Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Harrow NUT Trade unionists snou celebrate the reinstatement…]

Socialist Organiser no. 351, 31 March 1988 · scan p. 10 · Joanna Cain · about 459 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Harrow NUT Trade unionists snou celebrate the reinstatement ( the expelled and suspende members of the Inner Londo Teachers' Association (ILTA)

While NUT leaders are cuttir back on staff and on unic democracy in the interests 4 of economy, no expense was spared the courts to attack individu militants.

For once the courts worke against the right wing and forc the union leaders to make a u-tur Does this mean that using the cour in labour movement disputes justified? We think not.

In the vast majority of cases tf courts will work against the le Otherwise they would not 1 bourgeois courts. Also there is heavy price for going to court, w or lose.

In this particular instance t/ first result of Mike Loseley's i junction last year was to sti debate on the conference flo about the undemocratic trickery the Executive. We could do 1 more than hold fringe meetings al distribute leaflets outside the co ference hall.

More generally, to focus on t courts for a decision is to limit cal paigning in the wider labour mor ment. We can end up waiting for court decision instead of directi all our campaigning energies with the movement. aramant Could a campaign within the movement have won in this case? We do not know. But we do know NUT — not by trusung on tne bids" the hine ed lottery of judges' decisions.

The wider principle is that we should not bring the bourgeois courts into the affairs of the labour movement. Unions and the Labour Party should settle internal disputes independently of the state.

Union leaders are often working for the bourgeoisie, but it is up to union members to settle scores with them, not the agents of the ruling The reinstatement of the ILTA 8 has passed unnoticed by many members of the union. They were not reinstated as the result of popular opinion inside the NUT.

Finally, the incident must be put into the context of the struggle inside the NUT generally. The reinstatement is a victory because the attempt by the righi wing/Broad Left to carve oul leading London left wingers has, ir this case, been stopped.

But that grouping still has a tight grip on the Executive, despite the gains made by the leit in the recen elections. They might be scared ol the left's challenge, but they are stil much stronger - strong enough tr feel confident to mount a direct at tack on union democracy and hold off demands for real action agains the government.

Court victories should not diver us from the basic task of changing the relation of forces within thi anion

----- pull-quotes -----

that campaigning in the movement is the way the left will win in the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 351

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →