Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Pompous and boring

Socialist Organiser no. 354, 5 May 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 978 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

THE DOVErC Belinda Weaver "The Last Emperor™ The hot air from the Oscars might keep "The Last Emperor' afloat a bit longer, but it's a very leaden balloon, I wasn't the only person squirming in my seat during the long, long hours of watching it. I wasn't just bored; I was stupefied.

It is a film bristling with production values' - the sort of stuff that gets the producers interested in bankrolling movies. The sets and the costumes and the cast of thousands probably are a marvel, but they wear very thin after several hours of the stuff. You need a story to push things along, and this pretty set is overpopulated with everything but a story.

On paper, the subject of the movie must have sounded irresistible. Pu Yi was crowned Emperor of China at the age of three; he ended his life humbly as a gardener in Mao's China. In between, he lost his autocratic powers, became the tool of Japan as Emperor of Manchukuo, then lost everything again after the Second World War when Japan fell.

But Bertolucci, the director of this mess, isn't interested in Pu Yi. He doesn't make the man or his story live. All we get instead is a pageant with as much animation as the pictures in 'National Geographic' Pu Yi grew up in the Forbidden City in China, where he ruled over a By Ivan Well-intentioned official antiracism can backfire — and those who suffer are not the official anti-racists, but working class black people.

Such is the conclusion of a report commissioned by Manchester's Labour City Council and leaked to huge household of eunuchs and other hangers on. The city was totally cut off from the outside world. When China becomes a republic and Pu Yi loses his powers, we find out about it through a conversation. There is no sense of the world outside the walls of the Forbidden City.

This is a mistake. Once you've seen all the costumes once, you long to get outside to see what is going on, but like Pu Yi, you can't. Absolute power doesn't mean much if you can't get outside your front door. Pu Yi's life is a series of theatrical tableaux but, like tableaux, it is nothing like life.

When Pu Yi gets his freedom tınally, he wastes it, becoming a silly playboy, scheming with the Japanese to get a new throne in Manchukuo (Manchuria). From there, he falls into the prisons of the People's Republic of China, whence he emerges, supposedly reeducated and resigned, to take up his gardening duties.

None of this carries any conviction at all. We never get to see Pu Yi at all; all we see is a mask. The infant Pu Yi is the liveliest. As he ages, he becomes less and less interesting.

Perhaps Bertolucci is trying to show what a hollow man Pu Yi was, how he reflected his surroundings and adapted to them, chameleonlike. But it is a grave mistake to centre your film around a blank. If there is no other character to seize the audience's sympathy, interest drains away. Since Pu Yi is the only character on screen for any length of time, we rapidly get bored with NEV simply seeing his surface. Even his revelations in the prison camp are lifeless.

We hardly get to see Pu Yi in his daily life as a gardener either. It's as if Bertolucci found the Mao jackets a visual insult after the gorgeous reds and yellows of old imperial What is totally lacking in the film is any context. We never see the contract that could have brought the story to life. As it is, it's like a retrospective episode of "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous" - quaint but unmemorable, dullish.

Bertolucci is supposed to be a Marxist, so one wonders about his motivation in making this film. If his aim was to show the nothingness of the emperors, then his aim got buried undr brocade and ceremony. If it was merely to provide glamour junkies with a series of inside peeks, then it is reprehensible.

If I were Bertolucci, I'd be a little worried about that clutch of Oscars. When the Hollywood mafia call you a lion, it's generally because your teeth are no longer sharp. Is "The Last Emperor' really 'The Taming of Bertolucci'?

PRYCES .. Les Hearn's Gorbachev's government | is presiding over a scarcely credible ecological disaster in Uzbekistan.

The inland Aral Sea, previously the fourth largest in the world, is disappearing fast, together with the livelihoods hundreds of thousands of Uzbeks.

The problems of the Aral Sea were detailed starkly by the Guardian's USSR correspondent, Martin Walker, last week. In the last 30 years: • the Aral sea has lost 60% of volume, • the sea level has fallen by metres; • the port of Muinak, once home to 10,000 fishermen who used to provide 11% of the USSR's catch, is now 30 miles from the sea. To keep the canneries and fish processing plants going, frozen fish is brought in by train from the Arctic port of Murmansk.

The dried-up sea bed is now a salt desert. Vast dust storms whip up 50 million tonnes of salt and sand each year, depositing half a tonne on each hectare of farm land. This exfruit, tra salt is damaging suton pince cotton.

Uzbekistan produces 35% of the USSR's fruit, 40% of its rice and 95% of its cotton, the effects will be far-reaching.

What has caused this? Why has nothing been done? What can be done?] The Aral Sea needs 43 cubic kilometres of water per year to avoid shrinking further. The two greau Darya (Oxus) used to supply great Asian rivers Sir Darya and

----- pull-quotes -----

China beyond the imprisoning walls of the Forbidden City. That is the

Disaster in USSR

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 354

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →