Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Beating the ce

Socialist Organiser nos. 352–353: Fight the Tories! Rebuild the Left!, April 1988, undated · scan p. 18 · about 820 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 18 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 18

How, when Labour is in power, do you really establish a commanding position over the Establishment which you have democratically won the right to control? We must strengthen the role of Ministers. It may be it would be better if we put committees of MPs into Departments.

You would have 15 or 20 Labour MPs in each department to keep an eye on what was going on and to maintain contact with the trade union movement, with the Parliamentary Labour Party, and with the Party outside.

A Freedom of Information Act would also tip the balance very substantially in favour of democratic control.

In the nationalised industries, you can't have elected chairmen. But I think the appointment of Ministers over nationalised industries has got merit. Because what happened to the nationalised industries under the Herbert Morrison scheme was that when they were set up, the chairman - Edwardes or Robens or Marsh or McGregor - had absolutely dictatorial powers.

The Treasury insists that they follow the economic criteria appropriate to a private enterprise, and the result is that public ownership has become in many ways an instrument for restructuring capitalism on capitalist criteria.

I am an absolutely committed believer in workers' self-management. It has always seemed to me strange that we should accept as normal that the electorate can hire and fire a Prime Minister but that workers can't hire and fire their management. The right of the workforce to control management would be one of the most significant ways of dealing with that situation.

The task of a socialist is to analyse where power really lies. The Press tells us the power lies with the 'Left-dominated National Executive Committee' and the 'trade union bosses'. That's the way the Mail, the Express or the Sun put it.

But anyone who has thought it out knows that true power in our economy Tony Benn explainer some of his ideas about socialism in a 1980 interview with Socialist Organiser does not reside there. It still resides with the landowners and the bankers and the multinationals and the IMF and the EEC and so on.

If you try to change things, how can you beat those centres of power? To answer that, you've got to convert yourself into a different sort of analyst, say: they've got power now, but they've got the power now because we accept that they have power. If we decide that they won't have power, then they would not be as strong as they appear to be.

In March 1974, when we were elected, the financial and business establishment was really totally demoralised by their defeat. One of the tragedies of the last Labour Government was that 18 months later, after the referendum, the morale of the Establishment had been completely re-established. But it didn't have to be re-established.

They were in a position then, even when the Labour Government had a small majority, of having to go along with whatever we asked. The trouble was we didn't ask enough. Indeed, we not only didn't ask enough — in the end as you know it became a retreat. That Government almost ended up in an alliance with the Establishment.

Although there would be difficulty, I don't believe that the British people would accept an act of sabotage by the Establishment against a clear mandate given to a Labour Government by the electors. It would be a tussle, but a tussle to be won by consent, provided, and always provided, that you have said clearly before you start what you intend to do.

The Labour Party exists, and existed first, outside Parliament. The theory which is advanced by some revolutionists, that the whole Parliamentary process is inappropriate for social change, forgets the fact that the Labour Party was founded outside Parliament and it fought its way in by election.

The original idea of the LRC was the right of working people to be represented in Parliament. Despite this, some of the tendencies have developed in the last 30 years of revisionism have moved towards Edmund Burke's idea that when an MP gets there he or she then represents everybody, and the Labour Party is seen as just another pressure group. That is not acceptable. The Party is entitled to determine policy and see that those views are put forward in the House of Commons.

That is not to say that the only instrument of social change is the House of Commons, because the House of Commons is inevitably the last place which pressure for reform reaches.

Of course the transformation towards socialism by democratic means will involve changes in institutions, and l've mentioned some of them: the possibility of sending committees of MPs into ministries, the possibility of having Ministers in charge of certain operations with respect to nationalised industries and so on.

This does not lead you to the need to analyse, in greater detail than the Labour

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 352–353: Fight the Tories! Rebuild the Left!

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →