Why By Tony Benn
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
We have already put out the Aims Objectives of the campaign.
A crisis of representation is developing Britain as party politics are being realised from the top towards a general acceptance of things as they are, denying the existence of any alternative.
Mrs Thatcher has set out to really reestablish the Tory Party in her own image -harsh, repressive, unjust, centralising and strengthening the power of the state to silencr and crush all dissent and destroy all opposition.
Meanwhile a succession of Labour leaders beginning with Gaitskell have tried to change the nature of the Labour Party by weakening its links with the unions and diluting its socialism, in an unsuccessful attempt to win the middle ground. This process is now being advanced again in the name of the new realism': But, in fact, the middle ground of British polities has virtually disappeared with the collapse of the Liberal-SDP Alliance and the dissolution of the Liberal Party as it has merged with the old Labour right and has split again.
These developments have been hailed as marking the death of socialism. Actually they have created a huge vacuum in British politic: filled by sterile arguments about which inagitation against Health Service cuts is continuing. A poll before the Budget showed that only 6 per cent of voters wanted tax cuts rather than more money for the NHS, and some 92 per cent wanted more money for the Health Service.
Another poll showed a majority of the population supporting the striking nurses.
The Education Reform Bill is going through Parliament. A poll last June showed 55 per cent in favour of its plan for schools to opt out of local authority control. By this January, only 18 per cent supported this idea. 62 percent were agianst a national written test for seven year old schoolchildren.
The huge waiting list for council housing - in many area, the waiting list means waiting forever - are proof that the Tories' plan to cut back council housing run counter to the needs and wishes of millions. Where Tory councils have tried to push through Government policy in advance — as in Westminster, where they plan to sell off half the council's housing stock as quick as they can — they have aroused fierce opposition.
Previous Tory attempts to revive the private landlord, in the late '50s led to a mass outcry against 'Rachmanism' (profiteering slum landlords) and the ignominious end of 13 years in office for the Tories.
Clause 28/29 of the Local Government Bill, which threatens all facilities for lesbians and gays under the pretext of a ban on 'promoting homosexuality' has aroused the biggest demonstrations ever in this country for lesbian and gay rights. There is widespread opposition to the Tories' attacks on civil liberties on many other fronts.
The Ford workers' victory, the Pare Democracy itself is being undermined and destroyed as the Establishment sets out to im. pose a new tyranny of the powerful against all its critics, creating a crisis of representation leaving millions of people without a real choice of policies or any voice in deciding their own future.
What we need is a deep and serious discussion about the future and that everyone should be allowed to hear the case for peace and non-alignment, full employment, better public services, common ownership and industrial democracy, devolution and effective local government, social justice, equal rights, stronger environmental safeguards, and major reforms in the structure of the state to end secrecy and the corruption of patronage.
These are what Labour should be arguing for instead of peddling the stale old policies that led to the defeat of so many previous Labour governments.
Those are the issues on which the 1988 leadership election is going to be launched, a part of the campaign for socialism, appealing for the widest possible public support.
We are not prepared to accept that 'There Is No Alternative'. There are two TINAs really. There is the Tory TINA and the Labour TINA; and there is no alternative in effect to the views of two people.
At the moment the campaign, is'to identify what everybody feels and open it up, and through that gap put forward different proposals.
• Look at the NUT vote today — they have turned down the executive on this £42,000 g year job for Doug McAvoy. Look at the seamen, the carworkers, the NHS -tenacious battle by the P&O seafarers, and the strikes by and in support of the health workers (effectively defying Tory anti-union laws) show that trade union power is not finished Strikes and trade unionism have declined. But closer analysis shows that this decline is more or less entirely a product of manufacturing business closing down or moving to new areas. In the public services, strikes and trade unionism have, on average, increased.
And the Ford strike suggests that the recent fall in unemployment, limited though it is, has put a floor under the decline of trade unionism in manufacturing industry. When companies are taking new workers on, even in small numbers rather than sacking staff, then workers feel more confident.
Much has been written and said about the ideological grip of "Thatcherism' Socialist Org PO Box 823, 01.639 7967 Editor: John Typesetting: 358 1344. wherever you look there is now a mood of resistance beginning to develop, but that is not reflected at the top.
Parliament is out of touch. In a way, by supporting the people who are in struggle you are giving them confidence and that will clearly encourage them to do more; in return you are hoping to provide a voice for them that has been muffled if not absent.
Many people on the left argue that socialist ideas in the British working class have been swamped by the tide of market economics and dog-eat-dog consumerism.
There is no hard evidence for this. Detailed opinion surveys suggest that most people's attitudes have shifted, if anything, slightly to the left during the Thatcher years. Workers' confidence has been sapped by unemployment, by successive defeats, and by the feebleness. of the labour movement's leadership. That lack of confidence explains the Tories' triumphs. But it is something that can change — and change quite rapidly in the right circumstances.
There is plenty of inflammable material to raise a fire of protest against the Tories — given leadership.
That is why everyone in the labour movement who wants to fight the Tories must back Benn and Heffer.
aniser nun Iber London S :15 O'Mahony Upstream (TU).
Published by Socialist Organiser, Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Printed by Press Link Internatio (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Scan page 5
Rebild The height of the miners' strike. Photo: John Harris (IFL) uild the left Since 1983 the Party has been moving increasingly to the right. There is a greater concentration of power in the hands of the leadership and the National Executive has, to a large extent, been down-graded.
Now they plan to change the character of the Party Conference, step by step, so that the Party at grassroots level will not be determining policy.
And there has been retreat after retreat. The most blatant retreat is on the Common Market. Whatever you might think about this new policy, it has never been redefined and discussed by Party Conference — the Labour Party has just been slid and manoeuvred into a total change. Changes are also being made in the Party's attitude to public ownership, the nuclear bomb and a whole series of other It is time that this was changed. The drift away from basic socialist policies must be reversed.
It's all very well saying we want a nice friendly discussion in the Party. Certainly, se sant a friendly discussion. But the Comes Group felt that the best way to *I *z5 : soncretise it, to spotlight the mira sces by a contest for the Leader By Eric and the Deputy Leader.
Now the so-called 'soft left' and the centre have got to make their minds up. Are they really left wing? Do they want the Labour Party to be a socialist party which goes out and fights for working class politics? Or have they now abandoned all socialist ideas?
We are standing on a programme defined by the Campaign Group. It contains a number of important points. We want:
*an extension of public ownership.
*the restoration and development of the rights of the trade unions.
* All out opposition to racism.
*Greater democracy; the abolition of the House of Lords.
*A restoration of local democracy and an extension of local authority rights.
*Women to have genuine equality.
*The labour movement has got to support all those who are underdogs in one way or another, or who, like lesbians and gays, are being persecuted.
* A different international policy — one of 'realignment' and getting out of NATO.
*The abolition all *A move away from nuclear power so that nuclear weapons cannot be restarted again.
*We think Labour must have a much more realistic attitude towards Eastern Europe. At the same time, of course, we defend the democratic rights of all the people in Eastern Europe. We oppose dictatorship in Chile and in other parts of the world. We fight on behalf of those who are fighting for their liberation.
These are the issues we believe we have got to go out and fight for in the course of this campaign.
Why a contest now? Much of what I have been describing is not new. They have been going on for a long time and some comrades and I myself have spoken out against them.
As with everything else, you have to take tactical considerations into account.
If we had stood before the general election, and the election had then been lost, they would have said Labour lost because the left-wing Campaign Group put up candidates. We didn't. It was not because of us that the election was lost. In fact, most Campaign Group members increased their votes.
The election was in June. If we had put La candidate immediately afterwards Par 3
Scan page 6
there would not have been time for proper consideration and organisation of a campaign before last year's October conference.
This year is the right time. There are three, perhaps tour years before the next election, so there is not much mileage in accusations of rocking the boat although of course they will still accuse us of it. But people know that there have been elections in the past. Wilson challenged Gaitskell. Nye Bevan challenged different people at different times. In fact, if you look at the record you find a challenge to the leadership on average about once every three or four years.
I cannot understand why the present leadership has reacted so heatedly to the fact of this eleciton.
This is the year when it is important to begin. Maybe next year there will be another campaign, and maybe there will be different left candidates. This year we begin to break the logjam. It is raising the whole question of the leadership and the fact of a contest is making all sorts of people face up to defining their attitudes to what is going on in the Labour Party.
Many predict that we are unlikely to get more than 25% of the vote. Obviously we are out to win, but we are concerned with other things as well.
The campaign can help organise the left, all different sections of the left, throughout the Party, into a more cohesive political grouping, which recognises that we have more in common with each other than we have differences. If they believe in socialism they will work together. That Will be a really important spin-oft from the campaign.
The campaign will also help to mobilise and hearten many people who have voted Labour in the past — good socialists who are getting a bit disillusioned. Nye Bevan's campaign in the 1950s helped to keep millions of workers in the Labour Party at the very moment when they were getting pretty fed up with things. They felt that here were the basic, compassionate views of the Labour Party coming up again, expressed again, and that serious people were organising again to fight for them. That will happen this time, too.
I went to Bristol to do a housing meeting on Friday evening. Going down in the train people — strangers - were coming up to me saying they thought it was quite right to stand. Then at the meeting itself, although I never raised the question because I was there to speak about housing, people came up and said the decision was good. Then, coming back again on the less crowded train, people were still coming up to me — not all Labour Party members — saying that it was absolutely the right thing to do, that it was about time it was done. Those who say that we do not represent anything are in for a big surprise.
Now the Campaign Group should set about organising the campaign, both nationally and locally. What should we do?
We are going to have to produce publications explaining our aims and objectives, and get them to all the CLPs. I think there should be a series of rallies in the main centres throughout the country. At these rallies we should involve the local parties and the local supporting groups. Those who come to the rallies can then be our supporters in their own localities.
I think we will have the time to cover most of the urban centres, and then people can come in from outside to hear what we have to say Pare 4 I hope this will give a boost to the book I wrote. Tony Benn goes on about it being our bible in this situation because he says the book says it all. That can be well used. We will also have to think in terms of a pamphlet. And the Campaign News will have to be effectively used.
In the 1981 Deputy Leadership campaign there were a lot of big rallies. In places they were comparable to the rallies witnessed in the 1945 general election. But there was a problem with the trade unions and the unions were decisive.
What we should aim at is to try to get proper discussions in every trade union so that the issues are fully debated. What are the issues in the unions?
*The attitude that the Party must have to trade union legislation.
*Where the Labour Party stands on the struggles of workers in industry, in the National Health Service, the miners, the *What the Party should say to the -disgraceful — attempt to get a low-paid agreement by one union from Ford management.
All these matters can be properly debated. We will develop the campaign in the constituencies and then alongside it, and as part of it, we will campaign in the trade unions.
It seems likely that a number of trade unions, and also CLPs, will have an individual membership ballot to determine their attitude in the election.
I have never been against individual membership ballots. But if they are going to be held then our views have to be properly circulated as well as other people's views. An equal number oi words in a union journal, or views circulated to all their members. I think that would be a good thing. Representatives of both sides should speak at union conferences.
I stood in the leadership election in 1983 ast had big insidas in Neil Kinnock. the situation is different but there are some lessons to be learned.
We had a rather ramshackle campaign. A lot of people — like Socialist Organiser - rallied and did what they could. But there was no real financial backing. I think financial backing should come from the party itself. It should not be left to the candidates to finance the campaign, Tech right to stand as people aye as machine behind them. I raised this myself after the 1983 campaign but it got 'lost' So we are still in the same situation today.
What ought to be done this time is we should have more than a national group meeting and working on the campaign. We need people in each main urban area working together as a team, forming a support group. That is one of the main lessons I would learn.
We need support groups in different unions as well, although union members will be connected with what is happening in each area. Perhaps the Broad Lefts in each union can play a role. I hope they will be supporting us, and I am sure that in most cases they will.
The initial reaction to the announcement that Tony and I would be standing was surprising. I do not think people should react in that way. We have the rules; we are entitled to contest. If you are the leader, you should simply say: they are entitled to do so and it will be a choice between their views and ours. Unfortunately it did not come over like that. Now they are talking about the ideological debate, and that, of course, is right.
This is the point at which the left begins to reorganise itself and starts to rally. I made the point at the time of the Chesterfield Conference that the left needs to do more than just sit around talking about things. I floated the idea of going back to the old Socialist League type-organisation which had existed during the 1930s.
Out of this should emerge something of that kind. Because even if we are defeated in this election, they will not defeat socialism. You cannot wipe it away. Even in countries where the right wing have got firm control of the party — in Germany, Italy and so on — they have not got rid of socialism. Maybe for a period it is in reteat. But the very concept of socialism, of workers' struggle, cannot just be swept aside. As long as capitalism is there the working class will be there and so will socialism.
That is my reply to the kind of statement now being put out by Kinnock and Hattersley, that a victory by them will put the Party's seal of approval on their kind of politics for a very long time, and finally decide which direction the Party is going to take.
Certainly, this is a very serious debate about the future of the Party, and the direction in which it is going.
If they do win, then I trust they will not talk in terms of people having to 'toe the line'. If it comes to that you are no longer a democratic socialist party. We are not going to accept that. Win or lose, it will not stop the arguments, the discussions, socialist ideas. There has always been constant discussion within the Party - that is the essence of socialist politics, socialist democracy.
I was chucked out of the Communist Party over 40 odd years ago for not agreeing to that sort of thing. I have always thought that one of the great things about the Labour Party, for all its faults, has been that in general there has been open and frank and free discussion.
Finally, this is my message to comrades inside the Party who are heartened by the Campaign Group's decision to contest the leadership and deputy-leadership.
You should be mobilising throughout the entire labour movement - in your union branches and Labour Party wards and GMCs. Organise now to make sure we get the biggest possible vote for the socialist policies we are putting forward.
Scan page 7
support
----- pull-quotes -----
NUP NURSES