Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

'Revolutionary reformism'

Socialist Organiser nos. 352–353: Fight the Tories! Rebuild the Left!, April 1988, undated · scan pp. 24–25 · about 1,289 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 24 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 24

participation in policy-making is very patchy and could be greatly improved.

Thirdly, we must emphasise the importance of involving black and Asian people in the work of the Party. That means appointing full-time organisers in this area and going beyond the present policy of setting up Ethnic Minority Committees. I believe the black and Asian comrades must have direct representation on the NEC.

Fourthly, the Party must build a mass membership, with the objective of having party groups within the branches in every street and block of flats in the country.

Fifthly and finally, we should point out that the time has come to create a really effective political education programme. This should not be solely concerned with organising work for elections, but with teaching the political theory of socialism and developing the organisation to put that theory into effect. Since the demise of the NCLC there has not been an effective socialist educational organisation, and the Party should move quickly to create one.

The Black Sections' position is we support Benn and Heffer because they support black people. We are holding true to our socialist principles and that is why we are under attack from Kinnock and Hattersley, but we have also said that the platform of Benn and Heffer must be specifically anti-racist and they must include Black Section speakers at their meetings.

We are disgusted at the way the current leadership have conformed to Thatcher's agenda. This means the abandonment of blacks as an electoral liability.

Labour Party Black Sections The campaign to elect Benn and Heffer give socialists a boost in the unions as well as thi Labour Party. The leadership of the NUT have retreated from the Tories like Kinnock has done. Teachers who want to resist the government will be supporting the Benn-Heffer campaign.

Andy Dixon, NUT EC member, Greater Manchester.

It's a good thing and I hope the teachers will go to their ward meetings and vote for Benn and Heffer. Many people in Haringey are fed up with the Labour Party who they see as the ones making the cuts and attacking them.

Hopefully the Benn-Heffer campaign will make it clear there are two different Labour Parties and many are fighting back against what the Labour Party did here. There is a need for a regroupment of the left and the campaign will provide that.

Tony Brockman, secretary, Haringey NUT.

PaRe If second chambers have proved so obstructive to progressive policies then why do democratic socialists believe that socialism in Britain can be achieved through Parliament?

It is a question which those on the left, who are democratic socialists, but who believe in revolutionary socialist policies, cannot avoid facing up to.

There have been plenty of examples where democratically elected, progressive socialist governments have been overthrown by force. Hitler destroyed democracy in Germany, Mussolini in Italy, Franco in Spain, the colonels in Greece, the military in Turkey.

Unfortunately, in most countries in the world, democracy is weak and dictatorship is strong. Democracy under certain circumstances could be destroyed here but Labour will never do anything to endanger it.

We are opposed to the use of force to remove opposing political forces and the only occasions on which Labour might resort to it would be in the defence of democracy, as the Austrian socialists did when they fought to try to preserve democracy in their country in 1934.

The Labour Party is not a pacifist party and there are occasions when antidemocratic forces have to be dealt with in a democratic society. But it is essential to make sure that in the process all the basic democratic rights of the people are protected.

The type of policy required is what I have described for want of a better phrase 'Revolutionary Reformism' . To some extent Cole was the precursor of that concept, although he never used the phrase.

In 1954, he wrote a pamphlet published by the New Statesman and Nation in which he said:

"This pamphlet is about Socialism, by which I mean a society without class, and not one in which a new class structure has replaced the old.

"It is not about the policy to be followed by a Labour Government which is not seeking to establish a classless society, but only to nationalise a few more industries and add a few more pieces to the equipment of the Welfare State. It is an attempt to indicate a way of action for those socialists who feel a sense of frustration because to them Socialism means something radically different from the management of the Welfare State...

"If we mean to constitute a really democratic society, permeated by the spirit of social equality, we shall have to find ways of replacing old incentives of fear and habit with new inducements more consistent with the recognition of equal human rights...

"Social ownership is only half the battle; the other half is real participation by the workers in control — not only at the top, but at every level from the work group upwards. By participation I do not mean merely consultation; I mean real At the moment, despite the new NEC document on social ownership, we are neither being offered real social ownership nor real control by the workers. With the concept of 'new partnership' we are back in the realms of Gaitskell's pamphlet, Industry and Nationalisation, Tony Crosland's The Future of Socialism, John Strachey's Contemporary Capitalism and the Party Policy Statement of 1957, Industry and Society.

SOCK UST OR

Scan page 25

I believe that the Party today has to take a tremendously important decision as to the direction in which it is going. Is it to remain a basically socialist party, or is it to become a sort of Social Democratic Party Mark 2? The signs are that it is moving in the latter direction. For a short period after the leadership election the direction the party was taking was not clear. The election of the 'Dream Ticket' was supposed to be a balance between right and left and this confused many people.

But very quickly, at higher levels if not at grass-roots, the Party was tilted to the right.

Some on the left began to talk about the Leader being captured by the right, that Neil Kinnock was a prisoner who needed saving from those on the Shadow Cabinet around him.

All of this was very interesting at the time, but in the light of subsequent events it was irrelevant. The membership has now clearly been told that the Party is moving in a new direction. compromise' with sections of the ruling class has been a governing strategic objective.

I have the greatest admiration for the PCI. It is a genuine mass party of the Italian working class. But to translate the situation they face in Italy directly into a British context is a major mistake. It ignores the vital asset which Hobsbawm admits Labour has: "The capacity to win an election and form a government singlehanded' It is that asset which caused Labour in the late 1930s to reject the Popular Front, and which made Labour go all out for Government in 1945 instead of the 'national unity' administration advocated by the CP. That asset must today be the cornerstone of Labour's forward thinking.

It is the pessimism of Eurocommunists like Eric Hobsbawm which I find most depressing. For them, the struggle for socialism must be postponed.

Their constant theme is that the central task facing the workers' movement is the /963. MINEURS FRANCALS. EN LUTTE CONTRE DE GAULLE SOLICARITE 1984. MACURS ANGLA/S EN LUTTE CONTRE TATCHE P SOLOMRITE PRUR LE CHARBOR MÊME COM EAT nternational solidarity: French miners back British miners

----- pull-quotes -----

ERIC TE LABOUR'S FUTURE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 352–353: Fight the Tories! Rebuild the Left!

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →