Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Poland: which side are we on?

Socialist Organiser no. 354, 5 May 1988 · scan p. 3 · about 1,057 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Parliament votes on Alton The strike wave in Poland poses once again the question: which side are you on?

On the May Day weekend, to mark he day ol international workers joined a TUC rally in Alo- workers' thousands of andra Palace, and 4,000 marched on a magnificent demonstration in Chesterfield, Tony Benn's constituency. Arthur Scargill was among the speakers in both places. He spoke well and boldly in support of the P&O strikers and in solidarity with the people of Chile, South Africa and Nicaragua.

Yet in both places the tremendous strike wave in Poland got no mention and no solidarity from the platform.

There is no doubt that activists of the banned Solidarnosc trade union are leading the strikes. Legalisation of Solidarnose 1S one of their demands. Yet many sections of the British labour movement are at best ambivalent in their attitude to Solidarnosc, or at worst overtly hostile. Solidarnose is supported by Thatcher and Reagan, they say, and by the Catholic church. So Solidarnosc must be an anti-socialist force, and must be opposed - or, at the very least, it is a dubious organistion, and Polish workers' strikes do not deserve the automatic solidarity we give to workers' struggles elsewhere.

Yet Solidarnosc in Poland is a workers' movement. Even if every individual in it favoured Westerntype democracy and market economics as his or her alternative to Jaruzelski's tyranny, it would is Stalinist-led workers movements still be a workers' movement - just in the West are still workers' movements despite their leaderships. In fact there are many socialists in Solidarnosc. If there are "Socialism' it is because they iden- also are hostile tify it with what they know Poland - a system which is not socialist at all, but calls itself socialist.

The experience of "socialism" as a system of bureaucratic, despotic rule, imposed by force of arms, has inevitably driven many Polish workers to believe that Western parliamentary democracy is a better system. It does not mean that they are all ardent Tories, any more than workers in the West who see the USSR in rose colours all want to crush independent trade unionism and send dissidents and rebels to mental hospitals.

If the labour movement of the West turns its back while the Thatchers and Reagans proclaim their support for the Polish workers, then how can we be surprised that some Polish workers see Thatcher and Reagan as better than they really are?

When Arthur Scargill supports General Jaruzelski (despite actatist Organiser * Box 823 London SE15 4407 01-639 7965 test date for reports: first post-Mon day or by phone Menday evening Editor: John O hahony Typosetting: Upstream Lid (TU).

01-358 13( Published by Socialist -Printed by Press Link Internatrona (UK) Lid (TU). Registered as a newspaner at the Post Office Signed articles do-not necessarily elect the view of Socialist Olemne Jaruzelski's scab record during the miners' strike, against which Scargill protested), is it suprising that Polish workers look to Thatcher:

And doesn't opposition to democratic trade unionists in Poland and elsewhere in Eastern Europe make it more difficult for us to convince British workers that socialism will not be a police state? In fact a victory for the workers" movements of Eastern Europe, razing to the ground the bureaucratic dictatorships and establishing a socialist democracy, will be a blow for socialism everywhere. With our encouragement, they are more likely to set socialism as their aim.

Reagan and Thatcher support Solidarnosc only to embarrass their opponents in big-power politics. They support the IMF, which is forcing the Polish government to introduce the price rises against which the workers are protesting. The US government knew about Jaruzelski's plans for martial law in 1981 and decided not to warn David Alton's anti-abortion bill returns to the Commons this week for the crucial report stage.

Alton's supporters have made some concessions in order to preserve as much support as possible among the 296 MPs who backed the Bill at its second reading in January.

The first allows abortions after 18 weeks for foetuses likely to suffer "a severe physical or mental disability". The second allows a woman aged under 18 years an abortion after 18 weeks if the conception appears to be as a result of rape or incest.

A number of amendments have been tabled for discussion at the report stage, most of them concerned with the actual time limit for legal abortion. The Speaker of the House, Bernard Weatherill, can decide either to take them in descending order, with the first vote Solidarnose.

No socialist can seriously believe that Reagan and Thatcher would continue to support Solidarnose or ШОУСШСИ ПАС И И И WEIC GIUSE LO 4. 1i1. laca ta winning power for the workers. Think of the example a Polish workers' democracy would set!

Reagan and Thatcher are friends of workers anywhere.

Battle

Knee-jerk responses, saying yes wherever our enemies say no, are a bad principle for socialists. What Reagan and Thatcher say is bad isn't necessarily good. Consider Khomeini. And what they say is good isn't necessarily bad. We need our own judgements. And surely, our starting point, always, is to be on the side of the workers, whatever their illusions.

We should not forget the many socialists in Solidarnosc who have no illusions in the West, and who clearly aim for a workers' democracy in Poland. We should not forget the Silesian miners, or the underground Solidarnosc Mazowsze region who protested at Polish scab coal during the miners' strike and sent messages of solidarity to the NUM. Arthur Scargill should not forget that at the time he was moved to say "I think I owe Lech Walesa an apology". Lessons should not be un-learned.

The situation in Poland could be explosive. And an explosion in Poland could spread. The British labour movement must take sides.

Jaruzelski is a dictator. Solidarnosc is a movement of millions of workers. The free development of that workers' movement should be far more important to us than the fact that Jaruzelski's state owns Polish industry and calls itself socialist.

With political freedom, workers can learn - even through mistakes — who are really their enemies and who are really their friends. For Polish workers to learn that it is British workers, not British bosses who are their friends, British workers must show them solidarity.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 354

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →