Militancy's last rites! SAV
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Administering the last rites to militant trade unionism (and even to the working class itself) has become a fashionable pass-time in right wing circles in recent years.
Even sections of the 'left' have taken to writing off the organised working class and looking round for new 'alliances' to defeat Thatcherism.
Meanwhile, at the top of the trade union movement defeatism is the order of the day. 'New' forms of trade unionism - no strike/single union deals, cheap holidays and even credit cards — are conjured up as the alternatives to 'old fashioned' class struggle.
But reports of the death of the class struggle are, as Mark Twain might have said, somewhat premature. The Tories have inflicted a series of important setbacks on the working class since 1979 but they have not succeeded in imposing a decisive defeat. Even the outcome of the miners' strike has not set back the industrial struggle in the way that — for instance — the defeat of the 1926 General Strike did. Union membership is down (to around 9 million compared to 12 million in 1979) but the unions remain intact and shop floor organisation is still remarkably strong.
In recent months the rank and file in the motor industry, the NHS and the Channel ferries have shown a fighting spirit that puts the cowardice and defeatism of the union 'leaders' to shame.
This resurgence of militancy shows every sign of continuing and spreading and it will further sharpen the divisions that exist within the trade union bureaucracy.
The leaders of the TGWU, COHSE, NUPE and the 'left' of the TUC are willing to put themselves at the head of rank and file struggles if only to recruit members.
Meanwhile, the leaders of the EETPU, the AEU and the TUC right are now more or less openly committed to company unionism and regard militant action from the rank and file with undisguised hostility.
The left bureaucrats, of course, are quite capable of sabotaging struggles (witness the TGWU's handling of the Ford dispute and NUPE's response to calls for a one-day general strike on 14 March) but in the face of an upsurge in struggle the lefts feel obliged to give at The new realism has played havoc with the party in Manchester. A campaign to support Benn and Heffer along the lines of the policies we are going to need to fight the Tories is long overdue and can only strengthen us.
Pete Keenlyside, executive member, Manchester District Labour Party Defending the NHS. Photo: S. Caballe least some token leadership.
In this situation an open split within th TUC and even the emergence of an alter native, right wing trade union centr becomes a real possibility. Socialist would, of course, oppose any attempts o the right to split the TUC. But we shoul not delude ourselves that the lef bureaucrats offer a qualitatively bette alternative to the open class collaboratio! of the Hammonds and Lairds.
What is required is a new leadershi] based on, and accountable to, the ran! and file.
Some people on the left argue that w should ignore the question of leadershij and concentrate exclusively on promotin rank and file struggle at the point of pro duction. But even generalised militanc (of the type that occurred in Britain bet ween 1972 and 1974) is not in itself suffi cient to bring about socialism. Unions ar the bedrock organisations of the workin; class but they fight within capitalism bargaining over the price of labour rathe than fighting to abolish wage labou altogether.
Only a total transformation of society can guarantee and extend gains made by workers in struggle. Militant trade unionism must be combined with a political struggle for working class power I am supporting Benn and Heffer to get the Labour Party back on the road to socialist policies. Instead of Kinnock who is attempting to outdo Thatcher with his talk about shares. While you shouldn't have any illusions in Benn and Heffer producing major changes they will begin to open up the debate and get us on the right road so that we can win people back to socialist ideas. At present with every day of the Kinnock-Hattersley leadership it becomes less of a socialist party: Richard Moore, Vice Chair, Metropolitan South Branch NCU.
and control of society as a whole.
That is why we need to build a new leadership in the unions that will not only give wholehearted support to workers in struggle but will take those struggles tọ the political arena and will make them part of the fight to transform the Labour Party.
Scan page 14
the NHS delpsie rlife n bend o