Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialism means freedom

Socialist Organiser nos. 352–353: Fight the Tories! Rebuild the Left!, April 1988, undated · scan p. 23 · about 591 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 23 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 23

This breakdown of the authority of the Soviet Union produced a development which severely tested the commitment of the Labour Party to those struggling for freedom in Eastern Europe — the Polish workers' formation of Solidarity. It was clear that the official trade unions in Poland were basically adjuncts of the State, and instruments of the Party hierarchy.

The workers in Poland wanted a trade union organisation of their own which was free and independent of the State and the Party, and which they could control themselves. The fact that the Church, or at least some of the priests, supported Solidarity in no way detracts from the importance of the development, neither does it make the movement of workers basically anti-socialist as some, including leftwing trade union leaders, have suggested.

When I first raised the matter of support for Solidarity on the NEC, I had a tremendous struggle to get my resolution accepted. Some of my natural allies opposed it and one trade union member suggested that Solidarity was not a real union but a breakaway, and therefore it could not be supported.

I reminded him that he himself had supported an unofficial movement, in the Seamen's Defence Movement, in his own union years before. That movement had, at one stage, talked of forming a new union and I was one of those who urged them to remain in the NUS and fight to change it because they had the opportunity to do so. In Poland such opportunities did not exist and the workers had to forge new instruments to make any progress.

The NEC were proved right in giving their support to Solidarity and that was particularly underlined when the miners' strike took place.

The Polish Government, like the South African Government, exported coal to this country during the strike. The 'official' unions (Solidarity had been suppressed) did not object and Arthur Scargill and the NUM leaders had to make a strong protest to the head of the Polish Government.

In a foreword I wrote in a pamphlet issued by the Eastern European Solidarity Campaign titled The British Labour Movement and Oppression in Eastern Europe, I made it clear that in my view it is impossible to create a socialist society without freedom. Socialism and freedom are indivisible. Socialism means the Excerpts from Socialist or SDP Mark 28' ing that in doing so they are protecting the Soviet Union from capitalist forces internally and from hostile capitalist elements outside.

Because Soviet diplomats and visitors from the Soviet Union tend to meet predominantly with trade unionists and politicians who hold these views, they get the wrong impression of how their countries' policies are perceived outside. Socialists should at all times attempt to put the record straight.

Workers' democracy: Solidarnosc in sessic Dissident groups and individuals seeking democratic changes should receive the support of socialists in the Western capitalist countries, even it we do not always fully or even partly agree with their political ideas or positions.

To give such support does not mean that one is siding with those reactionaries who wish to create confrontation and possible war.

Unfortunately, the Soviet and other East European communist leaders are helping the reactionary forces by their actions against those who are critical of the regimes. They are, of course, protecting their own privileged positions.

If free and open debate took place in these societies, the people would demand changes, just as they did during the Polish Solidarity upsurge, the Hungarian revolution and the Czechoslovakian Spring.

----- pull-quotes -----

Hetfer's book, 'Labour's Futures

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 352–353: Fight the Tories! Rebuild the Left!

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →