What might have
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 16
The Left since 1968 The Tories are not invincible, many times since 1979 there have been occasions when they could have been driven from office.
If when Thatcher was first elected the labour movement had waged a militant campaign against them, they could have been beaten. If the trade unions had refused to talk with them, and instead had thrown themselves into winning disputes and building solidarity with workers on strike, Thatcher could have been humbled.
Sometimes, as Thatcher approaches her tenth year in office, she seems invincible. She looks immune to the kind of mass action that forced the last Tory Prime Minister, Edward Heath, to resign in 1974. What nas happened to make the left, which seemed so strong in 1974, seem so weak today?
The left has played a part in making itself weak. In the late 1960s, the left in Britain was far stronger than it had been for many years, mainly as a result of the big upsurge in student radicalism in 1968. The trade union movement, too, was strong - strong enough to prevent the Labour government imposing anti-union legislation. By the early 'seventies, sections of the 'new' revolutionary left -especially the International Socialist group, which today is the Socialist Workers' Party (SWP) — were able to sink some roots into the trade unions. At the time of Heath's defeat by the miners, IS had a few thousand members.
But IS believed, as the SWP still do, that it was possible to build a new political labour movement from scratch, as alternative to the Labour Party, which they said was 'dead' '. Many other socialists had similar attitudes.
The Heath government was battered throughout its period in office by industrial militancy, reaching near-general strike proportions in July 1972, and culminating in the government's downfall. Yet the political counterpart of this strength and militancy remained the Labour Party — and it was a Labour Party which in office was to prove as anti-working class as Heath had been, and was to pave the way for Thatcher.
An alternative to the dominant politics and ideology of the labour movement needed to be fought for within the Labour Party. Yet virtually all the left, like IS, had abandoned that arena of struggle entirely.
The strongest far-left group before '68 had been the Socialist Labour League, which had long since destroyed itself politically with the sectarian fantasy that it was already the 'alternative leadership' of the labour movement. Within the Labour Party there was, by the early There were big demonstrations against unemployment in 1981, but for the most part the Labour and trade union leaders ran for cover.
The steel workers posed the first major threat to the Tories. A general strike was being called for by rank-and-file militants - but the TUC refused to act.
They refused to act later, in 1982, to win the health workers dispute.
In 1984 the miners embarked on the greatest national strike in British history. But the TUC, firmly committed to the 'seventies, only the Militant tendency, in practice a highly sectarian and bureaucratic group. Militant's prominence in the Labour Party Young Socialists and in Liverpool were largely also the result of the exodus of so many other socialists from Labour in that period.
It was just possible in 1983 to regard Neil Kinnock as a left-wing candidate for Leader. The last five years should have disabused everyone. This election is about renewing socialist policies and leadership and widening the appeal of socialism to millions. The only candidates that are capable of winning people to socialist ideas are Benn and Heffer. The sad truth is no one else will try.
Reg Race, former MP for Wood Green, Socialist Conference organising committee member.
The Labour Party proved that it was not dead, and was sufficiently alive to dampen down the industrial militancy of the early 'seventies. Under the Wilson and Callaghan governments, many socialists came to recognse the need to challenge the Labour Party leadership directly by fighting for democracy and accountability FING France '68
theory of 'new realism' - do nothing in
case it doesn't work — sat on their hands, even when the NUM's funds were sequestrated. Neil Kinnock and the Labour Party leaders sat on the fence, and failed to throw their weight behind the strike.
So the miners were allowed to go down to a bitter defeat.
Many other workers have been left to fight alone, or sold out before a fight.
Passivity on the movement's leaders defeat. Defeat was part of the labour paved the way for seen to justify more within the Labour Party.
This internal challenge gathered strength after the Callaghan leadership lost the general election in 1979. Important changes in Labour Party rules were pushed through, giving local Parties the right to reselect or deselect MPs, and putting the election of Leader and Deputy Leader into the hands of the Party conference.
The issue of democracy was combined with issues of policy. The democracy campaign was about ensuring that there would never again be a Labour government that rode roughshod over the wishes and decisions of Party conferences; democracy was needed to ensure that governments implemented Party policy. It was because this was too much for them to stomach that the Social Democratic Party split.
The climax of the political counterpart of the democracy battle was the nearlysuccessful campaign to get Tony Benn elected as Deputy Leader in 1981.
Politically, the democracy movement was quite diffuse and incoherent. And this incoherence was to matter.
A lot of the Bennite left, as they rose to prominence within the radicalising
Scan page 17
been passivity. So the downward spil defeat went on.
The health workers today show it is still not too late. The labour and trade union movement could still turn the tide. But it needs to change course.
The Tories have been allowed to get away with several instalments of anti### SOGAT OFFICIAL OMEN UNITE DISPUTE