The retreat from socialism
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The labour movement has retreated a long way ideologically in recent years. The new 'values document' by Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley sums it up.
Despite some amendments, and despite the face-saving device of adding Clause Four of the Labour Party constitution — calling for 'common ownership of the means of production' — to the document as an appendix, the document abandons any idea of socialism as something radically different from capitalism.
'Socialism', as defined by Kinnock and Hattersley, may have a few more utilities in public ownership than the Tories would wish - but it would not renationalise all that the Tories have privatised let alone bring new sectors into public ownership. It may have a higher level of spending on public services than the Tories would wish - but it would not even completely restore the cuts that the Tories have made since 1979.
It would try to reduce unemployment, but it would renounce any attempt at a comprehensive planned economy to guarantee decent jobs for all. It would get rid of the worst of the Tories' anti-union laws, but it would not even try to restore the balance of legal power between workers and employers to what it was in 1979, let alone go for workers' control to replace the employers.
In short, this 'socialism' would be a version of the Tories' system, only run with less ruthlessness and spite.
On 23 March Labour's National Executive defeated an amendment from Tony Benn which sought to add to the 'values document' a commitment that 'the commanding heights of the economy be brought into social ownership' Logic and reason show less ever for socialists to abandon or water down our opposition to the profit economy of capitalism and our support for a planned economy under workers' control. Capitalism is in terrible chaos all over the world.
In the 1950s and early 1960s Labour 'revisionists' used to argue that modern Our constituency has already sent off a message of support because we think it is important that there is a leadershp contest. Not because of the personalities of Neil Kinnock, Roy Hattersley, Tony Benn or Eric Heffer, but because we think it is important to have the arguments about the way forward for the Labour Party — whether that is going to be market forces socialism or as we believe, a working class socialist alternative. That's why I am supporting Benn and Heffer.
I will be pushing for local events to involve the full membership of the party in discussing who we will be supporting and the reasons behind that support. It is important it isn't left to personalities.
Lol Duffy, Chair, Wallasey CLP.
capitalism had purged itself of the system's inherent drive to produce slumps, create unemployment and make for poverty and inequality. The socialist aim of a free, equal, secure society could be achieved by, modifying capitalişm.
Nobody argues that today. The defenders of capitalism just say that stability, full employment, and equality are impossible. We 'can't afford' even to attempt them. They are utopian goais.
So it is admitted that capitalism cannot allow us to achieve our aims. Yet socialism is not even tried!
The bad experience of the Stalinist states of the USSR, Eastern Europe and China is no justification for this. These states were never socialist. Marxists explained long ago that a bureaucratic command economy, without workers democracy, is not only brutal but inefficient and unproductive - sometimes less efficient and productive than market capitalism.
It does not follow that the old system of market capitalism already discredited for anyone who cares to study history by the decades and centuries of suffering it has imposed on humanity, should be defended! Where the bureaucrats of Eastern Europe have gone in most enthusiastically for market economics — as in Hungary and Yugoslavia — the consequences are the same as socialists have always predicted: unemployment, inflation, inequality and insecurity.
Logic and reason do not count for much with the new Labour 'revisionists'. They just reflect and rationalise a mood - the mood of demoralisation, despair and defeatisin which the Tories' triumphs have created in the labour movement. The chaos, inhumanity, and brutality of capitalism has thus become a force pushing the labour movement's leaders to accept capitalism!
Whatever arguments there can be among the supporters of Tony Benn and Eric Heffer about exactly what socialism will be and how we will get there, the contest for the Labour Party leadership is undoubtedly, and above all, an attempt to put on the agenda of the labour movement the idea of scrapping capitalism and replacing it by a new sort of society.
That idea is the key to reviving the labour movement. It is even the key to success in workers' immediate battles on jobs, wages, and conditions — for it is the only answer to Thatcher's cry that "There is No Alternative'