vast quantities of precious water to seep away.
Third, excess fertilisers and the natural salt in the ground are making the land too salty, harming crops and even affecting deep artesian ground water.
A leading Uzbek scientist believes that the Aral disaster could have wider effects on the climate of Asia, even harming the food supply of InThe solution, according to leading Russian ecologist, is a massive change in Uzbek land use, a shift to factories, and 'redistribution of the population' (i.e. mass evacuation). The other solution mooted is to resurrect the plan to reverse the flow of the Siberian rivers, only recently dropped after Russian and international protests.
The present idea would only involve 7% of the Siberian water, but environmentalists are still worried that it could upset the Arctic balance. perhaps triggering a new Ice Age!
The disaster is a direct result of bureaucratic police-state-style planning. With a priority of proluction at all costs, protests would e brushed aside or discouraged by the means available to all-powerful bureaucracies. The notorious corruption in the Uzbek "Soviet Socialist' Republic would see to it that attempts to control the waste of water would fail.
This is the very opposite of open, democratic socialist planningNational Union of Students conference WHETTON'S
Scan page 11
----- pull-quotes -----
SELF DEFENCE No OFFENCE