A balance-sheet of the Broad Left NEC, 1987-8
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-05-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
accountability organises clerical workers in the civil service — has had a Broad Left majority on its National Executive Committee for the last year.
The dominant force in that Broad Marxist tendency. As the CPSA ap- Left is "Militant' avowedly proaches this year's conference, on 7-13 May, and awaits the results of this year's elections for the NEC, what is the record of the year of Broad Left leadership?
The first major issue confronting the new leadership in June last year was the ballot for all out strike action over the pay claim. It took place in extremely difficult circumstances. The right had refused to hand over the leadership; the Broad Left didn't take over until the beginning of June. The call for all out action did not come until 14 June, with two weeks of selective action still to go. CPSA members were tired after the long drawn-out selective action under the old rightwing leadership. The SCPS (now the NUCPS) had withdrawn from the joint action after Thatcher's victory in the general election. The vote went against an all-out strike, although there was a substantial minority for action.
Probably the vote could not have been won even if the Broad Left had run the best campaign imaginable. But it did not. The Broad Left machine was set into operation as if this was another election. It was assumed that left branches would deliver the vote. The arguments for the strike were simply not put.
That ballot defeat led straight in to an important climbdown in the DHSS section.
There was a seven month struggle in the DHSS around the introduction of the Tories' social security changes (the Fowler Reviews) and of Limited Period Appointments (LPAs). February 1987 saw the begining of staff training for the new system. The policy of the CPSA's DHSS Section conference was for non-cooperation and limited industrial action. Departmental management said they would apply for a writ as the action was political.
The Section Executive was split between the Militant majority and a left-wing minority including the Socialist Caucus (a left grouping within the Broad Left which includes SO supporters), SWP and others. Militant argued for a retreat. The DHSS was only one section of a right wing dominated union. Any action would therefore be unofficial. The only course open was a 'political campaign' Victory for the Broad Left in May radically changed that situa non. Here was an opportunity for the left under the leadership of the 'Marxists' to put into practice what it preaches about the need to turn back the Tories' offensive. The left could use its new position as leadership to mobilise against the Tories.
In June the Fowler issue was shelved in favour of the campaign for an all-out strike on pay - even though by this time the second stage of the reform was being implemented, the introduction of Limited Period Appointments or casual workers.
The union was told that LPAs would only be introduced to help get over the initial work on the Fowler package. But in fact these casual workers have been earmarked, are central to the Government's strategy for undermining the unions John Macreadie Photo: Nigel Clap and reshaping the civil service. For instance they will be used to help the introduction of new technology. which will result in the loss of 20,000 jobs in the DHSS alone. s (the Fowler Reviews) and of Limited Period Appointments (LPAs). February 1987 saw the begining of staff training for the new system. The policy of the CPSA's DHSS Section conference was for non-cooperation and limited industrial action. Departmental management said they would apply for a writ as the action was political.
The Section Executive was split between the Militant majority and a left-wing minority including the Socialist Caucus (a left grouping within the Broad Left which includes SO supporters), SWP and others. Militant argued for a retreat. The DHSS was only one section of a right wing dominated union. Any action would therefore be unofficial. The only course open was a 'political campaign'.
Victory for the Broad Left in May radically changed that situation. Here was an opportunity for the left under the leadership of the Marxists' to put into practice what it preaches about the need to turn back the Tories' offensive. The left could use its new position as leadership to mobilise against the Tories.
In June the Fowler issue was put on the back burner, shelved favour of the campaign for an all-out strike on pay — even though by this time the second stage of the reform was being implemented, the introduction of Limited Period Appointments or casual workers.
At the time the union was told that LPAs would only be introduced to help get over the initial work on the Fowler package. But in fact these casual workers have been earmarked, are central to the Government's strategy for undermining the unions and reshaping the civil service. For instance they will be used to help the introduction of new technology, which will result in the loss of 20,000 Jobs in the DHSS alone.
In early June the Section Executive agreed to launch a campaign over LPAs. No clear strategy was adopted; they just wanted to get something going.
The July Quarterly Executive reviewed the situation. The left wanted the fight against LPAs to be linked to a fight against the whole Fowler package, due to come into effect from April 1988. But now Militant argued that the union was in no position to break the law... They had moved the goal posts. The conclusion — no industrial action - was the same as before; only its justification had changed.
A campaign was launched around LPAs. The Section Executive decided on a four-week campaign leading up to a ballot on all-out strike action. And there was a militant response from the members: over 70 offices took action 4 or 5 all-out strike action, the rest taking regular selective strike action.
Within two weeks, Militant called an Emergency • Executive which overturned the strike call.
What had changed? According to Militant, losing the earlier ballot over pay would mean losing on this issue as well - and we must avoid truly make the decisions and the leaders carry them out. It is one where the leaders genuinely have the interests of the rank and file at heart - because those are their interests too.
A trade union bureaucrat, not answerable to the members and earning wages more than double that of most members, is not such a leader.
Militant supporters argue for 5 yearly elections. This is a concession to extending democracy within the CPSA, but does not go far enough. Our aim must be for the greatest democracy possible. Only yearly elections of all full-time officers and pay comparable to that of the rank and file, will achieve this. Civil servants demonstrate durin another defeat for the left.
Militant explained the climbdow as a 'necessary retreat' and the congratulated those members whi had taken strike action. But wha about the needs of the members t defend their jobs? In fact Militan were putting their own prestige an power within the union above thei members' interests. Defeat in ballot would undermine th "socialist leadership' within th branches, It wasn't deliberate betrayal. Bu the union, under the leadership o the 'Marxists', went from a polic of industrial action to defeat th legislation to a policy not even o paper opposition. This resulted i demoralisation among the most ac tive members and a mangagemen offensive.
The government now has a toc hold for LPAs. After this debac the union effectively lost an overall strategy of fighting goverr ment attacks.
Since then the policy of the Mil tant supporters on the NEC ha been to support local strikes -which is good - but to refuse t give any lead themselves. Mear while they are busy trying to fill th union's appointed full-time offici positions with Militant supporte — and they do not want to take an risks which could upset that.
The Camden DE strikers had t fight to overturn the Militant position that the strike could t won in one office. At the nation: ig two-day strike last year. Photo: And executive the Socialist Caucus supporters were the only two to support the strikers' call for official action. Militant initially wanted to put it through the unions' dispute panel.
The role of John Macreadie -the union's Assistant General Secretary, and a Militant supporter - in the health dispute is also instructive. He quite correctly called on the TUC to call a one-day general strike for the 14 March Day of Action. But propaganda on the TUC General Council is one thing, action is another. In fact, there was no real commitment from the CPSA leadership to winning workers to strike action over the issue.
The central problem here was the law. The left had been told by John Ellis, the right-wing General Secretary of the CPSA, that the action would be 'secondary' and so be taken to court.
Many other trade unionists did strike on 14 March without getting taken to court. But still, maybe you could argue that this was not the issue to fight on. The problem was that for the Militant leadership no issue is the right one to fight on.
And the union leadership's line was weak even if you agree that it would be too risky to make an official strike call. There wasn't much of an unofficial campaign, either. A circular calling for local ballots was put out. The right wing on the NEC blocked them getting the ballot