SWP and the wheelbarrow
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 22 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 22
'If you want to push a wheelbarrow, don't sit in it'. So said Paul Foot, Daily Mirror columnist and front man for the sectarian and obscurantist Socialist Workers' Party, explaining his policy towards the Labour Party According to the SWP, the Labour Party possesses such truly fantastic power that socialists had better keep it at arm's length if they don't want to be corrupted by it. Membership of the Labour Party can rot your brain, and the main corrosive influence is 'electoralism' , under pressure of which even the best socialists will gradually move further and further right until they have completely abandoned socialist principle.
Foot made his wheelbarrow joke in 1982, just as the Militant editorial board were being expelled from the Labour Party — in other words, just as the Party bureaucracy were getting things back under control and reasserting their authority. For the SWP, the witchhunt only went to show that the whole struggle to change the Labour Party had been a complete waste of time — about as much use as trying to revolutionise a wheelbarrow.
The moral, then as ever, was meant to be that the best thing to do was get out of the wheelbarrow and do something else. It is pointless trying to change the Labour Party because it is built for the wrong purpose: since socialism doesn't come through elections, it's pointless trying to win them. 'We need a different sort of party, the SWP insist — one that gets stuck into strikes.
This general argument of the SWP's led them to pour scorn on the big democracy struggle in the Labour Party in the early 'eighties, promising that it could only end in tears, and later happily concluding that they had told us so. The fact that it might not have ended in tears if they had thrown their own not insignificant weight into it never seemed to occur to them.
In fact the abstention of people like the SWP from that struggle helped pave the way for the rise and consolidation of the New Right under Kinnock.
But the SWP gave it all a particularly quirky twist at the time. They have a theory according to which the British working class Page is suffering from a long-term 'downturn' in its combativity and rank and file organisation. The trouble with the Bennite movement was that it had no real base among rank and file workers; it didn't understand that the rank and file was moving to the right. So there was no point having all this left wing democracy stuff in the Labour Party anyway, as it was way above the heads of most workers.
In other words — the Bennite movement the carly 'eighties was too left wing and rushing too far ahead of the working class.
Later they were to comment, revealingly: "during the period of Bennism in the early 'eighties we had to steer a course away fron the rest of the left for fear of being pulled i to the 'swamp' ". (Socialst Worker Review, April 1987).
For fear! The SWP was afraid of Labour left.
Having thus stood on the sidelines giving everyone these classically sectarian lectures the SWP suddenly found a miners' strike on their hands. For the miners' support committees they initially had nothing but scorn (again), describing them as 'left wing Oxfam' — until they realised that there was real life in these committees — and that most of the life came from Labour Party members.
The SWP lurched again, and went on a 'be nice to Labour' binge, which included a series of unrequited love letters to Militant ('revolutionaries except for being in the Labour Party') and a number of general appeals to Labour Party members to leave it and join them.
Now they woke up to the witch-hunt, decided it was a very bad thing, and launched a petition against it.
Alter years of considering the Labour rarty to be 'dead', or at least too middle class to bother with, they found themselves with not much to do except stand outside Labour Party meetings selling Socialist Worker. Indeed, a Central Committee document commented that "the sales help us to get a feel for the local working class movement and understand the sorts of arguments we are up against." (Socialist Worker Review, April 1987).
'IT" electoralism actually to go inside the meeting to participate in the discussion: far better to go to the pub.
The SWP's basic problem is that they see mass electoral activity, and work in the Labour Party, as counterposed to industrial struggle. Come elections, they call for a Labour vote ('without illusions'), and indeed in 1979 dropped all criticism of the Labour government (For the next three weeks I shall be a solid Labour supporter' , said Paul Foot). But it doesn't hold together very well politically: in 1987 they understood the significance a Labour victory would have, bu refused to draw the obvious conclusion that they should go out and canvass - too electoralist, you see.
But the division they make between industrial and political activity is identical to the one made by the right wing — who are quite happy to have socialists avoid general political activity, like elections, as it lets them off the hook. In fact what socialists need to do is to integrate industrial and political activity into a coherent strategy.
Of course the Labour Party is usually electoralist, and often crudely so. But the way to challenge that is to fight it, not to run away from it. Socialists in the Labour Party have shown that they can run left wing election campaigns without sacrificing their principles It is indeed the argument of the right that you have to be right wing to win votes.
Now, of course, the SWP are cheering on the Benn and Heffer campaign — not quite their attitude to the Benn for Deputy campaign in 1981! But their approach is characteristically illogical.
Either it's a good thing if the Labour Party has a left wing leadership, in which case they should seriously join the fight to see that it gets one; or it doesn't matter one way or the other, in which case they should say so. Logically, from the SWP's point of view, it's a bad thing if the Labour Party moves to the left, as a new generation of workers will have to learn how awful it is.
But it's not just an illogical approach; it's also opportunist. They don't spell out what their leave the Labour Party' policy really means (and if we all leave the Labour Party there would be no chance of electing Benn and Heffer, would there?), because it would make them unpopular.