Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

South Africa: 'The left must work together"

Socialist Organiser no. 354, 5 May 1988 · scan p. 9 · about 1,499 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

The black working class has the power to destroy apartheid and capitalism. Photo David Lurie (Reflex) African socialist How would you characterise the situation in South Africa overall?

It's difficult to generalise. However, there is a lot of tiredness. It's not so easy to call on the community to take action like consumer boycotts, stayaways, etc.

There is a growing realisation amongst people that the South African government is not going to topple in the next couple of years.

The fact that the miners could pull off such an impressive strike and sustain it was a really important victory for the miners and the working class generally.

However, there is a lot of demoralisation. I think 30,000 miners have lost their jobs. There is a lot of dissatisfaction about how the leadership of the NUM resolved the dispute with Anglo-American and the other mine bosses.

The same goes for the railway strike. The workers had to go back to the same conditions that they went out on strike against.

A large part of the reason for the downturn now is related to the way the Congress movement operated. They didn't build strong structures on the ground, they didn't consolidate. The mass consciousness was very superficial, people didn't understand the serious nature of the struggle.

What did consolidation mean?

Part of the answer can be provided by looking at the way Moses Mayekiso and other comrades in Alexandra township went about building democratic, accountable structures to help organise the townships and link together the trade union and community struggles.

The building of street committees only happened in a few areas. It was very difficult to do. An even more basic form of consolidation was needed - to develop inside the working class clear leadership and a clear understanding of the struggle and the fact that it's a long struggle.

One of the problems was that the black working class was told that revolution was round the corner and that all was needed was a final push and we would acquire power.

There was a lot of misleadership, and this can only happen when class consciousness is low.

When we talk about consolidation we need to look at how we can advance black working class leadership and infuse socialist ideas and consciousness within the working How do you see the political line-up inside the unions, in particular inside COSATU?

From the beginning of the '80s right up to '85, the trade unions isolated themselves from the populists and from popular struggles and the democratic demands that workers were putting forward.

At this time the bulk of the unions refused to join the UDF, At one time it looked as though the populist UDF unions were going to ressurect SACTU. Instead they were for unity. They got involved in the unity talks which led to the formation of COSATU. Some of these people got themselves involved in the major unions, took up positions and got themselves entrenched there, It would also be wrong to believe that the wave of populism that swept the country did not affect the workers in the unions.

The left in the unions didn't create an alternative pole to which workers could gravitate.

What form would such a pole take?

Various forms were put forward. Some people said we needed to build a mass workers' party, a popular socialist movement. People were talking about a mass workers' party on Brazilian lines.

Others were putting forward the need for a vanguard party, a Leninist organisation.

Why should the need for a Leninist organisation be counterposed to building a mass workers' party?

The argument against the mass workers' party revolved around the question of how do you seize power with such an instrument? People also pointed to developments in the Brazilian PT and asked, do we really want to follow this?

Other people on the left were worried by the idea of a vanguard party. How do you stop such an organisation turning into a Stalinist party? I don't think that the two ideas need to be mutually exclusive.

We as the Cape Action League should be very critical of ourselves. Especially in this last period, the socialists in South Africa have been very fragmented. We have not come together to decide as a policy or programme for the road ahead.

We have not sorted out our differences. In '83-'87 we tailended the populists. We need to correct this.

We also need to solve the problem of sectarianism, and encourage democratic debate and build accountable structures. We need to take on the bureaucracy in the mass movement.

It was very important that we organised outside the UDF. What was a weakness for us is that we didn't have a national organisation. We had problems in trying to formulate a clear strategy around the national question and class struggle.

tog

Often our slogans were too high pitched so they didn't mean much to people. We weren't able to formulate a mass line. We ended up with slogans like 'Smash capitalism, build socialism!' but it meant nothing to most workers. We failed to win a sufficient base within the so-called African working class. We were also weak initially in trying to organise student youth.

We are now trying to correct these errors. I think it is important to say that we are barely four years. old.

We have also made important gains, we have started to put socialism on the agenda. The first congress of the National Forum [an alliance of groups loosely associated with "black consciousness'] adopted beleve we've done a lot to help tis socialism perspective. development.

We could have been more bold about our politics. At various turning points we correctly predicted what was going to happen and we adjusted our tactics to entrench ourselves inside working class communities and to consolidate our base when we saw increased repression coming.

For a whole period we were a federal organisation with different groups affiliated. We only changed that recently and became a central organisation. This has helped us to consolidate and take steps forward.

We are in alliance with AZAPO. But AZAPO is not a homogenous. organisation. We have had many problems with AZAPO. At this point in time they are quite marginalised and have suffered many defeats, partly as a result of sectarian attacks.

Within AZAPO, unlike the ANC, there is no Communist Party. That means they are more open and we can argue for socialist poltics. AZAPO have moved from a position of anti-whitism, and we can win them over to a position of non-racialism and anti-liberalism. So we have made some gains. AZAPO has put forward a position of socialism.

But what kind of socialism does AZAPO support?

I think you should about that.

What is your attitude to the trade union left, the so-called "workerists'?

We have argued with the "workerists' over the years. Often we have shared similar criticisms of the workerists with the Congress movement.

I think we must see them as an important group of people who have played a major role strengthening the trade union movement. At the moment we share a similar position in fighting for the independence of the working class. There are times when we share similar positions, there are times when we differ. At the present time we need to work together.

How do you assess COSATU and NACTU as trade union federations?

We passed a resolution at our AGM which said that it is important to recognise that there are two federations in our country and also independent non-aligned unions.

We think that it is important to fight for the unity of the working class. There should be plenty of issues on which the two federations can unite. The ruling class can exploit a divided trade union movement. At the moment the two federations won't even share the same platform.

What attitude should socialists in Britain take to the struggle in South Africa?

Firstly, non-sectarianism is an important issue. We need socialists in Britain to popularise the left and what it does in South Africa, and not to play up one group against another group.

The left needs to intervene very actively in the Anti-Apartheid movement and to break down the AAM sectarianism which means that only Congress people supporters and associates of the ANC] get a hearing.

We need to strengthen links between the left in Britain and the left in South Africa. We need solidarity and criticism.

Workers' Liberty 88 will take place in 2-3 July Special courses • The national tion • Party and class •Workers in Eastern Europe There will also be an Introducing Marxism series for those new to socialism.

More details from Mark Osborn, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Organiser no.354 5 May 1988 Page 9

----- pull-quotes -----

A leading activist in the Cape Action League, a South

group, talked to Socialist Organiser

come together, didn't put over a coherent argument and didn't

Workers' 88 Liberty summer school

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 354

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →