Fight in EEC
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 25 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 25
It could, of course, be moving sideways, upwards or downwards, retaining the same political positions but pushing for them in a different way. But it is not; the move is rapidly right-wards. The position advanced by Hobsbawm and other Euro-communists like Bob Rowthorn and Dave Prescott is, in essence, a revision to the type of argument for a government of 'national unity' put forward by the Communist Party towards the end of the Second World War when the party leadership argued that such a government should include 'progressive' Tories like Churchill and Eden.
It also draws heavily on the politics and experience of the Italian Communist Party, the PCI, whose search for a 'historic The NEC under Kinnock and Hattersley voted not to support NHS workers who strike. We need leaders who will stand solidly behind us, who will defend the health service now and not ask us to wait four years for a Labour government.
Karen Reissman, COHSE shop steward, Springfield Hospital, North Manchester.
If elections are seen to be a distraction then is a very worrying time for the Party. It is a dangerous argument because we have annual elections for the NEC and they are not a distraction. Elections are good because they always offer the opportunity to decide which way we should be going.
The leadership election will be no different It offers socialists the opportunity to discuss and debate in which direction the Party should be heading..
Billy Hayes, Branch Secretary, Liverpool UCW Amalgamated Branch (personal capacity)
This provides the labour movement with an opportunity to get us back debating socialisi policies and fighting on socialist principles. will bring the class struggle back into the George Hall, sacked Sun FoC, Branch committee, London Clerical Branch, SOGAT I'll definitely be supporting Benn and Heffer because they have made a stand in disputes like the miners' strike. They were with us. Kinnock showed his colours in the miners' strike and the Wapping dispute. He's just noi interested in people's struggles. It's about time we went back to socialist ideas rather than Kinnock's way of thinking. He has lost contact with the working class.
Liz French removal of Thatcher. What replaces her is of secondary importance. I argued against this view as far back as 1975 when in an article 'Two Labour Parties or One?' for the Political Quarterly, I wrote:
"The left view is that the crisis of capitalism must be the occasion to introduce socialist measures and move towards a classless, egalitarian society. This is the very opposite of those who say "Get the crisis over first, then move towards socialism later" • The face is that once the immediate crisis is over and the pressure is off, then the opportunities for getting measures through which can lead towards socialism are lost and it becomes more difficult at a later stage.' Hobsbawm's views on the prospects for socialism are founded on a belief that class politics are no longer key in the struggle. Whilst he has highlighted important changes in the structure of the working class in recent years which need to be taken into account in Labour's campaigns and policies, I believe he and the other Eurocommunists are quite mistaken in emphasising what they see as a fall in the importance of the workers' movement.
Labour must certainly bring its propaganda and methods up to date by taking into account the shift from manual to white collar and service jobs within the working class. It must not, however, abandon its basic class orientation. If it does, the core of its base of support will disappear and it will be little different from other reformist capitalist parties. Eric Hobsbawm Not all European countries are in the EEC, ana some have no wish or intention to join. This is the case with most of the Scandinavian countries as well as Austria and Switzerland. One cannot ignore the EEC, it is a fact of life which affects our legislation and our political and personal lives. I believe we should work for socialist and working class internationalism in Europe without making the EEC a major issue of contention at the present time, even if some of the European Socialists wish to do so.
I am not saying here that the Party should abandon its position on withdrawal from the EEC, that is still essential. But I do believe that we should step up attempts to bring the left together in all parts of Europe to fight in the EEC on the Council of Europe, and in all wider European organisations for nuclear disarmament, the phasing out of nuclear power, greater control over the multi-nationals, concerted aid to the Third World and working class unity in action throughout the European trade union movement.
In 1980, the Labour Party issued another pamphlet, The Dilemma of Eurocommunism which, though now bypassed by certain events, does not date in its essentials.
Part of its message is that in the EEC it is important that the industrial and political working class movement should as far as possible, join together ín action to fight the multi-nationals and to put forward an. internationalist perspective. Though this will not be easy it must in my view, be tackled. British socialism cannot build a wall around itself or solve its political and economic problems in isolation. The movement should enter into liscussions with all sections of the labour, socialist/communist movements in the EEC at the earliest possible moment and at all levels.
There are some positive discussions that can take place immediately, not on the basis of defending the Common Market by discussing the best way to operate the capitalist system which exists in the countries of the EEC, but on the basis of what actions we can take in all the EEC Countries to spotlight trade union solidarity advocating socialist policies which stretch across national boundaries.
Pare
Scan page 26
Party: a black socialist denounces those who want to ban Black Sections. Photo Stefano Cagnoni, IFL An d crati The London open, I see from the press that the Labour Coordinating Committee is holding its Annual Meeting in Liverpool tomorrow, and the Secretary says it has 1,000 members nationally. Whether it is registered or not, the truth is surely that it is an organisation. What about Labour Solidarity, the heir to the Gang of Four, and all the other groups! Labour is a "Broad Church" and in my view should remain one.
The important thing to remember in this situation is that the Party has been here before. Various left-wingers in the Labour Party have been expelled in the past and action taken against Constituency Parties because they did not agree to go along with the actions of the NEC. The ironical fact is that some of those expelled either, when they were let back in, moved to the right, or are now referred to by most people in the Party as Party stalwarts who were folk heroes, especially, of course, after they died.
The most prominent of the latter group is Aneurin Bevan. Today, we often hear Nye Bevan quoted and to some in high places in the Party he is a God-like figure. Yet he was once expelled, in 1938, from the Party, and almost expelled again after the Second World War when the Attlee Government had gone out of office.
The story of Nye Bevan's expulsion is told in Michael Foot's book about him. It is too long a story to be told in detail tonight, but it should be remembered. In 1932, the Socialist League was formed. According to Michael Foot, 'The Socialist League mounted a big attack on what it regarded as the Party's unsevered attachment to 'gradualist' ideas." One of the leading figures was Stafford Cripps. Whilst at first Nye Bevan did not join the Socialist League, he did later because he felt Stafford Cripps was a cleaner and more wholesome influence on the Labour leadership than any of the others. As Foot says, Bevan thought "Cripps' approach to Socialism might be crude, but was not a crude vitality greatly preferable to cynicism and lassitude?' The basic cause of Bevan's expulsion was his support for Sir Stafford Cripps over the issue of the Popular Front. Whether one agrees or disagrees with the Pare 24 emocratic p Popular Front concept, it was no reason to expel people from the Party. Cripps put forward a petition. He was expelled from the Party. Bevan said, "If every organised effort to change Party policy is to be described as an organised attack on the Party itself then the rigidity imposed by Party discipline will soon change into rigor mortis."
I would say to Party Leaders today, take note of what Nye Bevan then said, that the Party should take special care not to transform itself into "an intellectual concentration camp".
Re-establish
How should we respond? Not by sectarianism, because this is not a sectarian movement. Not by leaving the party, because it belongs to us. Not by splitting the party, because unity is strength. Not by personalising it, because our whole objection is that when they want to attack us they pick a personality and try to destroy that personality.
Our answer is to re-establish within the labour movement the traditions of socialism that brought it into being and gave it the greatest gains it had. Our business is to restate the demands that working people make: the right to work, the right to a good education throughout life, the right to proper health care free at the point of need, the right to a good home, the right to dignity in retirement, the right to peace. That is our job: to restate those demands, and go on making them until they're met.
Our job is to rediscover solidarity, to rediscover internationalism. The struggle we are waging in Liverpool is exactly the same struggle as the miners, exactly the same struggle as the people of South Africa, exactly the same struggle as the people of Nicaragua and Turkey. The internationalism of capital, which would deny Liverpool the resources to earn a living, has got to be replaced by the internationalism of Labour.
We are going through very hard times at the moment. But having said all this, I believe the Labour and socialist movement in Britain today is far stronger than at any time in my life. arty Stronger because of people like the Liverpool Councillors, the miners, and the black communities who stood up for their rights.
is frequently suggested that groups within Labour's ranks constitute separate parties within the Party. There is undeniably a grain of truth in this.
Any organisation within the Party must to some extent have a membership with a dual loyalty, a commitment to both the Labour Party itself and to the organisation that is working 'for its objectives within it.
There is nothing wrong with that provided the group takes the view that its objectives are to maintain, protect and develop the fundamental principles of the Party.
We have always been a federal organisation and should not fear changing back towards a more federal, decentralised structure.
The Labour Party has never been . a democratic centralist organisation and in my view should never become one. Democratic centralism is advocated by both the Communist Party and the Trotskyist groups. It is a theory which allows democratic discussion within the organisation but demands that all members present the majority position in public. In practice the centralist half of the equation has tended to dominate the democratic half.
Today, compared with the days of my youth, the books by Marx and about Marxism are more widely available and more numerous.
But whilst there are university courses in this field there has been little education, since the collapse of the NCLC, amongst working class organisations in the basics of Marxism.
The various Marxists groups have helped fill the gap left by the NCLC. Socialist Action, Socialist Organiser, Militant, The Morning Star, Labour Leader and many others, do an important job of helping to teach young workers the nature of society, the character of the State, and the centrality of the class struggle. It would be a serious retrograde step if such papers were banned for sale in the Party, and their supporters driven out.
Scan page 27
for almost toot; a. tressed the class herbings the move * the working STARVED, work of the working class te
----- pull-quotes -----
WORKERS! history and LIBERTY
-BATTERED, DEFIANT