Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Sell-out or d

Socialist Organiser no. 351, 31 March 1988 · scan p. 7 · about 527 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

After over five weeks on strike, the 6,000 hourly paid Land Rover workers have voted to return to work. The recommendation came from the full-time officials and was backed by the Solihull Joint Shop Stewards' Committee.

A mass meeting on Wednesday 23rd was expected to endorse the deal, but in fact broke up in confusion with some workers accusing the stewards of selling out. However, a ballot held over the weekend resulted in an overwhelming vote to accept.

Was the deal a sell-out? Some, like the SWP, have no hesitation in describing it as such. And some Land Rover workers consider that their five weeks of sacrifice have been a wasted effort.

Certainly the final deal, involving the phased consolidation of a t3.05 attendance allowance into the basic rate, 1s only a very marginal improvement on the original offer, and involves no "new money"

But the Land Rover shop stewards were of the unanimous opinion that the deal was the best that could be achieved, short of a protracted dispute lasting at least another month — and they judged that the membership could not hold out that long, without the trickle of scabs crossing the picket lines turning into a flood. Under those circumstances, management would quite possibly have withdrawn even their existing offer and union organisation at Solihull would have been devastated.

The stewards are probably right in their assessment of the situation that faced them by the fifth week, and many of those who now shout "sell-out" do not seem to appreciate the serious difficulties and dangers that faced the Solihull stewards. The fact is that the strike was deadlocked, and there was a very real risk of a large number of workers crossing picket lines.

But this situation need not have arisen. Mass picketing of the gates could have been organised (over 1,000 turned out on the first day of the strike) and regular mass meetings could have kept the strikers united and actively involved in the progress of the dispute. Instead, the shop stewards allowed the officials to limit picketing to six per gate (additional pickets were described as with work from striking UBOs.

The six staff at Camden A,UBO were threatened with compulsory transfer after management claimed a drop in the unemployment register (casuals at the office were also sacked). Staffing in the UBOs is at an all-time low. Casuals are used in place of permanent workers.

So why did the strike ballot go down? The DE Section Executive Committee (SEC) undoubtedly played a role. The always be counted upon to put the dampener on any industrial action by rank and file workers.

However, despite the narrow defeat in the ballot, the mood amongst workers in DE is good. The strike vote, although lost, was an encouraging one.

•There is a feeling that the will to strike is definitely there. This needs to be built on and organised by the DE SEC and the NEC because the dispute will not stop here.

Workers are now negotiating return to work on Thursday.

----- pull-quotes -----

SA ballot lost

DE SEC is controlled by the "new realists" of Broad Left '84, who can

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 351

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →