Palestine: two nations, two states!
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The uprising by Palestinians living in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, which began in December, has pushed the Palestinian question once more to the forefront of world Over 100 Palestinians have been killed, and many more injured. In an attempt to repress the revolt, the Israeli military authorities have detained hundreds of Palestinians; some have been deported.
The origins of the conflict lie in the uprooting of most of the original Arab-speaking population of Palestine when Israel was set up in 1948. The refugees live in camps - like the one in Gaza that Tory MP David Mellor described as an "affront to civilised values."
In the Israeli-Arab war of 190/, Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza — creating more refugees and imposing military rule on more than one million Arabs.
What is the answer? Israel should WHETTON'S get out of the West Bank and Gaza and allow the Palestinians living dependent state side by side with In any negotiations, the Palestinians should have the right to choose their own representatives -rather than have others (the Jordanian regime or Israeli nominees, for example speak for them.
And the clear representative of the vast majority of Palestinians is the Palestine Liberation Organisation, the PLO. Shimon Peres, Israel's Foreign Minister, recently admitted that if elections were held now in the occupied territories, the PLO would win nearly all of them.
Beyond that, what! A hard-ane Palestinian nationalist demand is the restoration of all of pre-1948 Palestine to the Palestinians. The problem is that over three million Jews live in that area now, and most of them were born there.
From a democratic — never mind socialist - point of view, those a liability?
defeated this year, that should not atfect the main idea - regular elections and an on-going campaign of getting socialism put back into the British political scene.
It is too early to say yet how the campaign will be run in the NUM. Last time round, when Benn stood against Healey for the deputy leadership, it was certainly raised at branches. I can also remember marching through Mansfield with an NUM banner saying, in large letters, "The only good deputy - Tony Benn'. There was a lot of rank and file feeling then. He came within a hair's breadth of winning then.
Even Hattersley is saying that it is about the future direction of the Labour Party. Look at the way the present leadership have been behaving. At the 'Labour Listens' event I raised the question of Clause 3, which defines Party membership, and the question of those who are still holding Party cards although they campaigned against us at the last election - the likes of Lynk and Prendergast. UDM members are breach of Clause 3, which requires membership of a bona fide trade union recognised by the TUC. Kinnock's reply to me then was that Clause 3 a "mere technicality"
So Clause 3 is a "mere technicality";
Clause 7 is a "distraction". How long before Clause 4 is seen as a "liability'"?
There have been attempts to take Clause 4 off the agenda in the past. At the last NEC meeting Kinnock and Hattersley presented their new document on Party aims and objectives. Benn and Skinner tried to get Clause 4 inserted in that but were defeated by something like 22-4.
Paul Whetton is a cotes NUM, Notts. Israeli Jews have every there.
Unless the Jews are driven out, a 'Palestinian' , that is, an Arab state, is not possible in all of Palestine: it a single state were to be created incorporating all of pre-1948 Palestine (what is now the occupied territories and Israel itself), it would have to be a joint IsraeliJewish/Palestinian-Arab state.
But is such a state possible? The long-term aim of the PLO, supported by many on the left, is for a "democratic, secular state' in all of Palestine. But unfortunately, this is unobtainable.
Where two distinct peoples or nations exist, with more-or-less distinct territory, it is very difficult simply to merge them into one. More precisely, two peoples won't simply merge unless they no longer see themselves as distinct nations. Socialists certainly want people to put national identity aside — but we recognise that the best way to overcome feelings of nationality is not just to denounce them or insist that people forget about them.
The 'secular democratic state' is, in effect, a programme merger of two nations. So what does it mean?
Either it depends upon convincing the Israeli Jewish nation that it shouldn't want to be a separate nation — in which case it will take a very long time to achieve and is no answer to the existing plight of the Palestinians.
Or it does not depend on convincing the Jews at all. They should be forced into a single state. But even if that were possible, its result would not be a state where everyone lived together happily: It would be imposed by war. Socialists don't always oppose wars, but we do oppose wars to subjugate nations.
A lot of socialists argue that the Israelis have no national rights that is, no right to a state — because they are the oppressors. Only oppressed nations, like the Palestinians, they say, have the right to self-determination.
Our fighting fund
With only one day to go on our fund drive for €10,000, the tally stands at £9244.84 Our thanks to everyone who has contributed. But there is only time for a short rest before fund-raising has to start again: we'll need another €10,000 by 30 June!
- Send money to SO, PO Box 823 London SE15 ANA. presses another now, doesn't mean they can be oppressed in turn in future.
The democratic and socialist answer is for each nation to have its own state.
On this democratic basis, the working class of both nations might be able to unite. It needs to be tied to other issues - the opposition to all Israel chauvinism and discrimination against the Arabs, as well as social and economic questions. A workers' movement that fights on all these fronts will be able to fight for socialism. Socialism is the ultimate answer - but for socialism to be possible, the national question that divides the working class needs to be sorted out.
----- pull-quotes -----
there the right to self-determination - that is, the right to form an in-